“THAT the recommendations as set out at paragraphs 7.1.1, 7.1.2 and 7.1.3 of the report be adopted, namely: 1. That the questioner is normally resident in the Thanet District Council area. 2. That the current restriction on repeat questions remains unchanged, as set out at Council Procedure Rule 13.5 – “Scope of questions”: 3. That Council Procedure Rule 13.5 be amended as shown below to reflect the change proposed. “ 13.5 Scope of questions The Chief Executive will reject a question if it: · is not about a matter for which the local authority has a responsibility or which affects the district; · is defamatory, frivolous or offensive; · is substantially the same as a question which has been put at a meeting of the Council in the past six months; · requires the disclosure of confidential or exempt information; · If the questioner is not normally a resident of Thanet; or · If a question relates to an individual planning or licensing application.”
Word for word from the decision Thanet published for this meeting.Source: democracy.thanet.gov.uk
QUESTIONS BY THE PRESS AND PUBLIC AT ORDINARY MEETINGS OF THE COUNCIL
To: Council – 5 December 2013
By: Democratic Services & Scrutiny Manager
Classification: Unrestricted
Wards: All
Summary: To review Council Procedure Rule 13 relating to questions by the press and public at ordinary meetings of the Council in so far as they relate to eligibility of questioners and the ability of questioners to ask repeat questions or more than one question over a period of time
For Decision
1.0Introduction and Background
1.1It has recently been suggested by some Members that certain aspects of the Council’s procedure rules relating to questions by members of the public at ordinary council meetings should be reviewed, particularly in relation to the qualifications of the questioners, for example, whether they should be required to be a local government elector, and whether the same questioner should be permitted to ask questions at more than one meeting of the council over a given period of time.
1.2The Council’s Procedure Rule 13, “Questions by the Public and Press” is based on the wording of a suggested rule (rule 10) for public questions contained within the “modular constitution”, which was drawn up by the then Office of the Deputy Prime Minister (now known as the Department for Communities and Local Government) as a guide to councils adopting executive arrangements under the Local Government Act 2000.
1.3An online research of other councils was carried out to determine what their council procedure rules on public questions at council meetings provided for in relation to the eligibility of questioners, repeat questions and multiple questions by the same questioner.
1.4The research was confined to the Council’s neighbouring councils, i.e, Ashford, Canterbury, Dover & Shepway and other councils who appeared to have rules based on rule 10 in the modular constitution. Eight of such “other councils” were chosen on a random basis, namely: Bournemouth Borough; Cornwall; Brighton & Hove; West Lindsay District; London Borough of Croydon; London Borough of Harrow; Richmondshire District; and Runnymede Borough.
1.5The findings of the research are summarised at Annex 1. Ashford and Canterbury were excluded on the basis that their provisions were not comparable with those of Thanet, as Ashford, which has public question time at Cabinet as well as Council meetings, permits only questions that are relevant to an item included upon the agenda for the meeting; and Canterbury, which allows questions at a wide range of committee meetings, permits a question at a council meeting only if it is supported by at least 15 signatories.
1.6For reference purposes, the Council’s Procedure Rule 13 is attached at Annex 2, and the modular constitution rule 10, at Annex 3.
2.0The Current Situation
2.1It will be noted from Annex 1 that:
2.1.1 Two councils (including Dover) require the questioner to be a local government elector; one (Thanet) requires the questioner to be a resident/citizen of the area; two councils require that the questioner lives or works in the area; one council requires the questioner to live, work, go to school or another educational establishment or otherwise own or lease land in the area; and, finally, four councils do not impose any restrictions.
2.1.2 With the exception of one council, whose constitution is silent on the issue, councils prescribe that a question cannot be substantially the same as one put at a previous Council meeting (normally, in the past six months, as per the modular constitution, although in West Lindsay’s case, no time limit is given).
2.1.3 West Lindsay District also provides: that no member of the public may submit more than six questions per year; and that no more than six questions on the same subject per year are allowed. Cornwall stipulates that no member of the public may ask more than two questions in any financial year.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.