RESOLVED, Cabinet 1. Approved the extension of advisor contracts for those professional advisors as stated in this paper to provide continuity of advice to support the final phase of the Divestment Strategy and agrees that these are met from the Transformation Reserve. 2. Noted the Council’s direct professional fees incurred to date and future cost estimates to implement its Divestment Strategy including potential litigation proceedings. 3. Endorsed the third-party administration costs associated with two companies within the Council’s investment portfolio that have been placed into administration (Toucan and JLG/JCF) and the arrangements that are in place to review and challenge theses costs. 4. Noted that a separate paper on the sale of the Toucan assets will be provided to Cabinet following sale completion and resolution of a number of outstanding matters associated with the transaction/sale. 5. Noted the programme management arrangements in place to provide oversight of the Divestment Strategy, including the administrations and the criteria used to consider litigation proceedings. 6. Updated Council on the above decisions in appropriate feedback sessions. Reason for decision: as outlined in the report. This decision is subject to call-in.
Word for word from the decision Thurrock published for this meeting.Source: democracy.thurrock.gov.uk
The Council has agreed to pursue a Divestment Strategy to reduce the scale of its investment portfolio which was in excess of £1bn at the start of the financial year. This strategy is critical to the Council’s financial recovery and will enable it to reduce its level of debt, reduce borrowing costs and reduce its exposure to commercial and financial risk.
This has become a more complex task, and even more time critical, due to two companies in the Council’s investment portfolio being placed into administration in November and December 2022 (Toucan1 and JLG/JCF2). The company directors appointed administrators to run the companies and prepare for asset sale (Toucan) and service the loan book to recover debts (JLG/JCF). The Toucan sale complete in February 2024 which will result in total distributions to the Council of c.£510m in FY 2023/24 with further distributions expected in FY 24/25. The JLG/JCF administration process will continue into FY 2024/25 with distributions expected to be paid to the Council on an ongoing basis as the loan book is recovered.
Given the Council’s lack of expertise, experience and capacity to engage in complex administration processes, the Council has used a number of specialist financial and legal advisors to protect the Council’s interests and work with the administrators to realise timely distributions to the Council. They have also gathered information and undertaken investigations to inform potential litigation proceedings to recover anticipated financial losses.
This report sets out the Council’s contractual arrangements with its advisors, professional fees to date and an estimate of future costs to deliver the Divestment Strategy and support the administration processes. It does not seek to provide a comprehensive update on the status of the
1 Toucan Energy Holdings Ltd (TEH) was placed into administration – referred to as “Toucan” 2 Companies are Just Loans Group (JLG) and Just Cashflow (JCF)
Version - Final divestment programme, ongoing investigations and litigation, although some commentary is included to provide context to current and future estimates for professional fees to deliver the Divestment Strategy.
It is recommended that contracts for professional advisors are extended to provide continuity of advice during the critical final period of the Divestment Strategy, including potential litigation proceedings.
The Council has developed a robust approach to managing its divestment workstreams including the oversight of its professional fees. They remain broadly in line with previous estimates provided to Cabinet at c.£11.1m (was £11m) up to the end of FY 25/26. Costs as set out in this report reflect the latest cost estimates for potential litigation proceedings (Toucan and JLG/JCF) which will remain subject to regular revision as actions and timescales are determined. Investigative work and supporting analysis are now more advanced, with the Council and administrators due to compare and prioritise claims and agree actions. This specialist resource has enabled the Council to divest and/or recover amounts from companies in administration (in excess of £630m before the end of FY 24/25) with further amounts anticipated in FY 25/26.
Commissioner Comment:
Commissioners have been consulted on the content of this report and agree with the recommendations made.
1. Recommendation(s)
1.1That Cabinet:
Approves the extension of advisor contracts for those professional advisors as stated in this paper to provide continuity of advice to support the final phase of the Divestment Strategy and agrees that these are met from the Transformation Reserve.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Thurrock Transport Strategy Adoption2.1 Cabinet approved the Thurrock Transport Strategy given in Appendix 1 to be progressed to Full Council for adoptio...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.