CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Swindon Borough Council
Audit Committee, Tuesday 27 November 2018

Audit Committee: Independent Members

Decided Finance 3 papers

Audit Committee decided this item on Tuesday 27 November 2018. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item38

Resolved

Resolved – That no action be taken to appoint Independent members to the Council’s Audit Committee but that this position be reviewed annually by the Committee.
Word for word from the decision Swindon published for this meeting. Source: ww5.swindon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Swindon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Audit Committee, 2 pages

Appendix 2

South Plymouth Bristol Poole Bournemouth Cornwall Gloucestershire Do you have any independent members on Yes Yes No No Yes Yes your Audit Committee? If yes, how many? Three – one currently Two N/A N/A One Two vacant Do any of your independent members chair No No N/A N/A Yes No the Audit Committee? When did you first appoint independent 2003 Around 2011 N/A N/A 2013 Around 2011 members? What remuneration do they receive? £4,400 special £1,300.40 pa plus Travel and parking responsibility £615pa N/A N/A reimbursement of expenses only allowance and travel reasonable expenses. and subsistence When you appointed were you looking for Consider complex any specific skills gap? information and act impartially at all times. Financial awareness, a broad Audit/Finance The independent understanding of the experience. Someone member was Governance, risk and financial, risk, who understood previously the Audit N/A N/A business control, and governance and Committee Chair so management corporate could provide the skill/experience was governance issues necessary challenge. already known facing local authorities generally and the Council specifically. If you have had an independent member in the past but no longer do what was the N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A reason for the change? If you haven’t got an independent member Members decided Members decided – have you tried and had no interest, or N/A N/A N/A N/A not to pursue not to pursue have Members decided not to pursue? Appendix 2

Audit Committee - Independent member benchmarking.

Comments received regarding what benefits and potential drawbacks an independent member(s) bring.

Benefits:  Business knowledge very crucial in accounts approval, quality of debate on technical issues, professional view, additional assurance for the Committee  Biggest difference is that they aren’t political and they keep the committee on track without getting side-tracked by personal/political agendas. Another big benefit is that they are audit professionals so can provide decent challenge with the correct focus.  No material difference  Independent members are there because they have a genuine interest rather than political motivation. They tend to be more objective and can ask some searching and usually very valid questions. A good independent member is not afraid to question what they don’t understand, including terminology and it is my belief that this can be helpful and informative to elected members who may be afraid of asking the ‘silly question’. One of the co-opted members on the audit committee was formally the Director of Corporate Finance at a University. They are a major asset as they properly understand finance (accounts, treasury management), audit and the constitution.

Drawbacks:  They do not vote so may not influence the decision in that way but they are respected and listened to.  None  Don’t consider that there any drawbacks but those with less direct experience would benefit from training and even a bit of mentoring to develop their knowledge and their confidence.  Sometimes they struggle with the committee’s role against that of scrutiny as they don’t see/hear what scrutiny do.

Other comments:  Recruitment is not easy. Democratic Services think that the last time they tried to recruit no candidates came forward  As Head of Internal Audit I did not get involved in the appointment of the independent member, this was dealt with be Legal. We felt separation on this point was important

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
job descrip specAppendix 1 3 pages Download
PDF
Appx 2: benchmarkingReport 2 pages DownloadRead as text
PDF
Audit Committee: Independent MembersReport 5 pages Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

5 of 8 attended
SW
Councillor Steve WeisingerChair, present
JB
Councillor John BallmanMember, apologies
NM
Nick Martin (Vice-Chair)Vice-Chair, apologies
DM
Councillor Des MoffattMember, apologies
KS
Councillor Kevin SmallMember, present
RS
Councillor Roger SmithMember, present
RT
Councillor Rahul TararMember, present
BM
Councillor Brian MattockMember, present

On this subject at Swindon

Search all
  1. Audit Committee: Independent MembersThis decision
  2. Audit Committee: Independent MemberAgreed
  3. Audit Committee - Independent Member(s)Decided
  4. Potential role for independent members on the Audit CommitteeNoted
  5. Potential role for independent members on the Audit CommitteeNoted

More from Swindon Audit Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
23 Jun 2026 MinutesThat the minutes of the previous meeting held on 17 March 2026 be confirmed as true record and signed by the Chairman Decided Open
23 Jun 2026 Corporate Risk Management UpdateThat (i) the risk management approach and the risks escalated in the Corporate Risk Register be endorsed (ii) a furth... Decided Open
23 Jun 2026 Audit Committee Annual ReportThat the report be noted Noted Open
23 Jun 2026 Head of Internal Audit Annual Report 2025/26 and OpinionThat the report be noted Noted Open
23 Jun 2026 Audit Committee Terms of ReferenceThat (i) the revised terms of reference attached at appendix 1 to the report be approved. (ii) The enhanced responsib... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies