Item486
Resolved
That the Committee’s unanimous decision is:- ( i ) That the allegations were presented clearly, and some were withdrawn subsequently; the appellant was able to call witnesses, was accompanied by his chosen representative and was not denied any specific documents relevant to the appeal; the Council employed an external, independent, qualified investigator; the disciplinary hearing was postponed to accommodate the appellant’s health needs; and the various references submitted by the appellant were taken into account; and therefore the ground that the Council did not follow its disciplinary procedure or the ACAS code is not upheld. (ii) That the relevant evidence was properly considered, leading to one of the allegations being dismissed at the disciplinary hearing, and a rationale for the decision to dismiss the appellant was given; the missing paragraph in the minutes referred to was an error that did not have any relevance, and the various errors referring to names and dates did not make any significant difference to the findings; the appellant had the opportunity to call other witnesses relevant to their case; and the alternative options to dismissal were carefully considered; and therefore the ground that the finding rested on flawed evidence is not upheld. (iii) That the volume of work, stress and lack of resources put forward by the appellant in mitigation were taken into account; and in view of the finding that the Council’s trust and confidence in the appellant had broken down the decision to dismiss was not unduly harsh. (iv) That in respect of allegations two and three, the disciplinary hearing reached a proper conclusion that insufficient robust action was ... view the full minutes text for item 486.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.
Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk