AI summarySutton Strategy and Resources Committee agrees to lease Quarry Cottage in Seears Park to Yourspace.Sutton for up to 25 years, with about £2.5m of external investment and no capital cost to the council.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApproved
MoneyApproximately £2.5m external capital investmentCouncil receives no extra income above existing nursery rent
What happens nextStatutory advert and 28-day representation periodThen external valuation, final terms and lease grant
Who it affectsNot stated
What was decided
The committee delegated authority to the Director for Assets and Capital Delivery to approve lease terms for a long lease of Quarry Cottage to Yourspace.Sutton for up to 25 years, on best consideration terms supported by an external valuation and in consultation with the Monitoring Officer.
As the property is in public open space, a statutory advert will be published in local media for two consecutive weeks inviting representations before terms are agreed. Report P7, P9, P12
The council is acting as sole Trustee of the John Sears Park Trust, so the lease must align with the trust's charitable purposes. Report P11
Why
The cottage is vacant and derelict, and disposal will cut the council's vacant repairs, maintenance and holding costs while delivering a fully restored asset with no capital outlay. Report P4
Yourspace.Sutton will fund the renovation and running costs itself, estimated at about £15k per annum, removing financial risk from the council. Report P6
The proposal will modernise the property, introduce a community hub with a community garden and recycling programmes, and support the borough's net-zero objectives. Report P1
What happens next
Publish statutory notices in a local newspaper for two consecutive weeks and allow a 28-day period for representations or objections. Report P7, P9, P12
Obtain an external valuation to confirm best consideration reasonably obtainable, and consult the Monitoring Officer before completing the lease. Report P10, P11
If best consideration cannot be achieved, consider a shorter lease or seek Secretary of State consent for disposal under section 123 of the Local Government Act 1972. Report P14
The money
approximately £2.5m Net capital investment benefit to the site, funded externally by Yourspace.Sutton Report P4
£15k per annum Estimated renovation and running costs, to be met by Yourspace.Sutton Report P6
Options considered
Chosen: Grant a long lease of up to 25 years to Yourspace.Sutton, with external funding of restoration. Restores a derelict asset at no cost or risk to the council, supports charitable and net-zero aims, subject to best consideration and statutory consultation Report P1, P4, P6
Rejected: If best consideration cannot be achieved, grant a shorter lease. Listed as a fallback only if the best consideration test is not met Report P14
Rejected: If best consideration cannot be achieved, seek Secretary of State consent to dispose under S123 LGA 1972. Listed as a fallback only if the best consideration test is not met Report P14
Implications
Financial: Council avoids capital outlay and ongoing holding, repair and maintenance costs, while gaining a fully restored asset, but receives no extra income above the existing nursery rent. Report P4
Legal: Disposal powers are exercised under section 123 Local Government Act 1972 and the Charities Act 2011, with statutory advertising under section 122(2A) LGA 1972 and section 233(4) Town and Country Planning Act 1990. Report P7, P9, P10, P12
Risk: Project depends on Yourspace.Sutton securing external grant funding; if best consideration is not achieved a shorter lease or Secretary of State consent would be needed. Report P6, P14
Climate: Restoration will modernise the derelict property; the proposed hub will promote sustainable practice, a community garden and recycling, supporting the borough's net-zero objectives. Report P1
Equalities: Equalities Impact Assessment completed by the Director of Assets and Capital Delivery on 07/01/2026. Report P28
Other: Acting as sole Trustee of the John Sears Park Trust, the council must ensure the lease serves the trust's charitable purposes. Report P11
Who and where
Yourspace.Sutton, as incoming long leaseholder and developer of the hub Report P4, P6
Users of Sears Park public open space in Cheam, including the existing nursery tenant Report P4, P7, P9
The John Sears Park Trust, of which the council is sole Trustee Report P11
Local residents who may make representations during the statutory advert period Report P7, P9, P12
Timeline
07/01/2026: Legal comments from the Monitoring Officer and Equalities and Climate Impact Assessments completed Report P26, P28, P29
15/01/2026: Finance comments provided by the Director of Finance Report P25
16/02/2026: Strategy and Resources Committee considered and approved the delegation to grant the lease
Two consecutive weeks (future): Statutory notices to be published in a local newspaper advertising the intention to dispose of the open-space land Report P7, P9, P12
28 days (future, after notice): Period allowed for submission of representations or objections before terms are finalised Report P12
Up to 25 years (future): Length of the proposed long lease to Yourspace.Sutton once granted
Plain English for the jargon
Best consideration reasonably obtainable: The highest price or value that can reasonably be achieved for a council disposal, required for leases over 12 years under section 123 of the Local Government Act 1972.
