Resolved Officers be authorised to consult the Council tenants of 5-24 Beech Tree Place and the lessee (Crown Housing) of no.25, on the proposed closure of Beech Tree Place, on the basis that any residents who wish to remain, if the redevelopment takes place, will be guaranteed suitable accommodation for older people in the redevelopment resident feedback be reported to a future meeting of the Housing, Economy and Business Committee. in the event of the scheme closing, flats becoming empty be made available on an interim basis as temporary accommodation for compatible homeless households to whom the council owes a duty, subject to a property by property business case and risk assessment. in the event of the scheme closing, officers commission a report on the range of potential redevelopment options for Beech Tree Place and the wider allocated site for a future HEB Committee. in the event of proceeding with a decision to close the scheme, existing secure tenants be awarded priority rehousing status, including eligibility for statutory Home Loss and disturbance allowance payments, with the right to return where feasible. (Note : only resolutions 1 and 5 were subject to the requisition. )
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
1.1In accordance with committee procedure rule 23.4 Requisitions, Full Council is asked to consider a requisition relating to a decision made by the Housing, Economy and Business (HEB) Committee on 15 October 2018.
Recommendations
The Council is recommended to:
2.1Consider the requisition relating to resolutions 1 and 5 under item 28 Review of Beech Tree Place older persons housing scheme, considered by the HEB Committee on 15 October 2018.
Background
3.1The text of the requisition is set out below: Agenda Item 6d Page 42
“We wish to requisition this item for the following reasons: 1. At HEB, a guarantee amendment was made that stated residents removed from Beech Tree Place would have a guaranteed right of return. We believe that the remaining legal disclaimer makes this ‘guarantee’ worthless, and require it to be debated with legal advice available at Council. 2. At the HEB meeting, it emerged that so-called ‘Residents Charters’ that appeared to be proposed as part of the consultation process do not in fact exist at all. We believe it is wrong to progress to the forcible removal of residents when fully localised guidance on how to engage these residents sensitively and fairly does not exist as proposed. It was clear at the meeting that the Chair exposed officers to some awkwardness on this point alone. 3. We believe it is totally wrong for Regeneration Officers to be carrying out these ‘formal’ consultations. We believe social workers should be involved and consulted from the outset. The ‘informal’ consultations were clear in their intent, to remove the residents to allow for regeneration. The appendices where residents have commented on leaving their homes is evidence of this. This is insensitive and intimidatory for the residents concerned, as we have ascertained through personal visits.
The outcomes we are seeking are as follows: 1. A moratorium on the Beech Tree Place consultation and subsequent regeneration until a suitable localised ‘Residents Charter’ or such similar overarching guidance is produced that gives professionally-approved methods and processes to engage with residents, and which is fully endorsed by the HEB committee. 2. Urgent action to produce such localised guidance for dealing with vulnerable and other residents, based on local experiences and serious relocation issues faced in the past. 3. An acknowledgement that the undersigned value the council’s commitment to regeneration, but that regeneration cannot be hurried for the administration’s benefit at any human cost”.
4. Issues
4.1The process for considering requisitions is for the relevant chair to move the adoption of the minute of the decisions that have been requisitioned, which all members thus have an opportunity to debate and vote upon. The resolutions members are considering are: item 7 resolutions 2.1 and 2.5 as set out at Appendix A of this report.
5. Service Response
The Right to Return 5.1 At HEB Committee on 15th October the qualification to the right to return was removed, thereby making the commitment an absolute right of return. Should the closure proceed and regeneration proposals move forward, it is critical that the Council guarantees every existing resident a home on this site.
Residents’ Charters Page 43 Agenda Item 6d
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Review of Beech Tree Place older persons housing scheme: Appendix A, 25/09/2018 Housing, Economy and Business Committee, 15/10/2018 Housing, Economy and Business CommitteeAppendix
Review of Beech Tree Place older persons housing scheme: Report, 25/09/2018 Housing, Economy and Business Committee, 15/10/2018 Housing, Economy and Business CommitteeReport
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.