Resolved – (1) That approval be given to the variation of the premises licence for the Rodbourne Service Station, Rodbourne Road, Swindon, subject to the additional conditions set out in Appendix 2 to the report, and subject to the following opening hours:- Sale of Alcohol 24hours daily. Provision of Late Night Refreshments 24hours daily. The reason for this decision was that no evidence of potential problems arising from the grant of the permission had been substantiated
Word for word from the decision Swindon published for this meeting.Source: ww5.swindon.gov.uk
3.1There are no direct financial implications arising from the report. Failure to reach a reasonable conclusion in each case, based on the facts, could lead to nuisance or to unwarranted damage to the business concerned. Either scenario could raise issues of compensation. In the case of an appeal, the Council could become liable for costs.
4 Social, Environmental, Staffing, Legal/Human Rights, Risk and Other Implications
4.1Social Implications – There is a potential conflict between concerns about nuisance on the one hand and the rights of traders on the other.
4.2Environmental Implications – The primary environmental matter under discussion is noise. Litter is not itself a licensing matter.
4.3Staffing Implications – There are no staffing implications but if there were, they could not be considered.
4.4Legal/Human Rights Implications – A declaration has been made by the Secretary of State, that the Licensing Act is compliant with the Human Rights Act.
4.5All other Risk Implications – None noted. 4.6 Links to Corporate Plans and Policies (in particular to Swindon 2010) – The determination of the application will be made in accordance with set legal principles. The exercise of licensing powers by the panel relates particularly to the key objectives of making Swindon a safer place and supporting a vibrant leisure economy.
5 Detail
5.1The application to vary relates to the sale of alcohol and the provision of late night refreshment.
5.2The proposal is to remove all restrictions on hours of trading. At the moment, the core hours for alcohol sales are 08.00hrs until 23.00hrs daily, noon until 22.30hrs on Sundays. Late night refreshment is not mentioned by any of those making representations so has now been authorised on a 24 hour basis, every day.
5.3Nine residents have sent a standard letter that expresses opposition to the grant of the variation of hours for the sale of alcohol.
5.4Copies of the letters are circulated as a bundle to Members of this panel and will be available at the hearing.
5.5The sole ground stated for the objection is the allegation that granting authorisation would lead to street drinking. As generally understood, street drinking is a day-time phenomenon, so the basis for the allegation is unclear.
5.6It is solely this point which forms the basis for this hearing.
5.7Unless the Panel can see a possible connection between street drinking and extended opening hours, the application to vary should be approved. Should Members not approve the variation in full, the determination should be accompanied by a statement of the reasons for anticipating street drinking in the area.
5.8The Statutory Guidance says in 6.2 “…shops, stores and supermarkets selling alcohol should generally be permitted to match the hours during which they may sell alcohol with their normal trading hours during which other sales take place, unless there are exceptional reasons …” Paragraph 6.3 is not relevant because none of the representations make the point which is raised there.
5.9Our own Licensing statement says on page 7 “In considering representations, unless there are exceptional circumstances, the Licensing Authority accepts that licensed shop premises should be free to sell alcohol, for consumption off the premises, at any time of day when they are open for normal business”.
5.10The options before this panel are – 5.11 [a]. Set aside the representation and approve the variation application without further modification;
5.12[b]. Approve some variation but restrict the authorisation to a more limited set of days / hours of operation;
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.