Resolved – (1) That the application for a premises licence for the Queens Park Cafe, Queens Park, Swindon, be refused on the grounds of the prevention of crime and disorder and the protection of children from harm. The reasons for this decision were: That following evidence from Wiltshire Constabulary the Panel was not satisfied with the security arrangements in place or those proposed and were concerned that the storage of alcohol on site, or the perception that alcohol was stored on site, was likely to give rise to further crime. The Panel felt that, given the size and nature of the park, young people who were drinking alcohol whilst below the age of 18 would be more difficult to detect. Furthermore, the sale of off-licence sales from these premises increases the likelihood of such problems occurring. The Panel also heard evidence that suggested that there were already some public nuisance problems in this area and felt that the grant of the application would exacerbate this problem. The Chair asked officers to remind the applicant that he had the right of appeal to the Magistrates Court and that an application for any such appeal should be made within 21 days. The Chair asked officers to remind the applicant that he could obtain more information regarding Special Events Licensing from the Council’s Licensing Officer. The applicant left the hearing prior to the Panel’s consideration of the application. Councillor Steve Allsopp made a non-prejudicial declaration of interest in respect of Agenda Item No. 6 in his capacity as a Director of the Co-operative Society, which was referred to during questions of clarification.
Word for word from the decision Swindon published for this meeting.Source: ww5.swindon.gov.uk
Purpose • To determine an application for a premises licence for the sale of alcohol from the Café at Queens Park.
Recommendation Licensing Committee is asked to : - • In the light of the application and the representations made on it, to decide whether to approve or refuse the application.
1. Reasons 1.1 The Licensing Panel has a statutory duty to undertake the functions of the Licensing Authority, where these have been delegated by the Licensing Committee.
2. Detail 2.1 An application has been submitted by Mark Johnston for a premises licence, to permit him to sell alcohol.
2.2The proposed hours are from 09.00hrs until 23.00hrs daily. In practice, Queens Park closes earlier than that, so the later time would be relevant only in circumstances where the park is open late for a special purpose.
2.3Mark Johnston has not made any formal approach to the Council to change his lease, which at the moment bans any sale of alcohol.
2.4Representations have been made against the application, by a number of residents. Some of these are not admissible because the writer is not “in the vicinity”. Five of the submissions are relevant representations. A bundle containing the objections has been circulated.
2.5The Police have been consulted and they object to the application. A copy of their submission is attached as Appendix One.
2.6The Trading Standards Manager has been consulted and also objects. His submission is attached as Appendix Two.
Further information on the subject of this report can be obtained from Lionel Starling on 01793 466109 or e-mail [email protected]. Application for a premises licence for the Queens Park Café Licensing Committee Date: 5 October 2006 2.7 Many of the comments from residents focus on the question of amenity and on the need for another premises selling alcohol. These arguments are of no relevance and must be set aside.
2.8The key points made by objectors are that :-
- The park area is large and difficult to supervise, so there is considerable scope for inappropriate drinking, which the proprietor of the kiosk would be unable to control - The park is used by a lot of unsupervised children and the availability of alcohol would place them at risk - The café is vulnerable to break-ins and the knowledge that alcohol is sold would make it more vulnerable.
2.9In reaching a conclusion, Members must have regard to the Swindon Licensing Statement and to the section 182 Guidance issued by government. The latter has just been revised but the changes have no direct bearing on this application.
2.10A copy of the Standard Hearing Procedure is attached as a pre-amble to this report.
2.11Members have a wide discretion and can approve the application, approve it in part, apply conditions or refuse the application.
2.12A plan of the area showing the confirmed representations is attached as Appendix Three.
Alternative Options • It would be possible to defer a decision to another time or to defer the hearing itself but either step should be seen as an extreme and quite exceptional measure.
Risk Management Financial and Procurement Implications There are no direct financial implications arising from the report. Failure to reach a reasonable conclusion, based on the facts, could lead to nuisance to the public or to unwarranted damage to the business in question. Either scenario could raise issues of compensation. In the case of an appeal, the Council could become liable for costs. Legal / Human Rights Implications A declaration has been made by the Secretary of State, that the Licensing Act is compliant with the Human Rights Act. None of the relevant Articles of the Human Rights Act has absolute sway over the others. Article 8 deals with a right to undisturbed home life; Article 10 gives the right to free expression,
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.