CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Tunbridge Wells Borough Council
Conduct Hearing Panel, Thursday 2 April 2015 at 10.00am

Appendix A - Decision Notice

Noted Committee

Conduct Hearing Panel noted this item on Thursday 2 April 2015. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item9

Resolved

Councillor Goodman’s conduct amounted to a failure to comply with paragraphs 1 and 2 of the Code of Conduct. Paragraph 1 states that “He/she shall behave in such a way that a reasonable person would regard as respectful” Paragraph 2 states that “He/she shall not act in a way which a reasonable person would regard as bullying or intimidatory .” Allegation 2 – Meeting of the Planning and Environment Committee on 4 March 2013. It was alleged by Christine Darbyshir that, during a meeting of the Planning and Environment Committee, Councillor Goodman subjected her to harassment by shouting at her whilst she serviced the meeting; his behaviour making her feel belittled and incompetent. Finding of facts: (i) The Hearing Panel acknowledged that the fact that the minutes were asked for was not disputed, however there was a difference of opinion as to how these minutes were asked for. (ii) The Hearing Panel did not consider that the request to produce a copy of the minutes belittled Christine Darbyshir , and it was noted that she did admit in her interview that it was unlikely that the other councillors even noticed what was going on and were unlikely to think she was incompetent. (iii) The Hearing Panel considered that the evidence produced by Councillor Nicholls supported Councillor Goodman’s assertion that the debate was between them and not directed at Christine Darbyshir . In addition, Councillor Nicholls stated that the request to produce the minutes did not reflect negatively on Christine Darbyshir , as there would be no expectation for her to produce minutes relating to a meeting held three years before. (iv) On balance the Hearing Panel did not believe that the events that occurred at this meeting, taken in isolation, amounted to harassment in themselves and that if any shouting did occur it was as part of the ‘boisterous’ meeting described by Councillor Nicholls and was not out of the ordinary. Hearing Panel’s No breach of the Code of Conduct. Allegation 3 – Visit to the Council Offices on 5 March 2013. It was alleged by Christine Darbyshir that, on 5 March 2013, Councillor Goodman stormed into the Council offices and subjected her to a barrage of shouting, bullying and intimidating behaviour. Finding of facts: (i) The Hearing Panel acknowledged that it was not disputed by either party that Councillor Goodman visited the Council offices on 5 March 2013 with his wife whilst Christine Darbyshir was there alone. (ii) The Hearing Panel took account of the statement from Councillor Hamilton as to Christine Darbyshir’s distress following the visit by Councillor Goodman to the Council offices which members felt added weight to Christine Darbyshir’s account of the incident. (iii) The Hearing Panel considered Elizabeth Goodman’s evidence and noted that the wording was almost identical to that used in Councillor Goodman’s own account of events. Whilst the Hearing Panel did not dispute that she was outside of the offices, there was doubt as to how much of the incident was witnessed. In addition, the Hearing Panel did not consider Elizabeth Goodman to be a truly independent witness. (iv) The Hearing Panel took account of the Investigating Officer’s view that Christine Darbyshir was a credible witness and on the balance of probabilities (which was the standard of proof to be met in these matters) believed that the events that occurred on 5 March 2013 were as she described. Hearing Panel’s Councillor Goodman’s conduct amounted to a failure to comply with paragraphs 1 and 2 of the Code of Conduct. Paragraph 1 states that “He/she shall behave in such a way that a reasonable person would regard as respectful” Paragraph 2 states that “He/she shall not act in a way which a reasonable person would regard as bullying or intimidatory .” Sanctions applied The Hearing Panel agreed that the breach of the Paddock Wood Town Council’s Code of Conduct warrants the following sanctions: (1) Training for Councillor Goodman on the Code of Conduct, to be delivered within two months of the next election if he remains a councillor; (2) Training for all Paddock Wood Town Councillors on the Code of Conduct and the role of a councillor, to be delivered within two months of the next election (and thereafter within two months of the election of any new councillors), and other training provided as deemed appropriate; (3) That Paddock Wood Town Council considers how best to support each individual member within the Council and provide suitable provision for this; and (4) That Councillor Goodman only be allowed to visit the Council offices by prior arrangement and in the presence of a third party for the next six months. In addition the Chairman stated that the Hearing Panel considered it unfortunate that Councillor Goodman had failed to engage with the Investigating Officer throughout the investigation process. Appeal There is no right of appeal against the Hearing Panel’s decision. Notification of decision This decision notice is sent to the: · The subject member, Councillor Goodman · The complainant, Christine Darbyshir · The Borough Council’s Monitoring Officer · Clerk to the Paddock Wood Town Council · Tunbridge Wells Borough Council’s Audit and Governance Committee Additional help If you need additional support in relation to this decision notice or future contact with the Borough Council, please let us know as soon as possible. If you have difficulty reading this notice, we can make reasonable adjustments to assist you, in line with the requirements of the Equality Act 2010 . We can also help if English is not your first language. Please contact Wendy Newton-May, Local Democracy Officer, on 01892 554179, or email [email protected] Date: 9 April 2015 BOROUGH COUNCILLOR LEN HORWOOD Chairman of the Code of Conduct Sub-Committee Tunbridge Wells Borough Council Civic Way ROYAL TUNBRIDGE WELLS Kent TN1 1RS
Word for word from the decision Tunbridge Wells published for this meeting. Source: democracy.tunbridgewells.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Tunbridge Wells's papers

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in

No papers were published with this item. The decision above is the council's full record of it.

At this meeting

Whole meeting
7Code of Conduct Complaint against a Town CouncillorOn the agenda
9Appendix A - Decision NoticeThis decision

On this subject at Tunbridge Wells

Search all
  1. Appendix A - Decision NoticeThis decision
  2. Appendix A - Decision NoticeNoted

More from Tunbridge Wells Conduct Hearing Panel

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
15 Apr 2015 Appendix A - Decision NoticeDECISION NOTICE OF CODE OF CONDUCT HEARING PANEL 15 April 2015 Complaint No: T003595 (1) On 15 April 2015, the Code o... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies