Test of Assurance - Children's Services arrangements
NotedExecutive2 papers
AI summarySwindon Cabinet noted an LGA Test of Assurance on Children's Services and endorsed most of its recommendations, rejecting a single Lead Member for Children's Services and agreeing a further LGA review in 2026.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeNotedMost recommendations agreed, one rejected, further review planned
MoneyNo specific sum stated; budget referenced separately
What happens nextFurther LGA review in 2026Plus internal audit at six month point
Who it affectsChildren's Services and SEND in SwindonPlus scrutiny and Cabinet Member arrangements
What was decided
Cabinet noted the outcome of the Test of Assurance completed by the LGA in September 2025 and recorded thanks to the LGA and Caroline O'Neill. Report 2.1, 2.2, 3.14
Cabinet endorsed the actions taken on the recommendations at paragraphs 3.18.1 to 3.18.5 and 3.18.7 to 3.18.11. Report 2.3
Cabinet noted that recommendation 3.18.6 (a single Lead Member for Children's Services) has not been implemented and endorsed the reasons, and agreed a further LGA review in 2026. Report 2.4, 2.5, P58, P69
Why
The structural review merged Children's and Adult services into a People Directorate, following the departure of the previous Corporate Director of Children's Services, to give strong corporate leadership to a service with an Inadequate Ofsted rating and an upcoming re-inspection expected in 2026. Report 3.5, 3.9, 3.12, P40
Statutory guidance recommends a Test of Assurance when there are structural changes to the Director of Children's Services role, and the LGA offered to fund and complete it. Report 3.4, 3.14, 5.4
What happens next
New arrangements to split the combined Children, Adult and Health scrutiny portfolio to be in place by the new municipal year at the latest. Report P50
A 'ways of working' protocol for the DCS is being developed and was to be completed by the end of January. Report P52
A further Test of Assurance is recommended for late 2026, with an internal audit at the six-month point to review arrangements. Report P69
Options considered
Chosen: Continue with the current split structure (Children's Social Care under DCS; Education and SEND under Corporate Director of Prevention and Communities). Test of Assurance endorsed; traditional model has not worked previously and a significant improvement journey is still needed Report 4.1, P45, P58
Rejected: Revert to a traditional model with a separate Corporate Director for Children's Services and a Corporate Director for Adult Services. Traditional structures have not worked for this council for some time and there is a significant improvement journey to continue in both Children's Social Care and SEND Report 4.1
Rejected: Designate a single Lead Member for Children's Services, or designate the Cabinet Member for Education and SEND as Deputy Lead Member. Considered too much for one Cabinet Member to oversee given significant improvement requirements in both Children's Services and SEND; will be kept under review Report P56, P57, P58
Implications
Financial: There may be a need for further democratic services support once new scrutiny arrangements are in place; the necessary budget allocation is being included in the Council's 2026/2027 budget referenced elsewhere in this meeting. Report 5.1
Legal: Sections 18(4) and 19(1) of the Children Act 2004 require the Council to appoint a Director of Children's Services and designate a Lead Member; the Council has done so. Current arrangements do not wholly follow the statutory guidance, but the Test of Assurance has considered the position and the proposed arrangements are considered to achieve the intended outcomes. Report 5.2, 5.3, 5.4, 5.5
Equalities: An Equalities Impact Assessment was carried out in advance of the Test of Assurance and will be made available on the Council's website. Report 5.8, 7.1
Risk: Risks relating to the structure, including potential single points of failure, will be added to the People Directorate and Prevention and Communities Directorate risk registers and managed there. Report P48, 5.9
Climate: Officers believe the proposals would not bring a change in service delivery and there is no expected effect on the Council's carbon footprint. Report 5.6
Staffing: Brenda McInerney was appointed as Director of Children's Services and joined the Council on 24 November 2025; from January the DCS will have an open invitation to all Corporate Management Team meetings. Report 3.12, P65
Who and where
Children and families receiving services from Swindon Borough Council Report 3.16, P35, P36, P37
Children's Social Care staff and service users in Swindon Report 3.9
Children and young people with SEND and their families Report 3.6, 3.9
Members of the Children, Adult and Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee Report P49, P50
The Cabinet Member for Children's Services and the Cabinet Member for Education and SEND Report P54, P56, P57, P58
Partner agencies and external regulators working with Swindon's children's services Report P59, P60
Timeline
2024: 51 changes in Director of Children's Services postholders nationally, referenced as context for recruitment difficulty Report P40
September 2025: Test of Assurance completed by Caroline O'Neill, LGA Improvement Advisor Report 3.14, 3.15, 8.1
24 November 2025: Brenda McInerney joined Swindon Borough Council as Director of Children's Services Report 3.12
End of January: Target date for completion of a 'ways of working' protocol for how the DCS will deliver statutory duties Report P52
