Resolved
It was AGREED that the report be accepted for consideration, so as to enable the Panel to comment on it prior to the matter being considered by the Constitutional Review Working Party. Glenn Back presented the report, referring specifically to: the CCfA giving all Councillors the ability to request that an issue be considered by the Panel; the statutory obligation to have such a request placed on a Panel agenda, providing that it was a valid request, that all reasonable attempts had been made to resolve the issue (e.g., through dialogue with Officers) and that the problem still persisted; the various exclusions which applied, e.g., matters relating to a planning or licensing decision, over which the Panel would have no locus, requests which could be perceived as being vexatious, discriminatory or not reasonable, or local crime and disorder matters, which were covered by other statutory provisions; the choices available as to who determined whether or not a CCfA was valid and as to whether the Panel itself or a “task and finish” Working Group should investigate an issue so raised; the eventual Protocol submitted to the Constitutional Review Working Party would, most likely, be in the form of a flow chart with options at various stages. Discussion took place, during which the following views were expressed: some kind of time limit should apply to some of the exemptions; for example, it would not be acceptable to say that something was already being investigated if that had been taking place for a long time without any outcome. the rejection of a request on the basis that “ the issue is currently being dealt with by the relevant Director” should be amended to include “or Cabinet Member”; it should be made clear in the protocol that only individual planning decisions, and not overall planning processes, should be treated as “excluded matters”. It was AGREED that the Panel recommends to the Constitutional Review Working Party: that the comments above should be considered; that the Chairman & Vice-Chairman of the Panel should, in addition to the Chief Executive and the Monitoring Office, have the power to accept/reject a CCfA ; the Panel should be able to decide on whether or not a “task & finish” working party was appropriate to investigate any particular CCfA .