CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Thanet District Council
Standards Committee, Wednesday 9 May 2012 at 7.00pm

Motions on Notice - Amendments to Council Procedure Rules

Approved Committee 1 paper

Standards Committee approved this item on Wednesday 9 May 2012. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item212

Resolved

The Standards Committee made the following recommendations to Council to change the constitution as follows: i ) Council Procedure Rule 16.3 to read: “ The Member whose name appears first on the Notice will move the motion during his or her speech and call for a seconder . If seconded, a member from the controlling political group will be entitled to a reply, the motion shall then stand referred without further discussion to the Cabinet or appropriate Committee for determination or report unless the Council decides to debate the motion in accordance with Rule 19.” ii) Council Procedure Rule 16.4(a) - to include the following paragraphs “(iii) Where a motion on notice would, if adopted, constitute the exercise of an executive function, that motion must be referred to the Cabinet (or relevant Cabinet portfolio holder as appropriate) for decision. (iv) The Chairman shall rule out of order any motion on notice that relates to the adoption of, or amendment to, a policy falling within the Council’s adopted Policy Framework if that policy or amendment (as the case may be) has not first been proposed by the Cabinet and considered by the Overview and Scrutiny Panel. (v) The Chairman shall rule of out order any motion on notice that proposes the adoption of, or amendment to, any policy outside the adopted Policy Framework which by law or this Constitution is the sole responsibility of the Cabinet. (vi) Any motion on notice that proposes the adoption of a policy or the taking of a decision where Council has not received a report from the officers setting out the technical legal and financial implications of adopting the policy or taking the decision in question shall only be debated. The only action that may be taken is to refer the motion to Cabinet for consideration.” iii) Rejecting Motions on notice – to include the following paragraph: “The Chairman of Council may rule of out order Motions on Notice that in his opinion: a) are defamatory in nature, b) are frivolous in nature, or c) contain offensive language.” That the Corporate and Regulatory Services Manager be given delegated authority to amend the Council’s constitution in order to reflect any changes to it that are made as a result of Council’s decision on this matter.
Word for word from the decision Thanet published for this meeting. Source: democracy.thanet.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Thanet's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Standards Committee

MOTIONS ON NOTICE

To: Constitutional Review Working Party

Main Portfolio Area: Performance

By: Corporate and Regulatory Services Manager

Classification: Unrestricted

Summary: To consider amendments to the Council Procedure Rules regarding Notices of Motion.

For Recommendation

1.0Introduction and Background

1.1The purpose of Council Procedure Rule (CPR) 16 is to enable any two members to request full Council to consider debating and determining an issue that might not otherwise be debated and determined and it is for this reason that the Rule is drafted in very broad terms to encompass debates that engage not only the functions of the Council but also any matter affecting the district. The Motion on Notice Procedure framed by Rule 16 pre-dates the introduction of the Leader and Cabinet system and therefore would have represented one of the few opportunities in the old Committee system for opposition members to try to force a debate in Council on an important issue affecting the district or as a means of requesting the Council to reconsider a policy or decision it had made. In practice. The introduction of the Leader and Cabinet system where political power is centralised in a single party Cabinet held accountable by a politically balanced Overview & Scrutiny Committee, has resulted in a reduction in the use of the Notice of Motion Procedure as a tool for holding a ruling administration to account.

1.2However, the Rule was never intended to permit the decision making processes and procedures that flow from a Cabinet/Scrutiny model, i.e. those prescribed by law and the Council’s Constitution, to be circumvented. In other words a Motion on Notice should not ask the Council to take a decision in respect of a function that is an executive function because the discharge of an executive function is the sole responsibility of the Cabinet, nor should it ask Council to make or amend a policy which is not part of the Council’s Policy Framework (as the approval or amendment of such a policy is also the responsibility of the Cabinet), nor for that matter should a Motion on Notice enable the Council to make or amend a policy that is within the Policy Framework unless a draft of the policy has been considered by the Cabinet and by the Overview & Scrutiny Panel. It also follows that a Motion on Notice should not enable the Council to take any decision without a full understanding the technical, legal and financial implications of that decision. Indeed, if Council did pass a Motion without a full understanding and due consideration of these implications, Members would be in breach of their fiduciary duty to the taxpayer and the Council would be at risk of judicial review.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Motions on Notice: Amendments to Council Procedure RulesReport 105 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

11 of 15 attended
RH
Mr Robin Hills Independent MemberChair, present
BH
Mr Brian Hinchley Independent MemberVice-Chair, apologies
LF
Mrs Linda Frampton Independent MemberCommittee Member, apologies
MS
Ms Miriam Sarrafan Independent MemberCommittee Member, apologies
JC
Councillor Jack CohenCommittee Member, present
ME
Councillor Ms Elizabeth GreenCommittee Member, apologies, sent representative
WS
Councillor William ScobieCommittee Member, present as substitute
MI
Councillor Mrs Iris JohnstonCommittee Member, present
RR
Councillor Richard R NicholsonCommittee Member, apologies, sent representative
MJ
Councillor Mike J HarrisonCommittee Member, present as substitute
MJ
Councillor Michael J RobertsCommittee Member, apologies
MT
Councillor Michael TomlinsonCommittee Member, present

All 15 on the meeting page

On this subject at Thanet

Search all
  1. Motions on Notice - Amendments to Council Procedure RulesThis decision
  2. Reporting back to council on decisions made relating to petitions and motions on noticeApproved
  3. Reporting back to council on decisions made in relation to petitions and motions on noticeAgreed
  4. Motions on Notice - Amendments to Council Procedure Rule 16Approved

More from Thanet Standards Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
10 Nov 2022 Revised Complaints ArrangementsAGREED: · The 2.1.1 (Procedure on Receipt of a Complaint), section involving “Investigation Deadline”, be amended to ... Agreed Open
10 Mar 2022 Questions from Members to CouncilAGREED the recommendation. Cllr Crittenden proposed, Cllr Fellows seconded and Members AGREED to forward the report t... Agreed Open
5 Mar 2020 Exclusion of Press and PublicIt was AGREED that the public and press be excluded from the meeting for agenda item 7, as it contained exempt inform... Agreed Open
12 Sep 2017 Support to Town and Parish CouncilsIt was agreed that an update would be brought to the next meeting of the Standards Committee. Agreed Open
16 Sep 2014 Minutes of Previous MeetingAGREED that the minutes of the meeting of 1 April 2014 were a correct record. Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies