Resolved – That, the meeting be adjourned pending the receipt of additional information, and unless compelling evidence is received to satisfy the concerns of the Council’s Trading Standards Team the application be considered by this Panel on Friday 8 th June 2012. Reasons 1. That the Panel heard evidence as to the management of the premises under an individual which led to the subsequent revocation of the Premises Licence. 2. The Panel was aware of the concerns of the Council’s Trading Standards Team as to the authenticity of the current application and the need to prove that previous management would have no input or control over any application granted. 3. In order to satisfy itself that the Licensing Objectives would be met in full additional information was required prior to consideration of the application. 4. The Panel noted that should the information requested by the Council’s Trading Standards Team prove that the previous management would have no financial or management interest in the premises that the current objection to the grant of the application would be withdrawn and that no review would be required.
Word for word from the decision Swindon published for this meeting.Source: ww5.swindon.gov.uk
Application for a Premises Licence - 184 Victoria Road, Swindon Licensing Panel Date: 20 April 2012
Author: Head of Licensing Wards Affected: Eastcott
Purpose • To determine an application for a new premises licence for 184 Victoria Road.
Recommendation Licensing Committee is asked : - • In the light of the application, to determine any action that is necessary, having regard to the extensive remedial powers available.
1. Reasons 1.1 The Licensing Panel has a statutory duty to undertake the functions of the Licensing Authority, where these have been delegated by the Licensing Committee. 2. Detail 2.1 An application for review of the premises licence held by Tatras at 184 Victoria Road was heard on 27 January 2012. The licensing panel concluded that the shop was being used deliberately to further a criminal purpose, namely the sale of contraband tobacco. The premises licence was revoked. The minutes of that hearing are attached as Appendix One.
2.2There is no statutory bar to a fresh application being submitted in relation to closed premises, even for a limited period. Plainly this opens up significant potential for abuse, designed to undermine the effect of a ban.
2.3It is a simple matter for an associate of the original premises licence holder or a limited company to be set up with an opaque ownership to seek to circumvent a revocation by applying for a new licence.
2.4In the present case an application was made within a month of the revocation and only days after the expiry of the opportunity to appeal.
2.5It would undermine the licensing objectives if a decision to revoke could be subverted by a proxy application, so caution must be exercised in all cases.
2.6Since it was established that Tatras was operating as a criminal enterprise, Members will wish to be satisfied that the application now under consideration is bona fide.
Further information on the subject of this report can be obtained from Lionel Starling on 01793 466113 or e-mail [email protected]. Application for a Premises Licence - 184 Victoria Road, Swindon Licensing Panel Date: 20 April 2012 2.7 The application was made in the name of Victoria News. That has generated some confusion, as there is an established business at 115 Victoria which has long had that name. The latter business has nothing whatever to do with Tatras. The reasons for using the name of another business are unknown.
2.8Trading Standards brought the review which resulted in the revocation and they have made a representation on the current application, based on anxiety over whether the application is genuine or not. Their representation is shown as Appendix Two.
2.9The applicant has been asked by Trading Standards to show an audit trail which demonstrates convincingly that there is no association between him and the person who presented himself as proprietor of the shop at the time of the review.
2.10Documentation of a contract could have some value as evidence.
2.11Funds exchanged in connection with a change of title over land or goods would be indicative.
2.12Updating of formal records for taxation and the payment of utilities might help to establish that a genuine change has taken place.
2.13Evidence of new contracts to supply goods and services (e.g. with legitimate cash and carry dealers) would assist in reaching a conclusion.
2.14Formal records at the Land Registry would be of assistance.
2.15Even formal records do not always tell the full story. Sometimes the real owner or ‘controlling mind’ of a business has their own reasons for using a proxy individual to act as a front for them, masking their involvement.
2.16All the panel can do is to form an opinion on the evidence.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.