CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Trafford Metropolitan Borough Council
Executive, Monday 21 March 2022 at 6.30pm

Scrutiny Review Outcomes Report

Noted Executive 4 papers

Executive noted this item on Monday 21 March 2022. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item111

Resolved

RESOLVED - (1) That the work of the Scrutiny Review Panel, and the recommendation to the Executive and to Council made by the Scrutiny Committee, be noted. (2) That the proposals as detailed in the report be agreed. (3) That approval of the proposals be recommended to Council.
Word for word from the decision Trafford published for this meeting. Source: democratic.trafford.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Trafford's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive

Summary

This report provides a summary of the work undertaken by the Scrutiny Review Panel including: areas reviewed; areas of success and areas of potential improvement; and details of proposed improvements which are currently being considered by Members.

It should be noted that the scrutiny function review undertaken by the Scrutiny Review Panel and of the Centre for Governance and Scrutiny, has highlighted that Scrutiny function at Trafford is effective and that proposed changes are around process and procedure, rather than fundamental changes.

Recommendations

That the Executive: i) notes the work of the Scrutiny Review Panel and the recommendation to the Executive and to Council made by the Scrutiny Committee; ii) agrees the proposals as detailed in the report; and iii) recommends approval of the proposals to Council.

Contact person for access to background papers and further information:

Name: John Addison Background Papers: N/A

1 Relationship to Policy The purpose of scrutiny is ultimately to improve the lives Framework/Corporate Priorities of local people through improved public services. To justify the resources allocated to scrutiny it is important to be able to demonstrate that scrutiny work adds value and makes a difference to local people.

Effective scrutiny can be demonstrated if it fulfils one or more of the following conditions:

• it meets the objectives set out by the scrutiny committee

• feedback from the public shows that they think there has been the service improvement they desired

• the work has helped to achieve corporate or partnership priorities

• there is a return on investment, demonstrating scrutiny’s impact and outcomes in financial terms.

Relationship to GM Policy or N/A

Strategy Framework

Financial Note potential financial implications detailed in section 7 of the report. Any additional requests for financial resources would need to be considered against other priorities as part of future budget rounds.

Legal Implications: In accordance with the Local Government Act 2000 and Localism Act 2011, authorities are required to have a mechanism by which the Executive can be held to account via a transparent and robust scrutiny function.

The review of the Council’s scrutiny function was important to ensure that we have an effective scrutiny framework which adds value to the Council’s outputs.

Equality/Diversity Implications N/A

Sustainability Implications N/A

Carbon Reduction N/A

Resource Implications e.g. Staffing / The resource implications are detailed in the report. ICT / Assets

Risk Management Implications N/A

2 Health & Wellbeing Implications N/A

Health and Safety Implications N/A

Background

1.1In November 2018, following the submission of a report from the cross-party constitutional working group, Full Council agreed changes to the Constitution in order to increase openness, transparency and public engagement in a number of governance areas. This work included recommendations to review the Council’s Scrutiny function with a view to identifying any areas for improvement.

1.2In July 2021 a cross party scrutiny review panel was established for the purpose of: reviewing the Council’s current scrutiny arrangements; considering evidence gathered; and to make recommendations as to how the scrutiny arrangements could be improved. In addition to the internal review the Council engaged the Centre for Governance and Scrutiny to provide an external viewpoint on scrutiny in Trafford.

1.3The review took place over the course of the 2021/22 municipal year with an intention that recommendations are made to Council in 2022 in time to be implemented for the 2022/23 municipal year.

1.4The Review Panel’s proposals, as detailed in the report, were considered by the Scrutiny Committee on 16 March 2022. The Scrutiny Committee agreed the proposals and recommend approval of the proposals to the Executive and Council.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Trafford SIR: report letterAppendix 1 322 KB Download
PDF
_Scrutiny Topic Assessment_Selection CriteriaAppendix 2 276 KB Download
PDF
Scrutiny Work flowAppendix 3 172 KB Download
PDF
Scrutiny Review Outcomes ReportReport 403 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

12 of 27 attended
AW
Councillor Andrew WesternChair, present
CH
Councillor Catherine HynesDeputy Leader, present
SA
Councillor Stephen AdsheadCommittee Member, present
MF
Councillor Mike FreemanCommittee Member, apologies
JH
Councillor Joanne HardingCommittee Member, present
LP
Councillor Liz PatelCommittee Member, present
TR
Councillor Tom RossCommittee Member, present
JS
Councillor Jane SlaterCommittee Member, apologies
GW
Councillor Graham WhithamCommittee Member, apologies
JA
Councillor James Alexander WrightCommittee Member, apologies
DA
Councillor David ActonGuest, apologies
ML
Councillor Miss Linda BlackburnGuest, in attendance

All 27 on the meeting page

On this subject at Trafford

Search all
  1. Scrutiny Review Outcomes ReportThis decision
  2. Scrutiny Review 2024/2025 Outcomes ReportApproved
  3. Overview and Scrutiny Review of the Executive's Draft Budget Proposals for 2025-2026Decided
  4. Overview and scrutiny review of the executive's draft budget proposals for 2024-2025Decided
  5. Scrutiny Committee - Task and Finish Group: Review of Disability Access within Trafford - Response to Interim ReportNoted
  6. Scrutiny review implementation 2022/23Noted

More from Trafford Executive

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
21 Sep 2026 Greater Manchester End to End Fostering Recruitment Hub1) That the national and Greater Manchester context supporting the developments of the Greater Manchester End-to-End ... Approved Open
21 Sep 2026 Sale Waterside Private Finance Initiative Exit1) That the hand back of the Sale Waterside PFI assets to Council ownership on expiry of the PFI contract on 28 th Oc... Approved Open
20 Jul 2026 Wharfside Strategic MasterplanThat the Executive: (i) Approves the draft Trafford for consultation. (ii) (ii) Delegates authority to the Corporate ... Approved Open
20 Jul 2026 Local Plan Regulation 19 Consultation ApprovalThat the Executive: (i) Approves the Trafford Local Plan (Publication Version) 2026, including allocations, designati... Approved Open
15 Jun 2026 Trafford Good Growth Plan 2026/27(1) That the progress achieved against the actions contained in the Inclusive Economy and Delivery Plan, be noted. (2... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies