CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Torridge District Council
External Overview & Scrutiny, Wednesday 29 March 2017 at 6.00pm

Impact Evaluation

Approved Scrutiny 2 papers

External Overview & Scrutiny approved this item on Wednesday 29 March 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item72

Resolved

That the recommendations be approved for implementation as follows: i. Provide annual information to partners about the scrutiny role of the Committee and a listing of its current membership; and to include in the Members’ Bulletin and distribute to OMT/SMT. ii. Ensure that partner presentations are acknowledged and that any recommendations are communicated to them. iii. Review the process whereby key points of partner presentations are communicated to all Councillors and relevant Officers of the Council. iv. Provide partners with a named contact - Councillor or Officer - for communication between Committee meetings. And – That a separate report be compiled and added to the Forward Plan, to include i. The themes identified be used to develop a rating scale questionnaire for periodic evaluation of the Committee by partners and elected Members.. ii. Qualitative re-evaluation of the Committee every 4-year election cycle be engaged in, in order to review key themes. iii. A procedure be instituted, with partners, for following up on Committee recommendations in order to assess the objective impact of scrutiny. iv. Initiate discussions with Officers and partners about the potential for joint working between partners and the Council. (Vote: For – unanimous)
Word for word from the decision Torridge published for this meeting. Source: democracy.torridge.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Torridge's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to External Overview & Scrutiny

Torridge District Council External Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Evaluation of Impact – Partner Survey 2016

Phil Topham Non-elected independent member Aims of the survey

• To ask our external partners about the impact of this Committee on their work.

• To ask how we might do things differently. Participants •Questions and invitation letter to partners •Presented to OSC in last two years •10 participants; five receiving TDC funding •Diverse in size and contacts with TDC Interview Survey • To what extent is the relationship with the Committee helpful to your organisation? [0-10] • To what extent does the relationship with the Committee help your organisation to achieve specific aims and objectives? [0-10] • To what extent are meetings with the Committee (presentations and discussion) helpful to your organisation? [0-10] • To what extent do you think that the Committee provides a useful public service? [0-10] •What suggestions would you like to make about how the Committee meetings could be improved to make them more helpful to your organisation? •What suggestions would you like to make about how the relationship between your organisation and the Committee / Torridge District Council could be improved? •Are there any other comments you would like to make about the External Overview and Scrutiny Committee? Procedure • 10 interviews x 1 hour

• Welcomed and approved

• Recording the interview

• Interviewee checks the record Partner ratings Relationship with the Committee is helpful 72.2% (range 3-9) Committee provides a useful public service 68% (range 4-10) Meetings with the Committee are helpful 63.5% (range 5-9) Relationship with the Committee helps achieve specific aims and objectives 60% (range 0-9) Thematic analysis of interviews • Method of categorising data • Sort responses by similarity of content • Identify recurring themes • Condense and account for all the data • Summarise key features of each theme • Select examples to evidence each theme • Ask colleague to review analysis Five Main Themes Understanding A conduit to

our work the community

Relationships with the Committee

Ensuring value Work more for money closely together Relationships with the Committee: There is a generally positive perception of working relations with the Committee and the Council. It is good to be able to come to the Committee. We have a good relationship.

I always felt appreciated for what we did. The Chair always made appreciative comments about our work.

It is not currently a particularly close relationship but it is much better than nothing, and can certainly be built upon. Understanding our work: It is important for partners to describe their work to the Committee, its scope and the challenges they face.

The presentation means the committee is aware of what we do and able to ask questions and steer delivery.

It has allowed us to clarify matters and to deal with myths and misunderstandings.

Presentation and discussion is helpful – two-way. Questions show interest in what we do. A conduit to the community: Partners value the Committee as a two-way link between the Council and the community.

... provides us with a consolidation of public views condensed and communicated via Councillors.

....allows a democratic voice into the decision-making process; at the Committee it feels like you’re talking to the locals.

...it is our only inroad into the Members. They hear our work, we learn their priorities. Ensuring value for money: Both funded and non- funded partners are committed to providing value for money.

As one of our funders we need to know what you need.

Helpful for us to educate the Committee so they’re well informed about whether we’re good value.

Have received solid support from TDC in recent years – like to think that’s because we’ve demonstrated good value for money. Work more closely together: Partners see scrutiny meetings as a potential opportunity to explore joint working towards shared objectives.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Ext OSC Impact Evaln_Presn slidesReport 152 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Impact EvaluationReport 299 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

9 of 14 attended
SI
Councillor Simon InchChair, present
PP
Councillor Philip PenningtonVice-Chair, present
RD
Councillor Roger DarchCommittee Member, present
AE
Councillor Andrew EastmanCommittee Member, present
TJ
Councillor Trevor JohnsCommittee Member, present
IP
Councillor Ian ParkerCommittee Member, present
AW
Councillor Alan WhittleCommittee Member, apologies
AD
Councillor Anna DartCommittee Member, apologies
PT
Phillip TophamNon-elected, voting, present
AB
Councillor Alison BoyleCommittee Member, apologies, sent representative
JH
Jamie HollisOfficer, in attendance
MR
Mary RichardsOfficer, in attendance

All 14 on the meeting page

On this subject at Torridge

Search all
  1. Impact EvaluationThis decision
  2. 6 month Review of Impact EvaluationDecided
  3. Impact Evaluation QuestionnaireDecided
  4. Impact EvaluationAgreed

More from Torridge External Overview & Scrutiny

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
15 Jul 2026 MinutesThat the minutes of the meeting held on 03 June 2026 be agreed and signed as a correct record, with the above amendme... Agreed Open
3 Jun 2026 MinutesThat the minutes of the meeting held on 01 April 2026 be confirmed and signed as a correct record. (Vote: 3 For and 4... Decided Open
3 Jun 2026 Chair's Report - Proposed Extension of Rail Services to BidefordThat the report be taken to Full Council for debate, with an amendment to the recommendations, removing recommendatio... Decided Open
1 Apr 2026 MinutesThat the minutes of the meeting held on Wednesday 25 February 2026 be agreed and signed as a correct record. (Vote: 6... Agreed Open
1 Apr 2026 Consideration Of The Forward PlanIt was agreed by Members that RLNI and Coastguard would also be contacted regarding the 2026-27 meeting cycle. Counci... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies