Selective Licensing - Request for additional resources
AgreedCommittee4 papers
AI summaryThanet Council debated a proposed £190,000 budget to prepare selective licensing across eight Margate and Ramsgate wards; members called the scheme a 'broad brush approach' and a 'tax on the landlord'.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeAgreedDecision text records criticism and questions; full minutes not supplied
Money£190,000 proposedFrom Invest to Save Reserve, for consultant and set-up
What happens nextPublic consultation spring 2026Designation could go live spring 2027 if approved
Who it affectsAbout 12,625 private rented homesEight wards in Margate (7,055) and Ramsgate (5,570)
What was decided
The decision extract records that members agreed the proposal was a 'broad brush approach' and a 'tax on the landlord' likely passed to tenants.
Members questioned spending an extra £190,000 on top of £50,000 already spent, with no committed outcome, and suggested supporting existing private housing enforcement instead.
Councillor Whitehead responded that the council will enforce the Renters' Rights Act and expects a major rise in cases, that the fee equates to about £1.32 per month, and that the earlier Margate Central and Cliftonville West scheme led to significant property value rises.
Why
The Private Sector Housing team lacks the resources and specialist expertise to design and consult on two simultaneous five-year designations and to withstand legal challenge. Report P17, P18, P29, P33
The eight wards are among the 30% most deprived in England, four in the 10% most deprived, and show higher-than-average poor housing conditions and low energy efficiency. Report P25, P83, P84, P86, P92, P93
The Renters' Rights Bill is expected to add enforcement duties, with Shelter estimating a 25% rise in housing condition complaints after no-fault evictions are abolished. Report P52
What happens next
If funding is approved, appoint a specialist consultant (estimated £145,000) plus £45,000 for related costs, run a 12-week statutory consultation, and produce designation documents. Report P34, P35, P59, P60, P65
Members raised the option of deferring the decision until after the Renters' Rights Bill outcome; the Cabinet Member argued prevention is needed now.
If the council pulls out, aborted costs are estimated at £50,000 before consultation and £175,000 after; a successful judicial review could mean repaying up to £6.5 million in licence fees. Report P40, P41, P43, P48, P79
The money
£190,000 Requested budget to prepare and potentially implement two selective licensing designations, from the Invest to Save Reserve Report P11, P14, P65
£145,000 Estimated cost of a specialist consultant to run the legislative process and consultation Report P34, P65
£45,000 Additional related expenditure, forward-funded through the Invest to Save Reserve Report P65
£50,000 Anticipated aborted costs if Cabinet decides not to proceed before public consultation; also reported as already spent on prior work Report P40, P46
£175,000 Anticipated aborted costs if Cabinet decides not to designate after the consultation Report P40, P47
£6.5m Estimated total licence fee revenue at £800 per property, and the maximum exposure if a judicial review forces repayment Report P48, P64, P79
£800 Proposed licence fee per property, used to recover scheme costs Report P64, P72, P76
£2.5m Estimated staffing and ancillary cost in years one and two to process over 6,000 applications Report P43
Options considered
Chosen or rejected: Appoint specialist consultant and progress two selective licensing designations in eight wards (recommended). Officers say in-house delivery is not viable; specialist support needed for legal compliance and timely delivery Report P14, P32, P33, P53
Rejected: Deliver the project in-house with existing Private Sector Housing team. Team at capacity, lacks expertise for a large discretionary scheme, and faces added duties from the Renters' Rights Bill Report P51, P52, P53
Rejected: Continue business as usual without considering selective licensing designations. Would miss corporate plan priorities, miss chance to improve conditions and health outcomes, and fail to identify vulnerable tenants through proactive inspections Report P54, P55, P56, P57, P58
Implications
Financial: £190,000 drawn from the Invest to Save Reserve, with up to £6.5 million at risk if a judicial review succeeds and licence fees must be refunded Report P14, P48, P65, P79
Legal: Designation can be challenged by judicial review on illegality, procedural impropriety or irrationality; prior council scheme was challenged in 2011 Report P29, P70, P77
Equalities: Equality Impact Assessment screening completed; scheme expected to help families with young children, older persons and disabled tenants in poor accommodation Report P89, P96
Climate: 3,695 private rented properties in the proposed wards have EPC ratings E, F or G; selective licensing would increase inspections and enforcement of the Minimum Energy Efficiency Standard Report P84, P85, P86, P87
Risk: Scheme is six times larger than previous council schemes, landlord opposition is expected, and a successful judicial review could leave a significant burden on the General Fund Report P76, P79, P80, P81, P82
Staffing: Specialist consultant plus barrister oversight required; PSH team cannot run the scheme alone and will also face Renters' Rights Act enforcement duties Report P17, P18, P52
Who and where
Private landlords in eight wards of Margate and Ramsgate, expected to pay an £800 licence fee per property Report P25, P64, P76
Private tenants in those wards, including families with young children, older people and disabled people Report P25, P89
The council's Private Sector Housing team, which will gain new enforcement duties under the Renters' Rights Act Report P17, P52
Vulnerable tenants in deprived areas who may not self-report poor conditions, identified through proactive inspections Report P58, P92, P93
Timeline
April 2017 to March 2023: Period covered by most data used in the Metastreet housing condition survey Report P23
December 2023: Metastreet final report on the private rented sector received Report P23
February 2024: Cadence Innova feasibility report on selective licensing designations Report P24
January 2025: Initial findings of latest English Housing Survey data released Report P27
End of October 2025: Updated Indices of Multiple Deprivation expected to be released Report P27
Spring 2026: Public consultation could begin if funding is approved Report P60
Spring 2027: Earliest possible designation go-live date Report P61
20 November 2025: Extraordinary Council debated the £190,000 budget request Report P2
Plain English for the jargon
Selective licensing: A scheme under Part 3 of the Housing Act 2004 requiring all privately rented homes in a designated area to be licensed by the local authority
HMO: House in Multiple Occupation, a property shared by tenants who are not from the same household
IMD: Indices of Multiple Deprivation, the official measure of relative deprivation in England
EPC: Energy Performance Certificate, rating a property's energy efficiency from A (best) to G (worst)
MEES: Minimum Energy Efficiency Standard, requiring rented properties to reach at least EPC band E
PSH team: Private Sector Housing team within the council
Invest to Save Reserve: Council reserve used to fund up-front work expected to be recovered later
MHCLG: Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, which issues guidance on selective licensing
General Approval 2024: Approval that lets councils make selective licensing designations without Secretary of State sign-off
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item5
Resolved
It was agreed with the view that the proposal was a “broad brush approach” and a " tax on the landlord" that would be passed to the tenant. It was argued that this would negatively impact those on the lowest incomes and in receipt of benefits due to increased local housing allowance claims, potentially leading to a “ self defeating spiral.” They questioned the spending of an additional £190,000 ( after an initial £50,000 had already been spent) without a dedicated commitment to an outcome and suggested that current enforcement by the private housing team should be supported instead. · Questioning was raised regarding postponing the decision until the outcome of the Renters’ Rights Bill was clearer, suggesting this would move the cost to the next financial year and might result in less need for the scheme. Councillor Whitehead responded with the following comments: · The Council would be responsible for enforcing the Renters’ Rights Act and was expecting a significant increase in cases, which made the selective licensing preventative measures essential. · Regarding the costs being passed to tenants, it was stated that the fee equated to approximately £1.32 per month. · It was also noted that the previous introduction of the selective licensing system in Margate Central and Cliftonville West had resulted in significant increases in property values. Councillor ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Word for word from the decision Thanet published for this meeting.Source: democracy.thanet.gov.uk
1. Approve a £190,000 budget to progress proposals for selective licensing as set out in this report, to be funded from the Invest to Save Reserve.
2. Considerthefinancialriskofusingfundsthatmaynotberecoveredifthe selective licensing designations do not proceed.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.