Resolved
( i ) That whilst the assertion that targets were not set may be correct it does not reflect the compassion of the Council in following fairly and flexibly the advice of occupational health in not setting targets in this case, which in any event are not required by the Council’s procedure, and so the ground for appeal of procedural flaw is not upheld. (ii) That at the time of the decision to dismiss the appellant there was no evidence of a sustained improvement in the appellant’s attendance at work; and whilst the appellant has undergone a medical procedure since the previous hearing they have a number of other underlying medical conditions and there is no subsequent medical evidence that the appellant’s attendance at work was improving or would improve, and so the ground for appeal that there is up to date medical opinion is not upheld. (iii) That the dispute on a point of fact arose as a result of a misinterpretation at the previous hearing in relation to the effect of the appellant’s absence on the service and not the quality of her work, and so the ground that there is a dispute on a point of fact is not upheld. (iv) That at the time of the decision to dismiss, the appellant had been through a staged procedure during which they were given sufficient and reasonable opportunity, taking account of any disability, to reduce their sickness levels, and they were aware of the Council’s sickness absence target of no more than eight days; and in the light of that, the appellant’s sickness absence since 2006 and uncertainty about their attendance in the foreseeable future the ground of severity of the decision is not upheld. (v) That accordingly the decision that the appellant be dismissed be upheld.