“THAT the recommendations at paragraphs 6.1 & 6.2 of the report be adopted, namely: 1. That the recommendations of the Constitutional Review Working Party and Standards Committee be noted; 2. That no change to the current Overview & Scrutiny Committee structure be endorsed at this time.
Word for word from the decision Thanet published for this meeting.Source: democracy.thanet.gov.uk
OPTIONS FOR THE FUTURE OF OVERVIEW AND SCRUTINY IN THANET
To: Council – 18 April 2013
Main Portfolio Area: Democratic Services
By: Harvey Patterson, Corporate & Regulatory Service Manager
Classification: Unrestricted
Ward: N/A
Summary: To consider options for the future of overview and scrutiny in Thanet based on the recommendations submitted by the Overview & Scrutiny Panel, Constitutional Review Working Party and Standards Committee.
For Decision
1.0Introduction and Background
1.1At the request of the Overview & Scrutiny Panel, a review of the structure and operational role of overview and scrutiny within Thanet has been undertaken over the last year or so. This culminated in a report on the Overview and Scrutiny Panel’s preferred option being considered at an extraordinary Overview and Scrutiny Panel meeting on 12 February 2013.
1.2The Panel Members made recommendations to the Constitutional Review Working Party, who in turn considered these recommendations at their meeting on 7 March 2013.
1.3The Constitutional Review Working Party then made their recommendations to the Standards Committee who met to consider these on 3 April 2013.
2.0The Current Situation
2.1The paper presented to the Overview and Scrutiny Panel on 12 February 2013 outlined four major options:
(a) Not to change the structure of overview and scrutiny (b) To establish three standing sub-committees of the Overview and Scrutiny Panel but to cease separate work involving task and finish sub-groups (c) To establish three standing sub-committees of the Overview and Scrutiny Panel and to continue separate work involving task and finish sub-groups (d) To establish three scrutiny committees to replace the Overview and Scrutiny Panel and to continue separate work involving task and finish sub-groups
2.2The report contained a good deal of detailed information relating to the implementation of these options, and for convenience, that report is attached at Annex 1, italicised throughout to differentiate it from this main report.
2.3The Overview and Scrutiny Panel made the following recommendations to the Constitutional Review Working Party: (a) To recommend to the Constitutional Review Working Party (then Standards Committee and Council) that the Overview & Scrutiny Panel be abolished and replaced by three Overview & Scrutiny Committees as is reflected in the officer report;
(b) To recommend that Council approach the East Kent Joint Independent Remuneration Panel for advice regarding the amendment of the Special Responsibility Allowance Scheme to reflect the new scrutiny arrangements.
2.4Constitutional Review Working Party Recommendations to Standards Committee
2.4.1 When it met on 7 March 2013 the Constitutional Review Working Party recommended the following:
• Option (a); which is “that no change to the current Overview & Scrutiny Committee structure be endorsed”.
3.0Main Points Raised by the Constitutional Review Working Party and Standards Committee
3.1An increased number of scrutiny committees may cause overlap of functions within such a structure; 3.2 Multiple scrutiny committees may lead to delays in decision making and would therefore not be efficient; 3.3 The current structure did not engender early pro-active scrutiny committee involvement in policy development and decision making; 3.4 A possible way forward would be for the Executive to consider setting up Cabinet advisory group system with cross party membership to undertake in-depth review of policy initiatives; 3.5 Any changes (if there were going to be any) should take into consideration the possibility of Kent County Council (KCC) delegating to the District Council the function of scrutinising the soon to be established Health & Wellbeing Boards. However, it must be noted that there have been no indications thus far from KCC that they may opt for this approach. 4.0 Standards Committee Recommendations
4.1The Standards Committee on 3 April 2013 recommended the following:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.