From January: Director of Children's Services to have an open invitation to all Corporate Management Team meetings Report P65
Within the next six months: SEND inspection due Report 3.9
2026: Ofsted re-inspection of Children's Social Care expected Report 3.9
New municipal year at the latest: New scrutiny arrangements to be in place, splitting the combined Children, Adult and Health portfolio Report P50
2026: Further review of the impact of the structural changes to be carried out by the Local Government Association at an appropriate point in the year Report 2.5, P8
Late 2026: Further Test of Assurance recommended, with an internal audit at the six-month point Report P69
Plain English for the jargon
DCS: Director of Children's Services, a statutory chief officer role required under the Children Act 2004
LGA: Local Government Association, the body that funded and carried out the Test of Assurance
Test of Assurance: A framework for reviewing senior management arrangements for managing children's services and adult social services, conducted in a similar way to Sector Led Improvement
SEND: Special Educational Needs and Disabilities
DofE: Department for Education
CMT: Corporate Management Team, the council's senior officer leadership group
DSP: Designated Safeguarding Person, the senior officer with lead responsibility for safeguarding
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item68
Resolved
Non-key Decision Following consideration of the report and its appendix, Cabinet resolved: (1) That the outcome of the Test of Assurance outlined in Appendix 1 be noted. (2) That it’s thanks to the Local Government Association, and particularly to Caroline O’Neill for completing the Test of Assurance, be recorded. (3) That the actions that have been taken as recommended by the Test of Assurance as outlined in paragraphs 3.18.1 to 3.18.5 and 3.18.7 to 3.18.11 be noted and endorsed. (4) That the recommendation that has not been enacted as recommended by the Test of Assurance outlined in paragraph 3.18.6 be noted, and the reasons why that recommendation has not been implemented be endorsed. (5) That a further review of the impact of the structural changes be carried out by the Local Government Association at an appropriate point in 2026 to ensure the recommendations outlined in the report have been implemented and are having the necessary impact to ensure statutory responsibilities to children and their families are being carried out effectively. The reasons for the decision and alternative options are as set out in the report to the meeting.
Word for word from the decision Swindon published for this meeting.Source: ww5.swindon.gov.uk
2.1Note the outcome of the Test of Assurance outlined in Appendix 1.
2.2Record its thanks to the Local Government Association, and particularly to Caroline O’Neill for completing the Test of Assurance.
2.3Note the actions that have been taken as recommended by the Test of Assurance as outlined in paragraphs 3.18.1 to 3.18.5 and 3.18.7 to 3.18.11 and endorse those actions as appropriate.
2.4Note the recommendation that has not been enacted as recommended by the Test of Assurance outlined in paragraph 3.18.6 and to endorse the reasons why that recommendation has not been implemented.
2.5Agree that a further review of the impact of the structural changes be carried out by the Local Government Association at an appropriate point in 2026 to ensure the
Further information on the subject of this report can be obtained from Sam Mowbray, [email protected]. Test of Assurance – Children’s Services arrangements Cabinet Date: 4th February 2026
recommendations outlined in this report have been implemented and are having the necessary impact to ensure our statutory responsibilities to children and their families are being carried out effectively.
3. Detail
What is a Test of Assurance?
3.1A Test of Assurance is a framework for providing support to chief executives or executive directors of local authorities to review senior management arrangements for managing children’s services and adult social services.
3.2There are several possible reasons why a chief executive or executive director might consider that this is an appropriate mechanism to review senior management and leadership arrangements. These criteria could include:
3.2.1 changes in senior management structure, for example, new directors, new chief executive, split functions such as commissioning placed in an alternative directorate to statutory chief officer;
3.2.2 changes in council leadership, for example, new political administration or new portfolio holder/s;
3.2.3 concerns with financial or performance management at a strategic level.
3.3Statutory guidance requires local authorities to test the extent to which the organisational structures fulfil key criteria such as meeting statutory responsibilities, transparency of accountabilities and responsibilities, and support effective inter-agency and partnership working.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Capital Monitoring – Quarter 1 2026/2027Key Decision Following consideration of the report and its appendices, Cabinet resolved : (1) That the 2026/27 expend...
Consultation and Engagement PolicyKey Decision Following consideration of the report and its appendix, Cabinet resolved that the updated Consultation a...
CSC Ofsted Monitoring Visit UpdateNon-key Decision Following consideration of the report and its appendix, Cabinet resolved : (1) That the progress mad...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.