Appropriation: Formal council process of changing the use or status of land it owns, here linked to open-space and planning purposes, subject to statutory advertising.
Yourspace.Sutton: A local organisation working with the health sector that will take the long lease and redevelop Quarry Cottage as a community hub.
John Sears Park Trust: The charity of which the London Borough of Sutton acts as sole Trustee and which owns or controls the Sears Park site.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item42
Resolved
That authority be delegated to the Director for Assets and Capital Delivery to approve the lease terms on the Council's behalf, as sole Trustee of the John Seear’s Park Trust, for the grant of a long lease of Quarry Cottage to Yourspace.Sutton for a term of up to 25 years on terms representing best consideration reasonably obtainable, such terms to be supported by an external valuation and in consultation with the Monitoring Officer.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
Page 257 Agenda Item 9 Proposed Lease of Quarry Cottage, Seears Park
Report Title Proposed lease of Quarry Cottage, Seears Park
Committee Strategy and Resources Committee
Meeting Date 16 February 2026
Chair Councillor Barry Lewis, Leader of the Council
Lead Member Councillor Sunita Gordon, Lead Member for Resources
Report From Richard Simpson, Strategic Director of Resources
Report Author(s) Thuso Selelo, Director for Assets and Capital Delivery
Ward(s) Affected Sutton West & East Cheam
Ambitious for Sutton Strong and fair economic growth; priorities An efficient and well run Council
Open/Exempt Open
Signed Date 29 January 2026
1 Summary
1.1 This report seeks approval to grant an agreement for lease and a long lease to Yourspace.Sutton to restore and redevelop Quarry Cottage in Seear’s Park. The proposal seeks to take advantage of an opportunity to transform a derelict park keeper’s residence, vacant since 1997, into a community wellbeing hub. This initiative supports strong and fair economic growth by creating a social enterprise hub and supports the desire to be an efficient and well run Council by converting a long term vacant and derelict asset into a productive and accessible community facility.
2 Recommendations
2.1 To delegate to the Director for Assets and Capital Delivery the authority to approve the lease terms on the Council's behalf, as sole Trustee of the John Seear’s Park Trust, for the grant of a long lease of Quarry Cottage to Yourspace.Sutton for a term of up to 25 years on terms representing best consideration reasonably obtainable, such terms to be supported by an external valuation and in consultation with the Monitoring Officer.
3 Background and Key Information
3.1 Seear’s Park was dedicated in trust by the will of John Seear, who died on 3 December 1912 to the Parish of Cheam. The will describes the land being granted as ‘the meadow
Report page 1 Agenda Item 9 Page 258 Proposed Lease of Quarry Cottage, Seears Park
… on the north side of land abutting upon Love Lane in the Parish of Cheam aforesaid known as Orchard Meadow and containing seven acres or thereabouts together with the cottage erected by me thereon and which meadow I have laid out as a park and enclosed with iron railings unto the Parish Council for the Parish of Cheam in the county of Surrey to be held by them for ever for the benefit of and as an open space and recreation ground for the inhabitants of the said Parish’. The Council is therefore the sole custodian and trustee of the charity and therefore makes all decisions which affect this park on behalf of the charity called John Seear for Open Space and Recreation Ground Park Trust, Charity No. 303234.
3.2 Quarry Cottage, within Seear’s Park, is a derelict residence built in 1910 and is part of the open space. The cottage has been closed to the public and unused since 1997, and all security, maintenance and other costs so far are the Council’s responsibility as the trustee for the charity, which does not have any trading funds to pay for the upkeep and maintenance. The charity’s objective is to provide quiet enjoyment of the park and open space for the residents of Cheam. The proposal from Yourspace.Sutton to bring back into use this vacant and unused park keeper’s cottage, deliver benefits to park users as well as local residents, and help the charity and the Council, to meet its charitable objectives for the provision of open and recreation space.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.