That the Outline Business Case for future regeneration of the St Nicholas Centre and associated Town centre sites attached at Appendix A to the report and the outcomes of the Town Centre engagement attached at Appendix B to the report be noted. That the Council pursues the recommended preferred option of a comprehensive mixed use scheme on the St Nicholas Centre which includes a new Civic Centre complex and to release the current Civic Centre site, Gibson Road Multi Storey Car Park and the vacant Secombe Theatre for disposal. That it be agreed to undertake a full procurement exercise which is compliant with the relevant Public Contract Regulations to select a preferred development partner of suitable standing. That it be agreed to receive a further report to the Committee to consider Officer's recommendations in relation to the outcome of the steps authorised by paragraph 3 above. That there be ongoing engagement and conversations with residents and all Councillors on the final proposals.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
Page 1 Agenda Item 12 7 November 2022 Agenda Item 12 Recommendations i) To note the Business Case for future regeneration of the St Nicholas Centre and associated Town centre sites attached at Appendix A and the outcomes of the Town Centre engagement attached at Appendix B.
Page 2 ii) To agree that the Council pursues the recommended preferred option of a comprehensive mixed use scheme on the St Nicholas Centre which includes a new Civic Centre complex and to release the current Civic Centre site, Gibson Road Multi Storey Car Park and the vacant Secombe Theatre for disposal.
iii) To agree to undertake a full procurement exercise which is compliant with the relevant Public Contract Regulations to select a preferred development partner of suitable standing.
iv) To agree to receive a further report to the Committee to consider Officer's recommendations in relation to the outcome of the steps authorised by paragraph iii) above Page 3 Background and Context
Agenda Item 12 Background: St Nicholas Centre Acquisition
Agenda Item 12 • 15 July 2021 S&R agreed to acquire the SNC and to develop a Regeneration Strategy within next 9-12 months • St Nicholas Centre purchased on 13 August 2021
Page 4 • Acquisition was made for regeneration purposes giving the Council full control of a key strategic asset (4.7 acre site) to support the Council’s ambitions for Sutton Town Centre as set out in Local Plan and Town Centre Master Plan • The risk if the asset was purchased by a private developer was that the development would not meet the council’s vision for the Town Centre. Management of St Nicholas Centre • Completing essential works to keep the centre operational and to increase accessibility • Offering flexible occupancy terms encourage new tenants and existing tenants to remain - but these are ‘meanwhile’ - not viable over the medium term.
Page 5 • Without significant investment systems and structure will continue to deteriorate with increasing breakdowns and failures - as well as high carbon consumptions.
Agenda Item 12 • Retail sector changed forever. National retailers demanding significant discounts with a shift in Landlord and Tenant relationships Agenda Item 12 Page 6 Outline Business Case What are the challenges we are addressing?
● High Street experiencing long term challenges and vacancy rates ● SNC mirrors the changing face of retail, collapse of anchor tenants ● Civic is not fit for purpose, difficult to access, costly to run, wasteful of energy, with increasing backlog of maintenance and inefficient space c10,000m2
Page 7 being used by less than 250 staff per day. ● The Council have control of SNC a key strategic site in the heart of the Town Centre ● The exam question LBS set: What is the best use of these assets to
Agenda Item 12 support the future of local residents and business? The future of
Agenda Item 12 Britain’s high street Local authorities around the UK are working up regeneration schemes alongside other property owners that fit
Page 8 declining shopping centres into wider plans to invest. A key strategy is melding retail together with homes, workspace and leisure facilities
Adapting shopping centres so they are not so heavily reliant on traditional retail to draw in customers. Wellbeing and gym facilities, cultural events and last-mile logistics space are potential options. Strategic development - Town Centre Masterplan The Regeneration Strategy has been informed by the Town Centre Masterplan that indicates that development should be framed around the following objectives to:
1. Curate and promote an attractive and distinctive identity for Sutton Town Centre;
Page 9 2. Increase the economic resilience of the town centre through the growth of a diverse and distinctive retail, dining, cultural and leisure offer; 3. Increase housing supply; 4. Promote an accessible town centre which is easy to get to and through by a
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.