RESOLVED That the Council be recommended to restructure the Committee’s Sub-Committees as follows: Assessment and Consideration Sub-Committee – to deal with the initial assessment of complaints and, in those cases that are referred for investigation, consideration of the investigators report Appeals Sub-Committee – to deal with complainants requests for a review of assessment decisions to take no action Hearings Sub-Committee – to conduct hearings, make findings and decide on sanctions.
Word for word from the decision Thanet published for this meeting.Source: democracy.thanet.gov.uk
STANDARDS COMMITTEE - REVIEW OF THE COMMITTEE’S ARRANGEMENTS FOR THE DISCHARGE OF THEIR RESPONSIBILITIES
To: Constitutional Review Working Party – 23 February 2009 Standards Committee – 5 March 2009
By: Miles Smith, Interim Head of Legal & Democratic Services
Classification: Unrestricted
Summary: Following consideration at the December meeting, to give further consideration to the Standards Committee’s arrangements for determining allegations that members have failed to comply with the Council’s Code of Conduct.
For Decision
1.0Introduction and Background
1.1At their meeting on 22 April 2008, the Standards Committee approved initial arrangements for the discharge of their new responsibilities for local determination from 1 May 2008. 1.2 At that time it was anticipated that these arrangements would need to be reviewed in the light of experience, further advice from the Standards Board for England and the development of good practice. 1.3 At their meeting on 2 December 2008 the Standards Committee considered the issues set out in this report and deferred further consideration pending consideration by the Constitutional Working Party.
2.0Committee and Sub-Committee Structure
2.1In addition to its responsibility for the promotion and development of the local ethical framework and oversight of the local determination arrangements, the Standards Committee now has very specific responsibilities in accordance with the statutory framework for the assessment, review of assessment, consideration following investigation and hearing of complaints. To undertake these responsibilities it has to make some use of sub-committees.
2.2As the Working Party will recall, the statutory process has four stages: - Stage One. Assessment (Is there a case to answer?)
Stage Two. Review of Assessment (Appeal by complainant against Stage One decision to take no action)
Stage Three. Consideration of Investigation Report (Accepts investigation finding of no failure, or refers for full hearing)
Stage Four. Hearing (Where the investigation has found a failure to comply) 2.3 The Committee’s current arrangements provide for these steps to be dealt with as follows:
2.4These arrangements are generally sound and have worked well. A possible change that the Committee have considered would be for Stage Three (Consideration of Investigation Report) to be dealt with by the Standards Referral & Hearings Sub-Committee, and ideally with the same membership that has dealt with the matter at Stage One, rather than by the full Committee. If this approach were to be adopted, the Sub-Committee could be re-named the Assessment and Consideration Sub-Committee to reflect this changed role.
2.5The possible benefits of amending the sub-committee arrangements in this respect may include: -
• The full Standards Committee would deal with matters of policy, procedure, the promotion of the local ethical framework and oversight of these arrangements generally, but would not become involved in the determination of individual complaint issues.
• Step Three does not require the involvement of the full Committee and is arguably the step in the process where the least discretion is exercised.
• The use of the same sub-committee and members at Stage Three as at Stage One would take advantage of the Sub-Committees knowledge and consideration from Stage One and involving them in the outcome of the investigation makes their continued role something of a learning opportunity.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Revised Complaints ArrangementsAGREED: · The 2.1.1 (Procedure on Receipt of a Complaint), section involving “Investigation Deadline”, be amended to ...
Questions from Members to CouncilAGREED the recommendation. Cllr Crittenden proposed, Cllr Fellows seconded and Members AGREED to forward the report t...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.