Resolved
Resolved – That the report be noted.
Audit Committee noted this item on Tuesday 20 November 2012. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
Resolved – That the report be noted.
Internal Audit: Benchmarking
Audit Committee Date: 20th November 2012 Author: Head of Internal Audit Wards: None Locality Affected: None Parishes Affected: None
1. Purpose and Reasons 1.1 To present Members with a summary with a summary of the 2012 benchmarking exercise carried out by CIPFA with regard to the Council’s Internal Audit service. 1.2 The Council’s Audit Committee has a strategic role to ensure that the Council’s assurance framework is operating effectively. To this end it should seek assurance that key areas that contribute to this framework are operating properly. 1.3 The Council’s Internal Audit section is a key component of the assurance framework and therefore it is essential that this Committee monitor its performance to ensure that it is providing and effective service that offers value for money. 2. Recommendations The Committee is recommended to: 2.1 It is recommended that the contents of the report be noted. 3. Detail Background 3.1 The Council subscribes to the CIPFA benchmarking club. CIPFA carries out benchmarking in a number of areas, one of which relates to internal audit. On an annual basis we provide information on the section relating to:
• Cost • Audit coverage • Fraud and investigations • Staffing – numbers, qualifications and pay • Section structure • Corporate Governance (new this year) • Quartile figures
3.2A report is then produced (see Appendix 1) that sets out comparisons for actual performance from the previous financial year, in this case 2011/12, and planned
Further information on the subject of this report can be obtained from Nick Hobbs, Direct Dial Telephone Number 01793 463940, [email protected]. Internal Audit: Benchmarking
Audit Committee Date: 20th November 2012 performance for the current financial year (2012/13 ) against all other unitary authorities who have contributed benchmarking information. Findings 3.3 I have set out below the main results of the benchmarking under the above headings. Cost analysis (see pages 2 – 13 of Appendix 1) 3.4 This section shows the analysis of audit costs for 2011/12 actuals and 2012/13 estimates. The benchmarks are costs per audit day, cost per £m turnover and chargeable days per auditor.
• The cost of the audit section based on the Council’s turnover (for 2011/12) was above average when compared to all other unitary authorities in the benchmarking club and this is planned to continue in 2012/13 but is expected to reduce significantly in 2013/14 due to changes in the staffing structure and a retirement of a Senior Auditor. • However, the cost per chargeable audit day (i.e. number of audit days left after deducting annual leave, sickness, training etc.) remains significantly lower than the unitary average both for 2011/12 actual (£273 against an average of £313 per chargeable audit day) and 2012/13 estimated. • This lower cost per chargeable day along with a more productive than average audit section (184 chargeable days compared to an average of 171) helps in providing the authority with more audit days per £m of turnover than the unitary average i.e. 3.7 days per £m turnover compared to the unitary average of 2.5 days (in 2011/12). This continues in 2012/13 with an estimate of 3.5 days compared to 2.5 days. However, given the rate of change within Swindon and the control issues that this presents this would be expected. • The cost per in-house auditor (including on-costs, overheads etc.) was well below the unitary average in 2011/12(£51,857 compared to an average of £55,053) and is estimated to be below the average again for 2012/13.
Audit Coverage (see pages 14 - 23 of Appendix 1) 3.5 This section looks at audit days per £m gross revenue turnover and the split by type of audit. It also analyses the days spent on fundamental financial systems, operational risks and corporate governance
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
benchmarking reportAppendix A | 39 pages | Download |
PDF |
Internal Audit: BenchmarkingReport | 5 pages | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Audit Committee at Swindon and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Jun 2026 | MinutesThat the minutes of the previous meeting held on 17 March 2026 be confirmed as true record and signed by the Chairman | Decided | Open |
| 23 Jun 2026 | Corporate Risk Management UpdateThat (i) the risk management approach and the risks escalated in the Corporate Risk Register be endorsed (ii) a furth... | Decided | Open |
| 23 Jun 2026 | Audit Committee Annual ReportThat the report be noted | Noted | Open |
| 23 Jun 2026 | Head of Internal Audit Annual Report 2025/26 and OpinionThat the report be noted | Noted | Open |
| 23 Jun 2026 | Audit Committee Terms of ReferenceThat (i) the revised terms of reference attached at appendix 1 to the report be approved. (ii) The enhanced responsib... | Approved | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.