(i) to note the Legal position. (ii ) To carry out a full investigation to find a suitable partner to convert the currently derelict Sutton Green Lavatories into a café with an internal toilet open to the public before committing to any renovation work funding. (iii) To agree that the toilet block should not be demolished.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
It was reported to the Sutton Local Committee on 27th February 2008 that the public conveniences at Sutton Green had been closed to the public since 2003, due to the vandalism and other antisocial behaviour that they used to attract when they were open. However there is local interest in the possibility of re-opening the building as a café with toilets to improve the amenity of this area of Village Green. External Legal Counsel had previously recommended that the building be demolished in order to preserve the land as if the toilets had never existed.
Recommendations
I recommend the Committee to:
1. Note the legal position as expressed in this report.
2. Investigate proposals for the re-opening of this building as a café with toilets.
1.1The land on which the former public conveniences are situated is not in the Council’s ownership but is registered Village Green. Although the last known reputed owner was a [name removed] (Lord of the Manor) attempts to contact him or any successor have been unsuccessful.
1.2The public conveniences were closed to the public in 2003 as a budget saving measure due to ongoing vandalism and other antisocial behaviour which occurred prior to this time.
1.3As the law relating to Village Greens is obscure and complex, the advice of external Counsel was sought during 2007. The advice received back was that the erection of a building on registered Village Green was a criminal offence and always had been. Therefore on the basis of his advice the three possible options were:
1.3.1 to leave the building as it is and maintain the status quo;
1.3.2 to put the building back as a public toilet;
1.3.3 to demolish the building and restore it to grass.
1.4I have reviewed this external advice and the documented history of these former toilets (so far as that documentation exists), but do not accept Counsel’s conclusion that the building cannot be reused in a way which is beneficial for the public enjoyment of this valuable green space.
1.5To me the key to possible reuse lies in Section 7, Ministry of Housing and Local Government Provisional Order Confirmation (Greater London Parks and Open Spaces) Act 1967 which states that a local authority may in any open space (amongst other things):
“(d) Provide meals and refreshments of all kinds to sell to the public;
(e) provide and maintain swings, platforms, screens, chairs, seats, lockers, towels, costumes and any apparatus, appliances, equipment or conveniences necessary or desirable for persons resorting to the open space;
(f) erect and maintain for or in connection with any purpose relating to the open space such buildings or structures as they consider necessary or desirable including (without prejudice through the generality of this paragraph) buildings for the accommodation of keepers and other persons employed in connection with the open space. “
1.6Furthermore Section 8(1) of the same Act states that, “a local authority may, subject to such terms and conditions as to payment or otherwise as they may consider desirable, grant to any person the right of exercising any of the powers conferred upon the Local Authority by Article 7 and let to any person, for any of the purposes mentioned in that article, any building or structure erected or maintained, and any part of an open space set apart or enclosed, pursuant thereto”.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.