The Executive has agreed to RECOMMEND to the COUNCIL that: 1. the new post of ‘Scrutiny Officer’ be added to the Council’s establishment as set out as option 3 within the report; and 2. a supplementary estimate to cover additional staffing costs in 2016/17 and growth proposals being put forward ...
Word for word from the decision Waverley published for this meeting.Source: modgov.waverley.gov.uk
OFFICER SUPPORT FOR OVERVIEW AND SCRUTINY - OPTIONS ANALYSIS
[Portfolio Holders: Councillor Julia Potts and Councillor Tom Martin] [Wards Affected: All]
Summary and purpose:
At its last meeting, the Executive received a report from the Joint Overview and Scrutiny Committee setting out the findings and recommendations from its review of Overview and Scrutiny at Waverley. The Executive noted the recommendation that ‘dedicated scrutiny officer support be secured’ and asked officers to put forward options. Accordingly, this report identifies and analyses options in respect of scrutiny staffing at Waverley. Executive Members are asked to consider the options set out within this report and decide upon a way forward.
How this report relates to the Council’s Corporate Priorities: An effective Overview and Scrutiny function is a vital component of the Council’s Strong Leader and Executive governance model in that it ensures Executive decision-making is transparent, well-informed and accountable. The arrangements for staffing support for Overview and Scrutiny at Waverley therefore have a bearing on the full range of Executive decision-making and therefore relate to ALL of the Council’s priorities.
Financial Implications: Options 1 (do nothing) and 2 (reallocate workloads within the existing Democratic Services structure so that an existing Grade 7 Democratic Services Officer has responsibility for servicing all scrutiny committees) would incur no additional costs because they would not provide any additional resource.
Option 3 (create a new Grade 7 Scrutiny Officer post), which is recommended to the Executive, would cost £35,000 rising to £39,600 at 7a. (including salary, NI and pension). Pay band 7 is the anticipated grade and would be subject to the job evaluation process. As there is no pre-existing budget that would cover any increased staffing costs, this would require a supplementary estimate being agreed for 2016/17 and growth proposals being agreed during the next budget round.
Legal Implications: There are no direct legal implications.
Introduction
1. A Sub-Committee of the Joint Overview & Scrutiny Committee was appointed by the Executive to review the Terms of Reference and arrangements for Overview and Scrutiny (OS) at Waverley. 2. The Sub-Committee discussed this remit and in view of the length of time since OS arrangements were last reviewed comprehensively and along with anecdotal evidence of member dissatisfaction with OS arrangements, agreed that the review should be undertaken in the context of evaluating the effectiveness of Waverley’s OS function in relation to the four principles of effective scrutiny as described by the Centre for Public Scrutiny (CfPS). According to the four principles, good scrutiny:
provides a constructive ‘critical friend’ challenge – holding decision- makers to account; amplifies the voices and concerns of the public; is led by independent people who take responsibility for their role; and drives improvement in public services and makes a difference.
3. As part of its evidence gathering, the Sub-Committee sought the views of Waverley Members through a survey and interviews. The feedback received indicated a high level of frustration with the way in which the current arrangements operate, and an appetite for the scrutiny function at Waverley taking a more constructive and proactive role in supporting the work of the Council. The desktop research carried out into OS arrangements at other councils, and a review of academic research into OS arrangements generally, shows that the issues that Waverley has with its OS arrangements are not uncommon.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.