Item4
Resolved
( i ) That the Committee heard evidence that the disciplinary hearing procedure was explained to the appellant, he was given sufficient time to present his case, the possibility of resuming on a second day was explained at the outset, and whilst the appellant was interrupted on some occasions it was to ensure the appellant followed the agreed procedure; however, the Committee has some concerns that the investigation procedure was insufficiently thorough and so the appeal on the ground of procedural flaw is therefore upheld. (ii) That whilst the appellant has appealed on the ground of dispute on points of fact there was insufficient evidence, because of the flawed investigation, to enable the Committee to reach a conclusion regarding that ground for appeal. (iii) That in view of the Committee’s concerns about the flawed investigation the decision that followed from it is not relevant and the appeal is therefore upheld and the appellant be reinstated.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.
Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk