CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
London Borough of Sutton
The Executive, Tuesday 5 July 2011 at 10.00am

Sutton Business Improvement District

Decided Executive 1 paper

The Executive decided this item on Tuesday 5 July 2011. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item649

Resolved

That arrangements be made to re-run the Sutton Town Centre BID ballot in June 2012.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting. Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Sutton's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to The Executive

Page 153 Agenda Item 11

London Borough of Sutton The Executive : 5 July 2011

Report of the Executive Head of Planning, Transport and Highways Sutton Business Improvement District (BID)

Ward Sutton Central Author(s) and Contact Phone Number(s): Location: Mandy Cherrington Head of Business Development and Regulation 020 8770 5530 Area Served: Sutton Town Centre Executive Councillor: Cllr Jayne McCoy

Summary Sutton Town Centre marginally lost a majority vote in the recent Business Improvement District (BID) ballot. The outcome and the process have been reviewed; this report sets out the issues to be taken into consideration when deciding whether to go for a re-run. Recommendations That the Executive approves the decision to re-run the BID ballot in June 2012.

1. Background The Sutton Town Centre business BID vote, publicised on Monday 14th March 2011 revealed that the BID failed to obtain the two majority votes required. A majority was obtained by numbers 81 to 70 but lost the aggregate business rateable value by £1,335,298. The initial decision to run a BID was instigated and driven by the Town Centre Partnership and despite the recent result, the Partnership remains convinced that the overwhelming benefits to the town centre merit another attempt. The business led BID steering group also share the Partnership’s commitment to the benefits of a BID and unanimously agree to support another run. 1.1 Summary of the Ballot result This was a closely contested ballot with a split vote and a relatively low turnout. The votes by numbers were successful but not when measured by the aggregate rateable values: Turnout = 31% Votes by numbers of businesses = 151 votes cast Yes votes = 81 (53.6%) No votes = 70 (46.4%) Votes by rateable value - The total aggregate rateable value of the valid vote cast £16,386,302 Committee Report - BID - Next steps 30032011 v2 1 Agenda Item 11 Page 154

Yes aggregate = £7,525,502 (45.9%) No aggregate = £8,860,800 (54.1%)

1.2Why we failed to achieve a yes vote? There are three critical success factors attached to successful BIDS; The Business Case, the Proposition and the Process. The Business Case for Sutton town centre successfully identified the issues important to local business, however our evaluation showed that the BID Proposition while appealing to small business hence the “yes “vote, did not clearly demonstrate real benefit from the cost outlay to larger businesses. Finally the Process: this must be delivered in a manner that will generate interest and support, in turn this leads to a successful ballot turn out. Secondary influences There were two key secondary factors that inevitably influenced the final vote. 1. It is acknowledged that BIDs are most successful where there is already an existing business network in place – there is no such network in Sutton town centre. Historically Sutton town centre businesses have not engaged with each other or the council, they are part of the Town Centre Partnership but rarely attend the meetings or participate in any discussions or activities . 2. The present economic climate particularly among retail, eateries, public houses, clubs and the leisure sector places a great emphasis on the “bottom line“; paying an additional BID levy is seen as a further cost. Two other ballots have also recently failed (Keswick and Gainsborough) in both cases the ballot has been marginally lost on the rateable value count. This trend may be the result of large multiples adopting blanket policies to vote “no” regardless of the strength of the Proposal.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Sutton Bid Draft Committee Report: BID: Next steps 060511 v3 PB amendsReport 96 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

9 of 12 attended
JP
Julia PenfoundCouncil Staff, expected
SB
Councillor Sean BrennanChair, present
RD
Councillor Ruth DombeyVice-Chair, present
DC
Councillor Dave CallaghanExecutive Councillor, present
JD
Councillor John DrageExecutive Councillor, present
CH
Councillor Colin HallExecutive Councillor, present
KJ
Councillor Kirsty JeromeExecutive Councillor, present
JM
Councillor Jayne McCoyExecutive Councillor, present
CS
Councillor Colin StearsExecutive Councillor, present
GT
Councillor Graham TopeExecutive Councillor, apologies
SW
Councillor Simon WalesExecutive Councillor, present
RS
Richard ShortmanSecretary, expected

On this subject at Sutton

Search all
  1. Sutton Business Improvement DistrictThis decision
  2. Sutton Decentralised Energy Network (SDEN) Business Plan and BudgetApproved
  3. Sutton Living Limited (SLL) 2026/27 Budget & Ten Year Business PlanApproved
  4. DM2024/01755 Sutton Business Park Restmor Way Hackbridge SM6 7AHAgreed
  5. Delivering Ambitious for Sutton: Housing, Economy and Business CommitteeNoted
  6. Sutton Living Ltd Business Plan and BudgetApproved

More from Sutton The Executive

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
8 May 2012 Advocacy Commissioning(i) To note the contents of the report and progress made to date in reviewing and realigning advocacy services to mee... Noted Open
8 May 2012 Domestic Violence - Strategic Options(i) That the proposals set out in paragraphs 4 to 6 in the report be endorsed; (ii) To agree to forward the report to... Agreed Open
8 May 2012 Review of Housing Allocations Policy and Development of a Tenancy Strategy( i ) That the draft revised housing allocations policy, as set out in Appendix 1 to the report, be approved and adop... Approved Open
8 May 2012 Sutton Housing Partnership Delivery Plan 2012/13To approve the Sutton Housing Partnership Delivery Plan for 2012/13. Approved Open
8 May 2012 Epsom and Ewell Borough Council Insurance Arrangements(i) To agree to the principle of the provision of insurance services to Epsom and Ewell Borough Council and to author... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies