Resolved
(1) That an eight week period of public consultation on alternative options for the future of the Welwyn Garden City Estate Management Scheme be agreed to take the form of a letter to all residents within the Scheme area, a slightly different letter to all other residents who lived in Welwyn Garden City but were not within the Scheme area and less targeted consultation via the Council’s website and other communication channels such as newspaper adverts to other residents and bodies who might have an interest in the Scheme with agreement of the consultation letter(s) with Counsel to mitigate any later challenges. (2) That a future report be made to the Cabinet setting out the responses to the public consultation and recommending a preferred way forward as a consequence of those responses. (2) Reasons for the Decision The Cabinet considered a report in July 2015 which sought to resolve ongoing problems with the administration and enforcement of Welwyn Garden City Estate Management Scheme. It proposed to replace the Scheme with an Article 4 Direction and to apply to the High Court Tribunal to vary or terminate the Scheme. The Officers had followed up various issues since then, including legal advice on the merits of the intended way forward. This highlighted a number of issues, namely that an Article 4 Direction needed to provide at least the equivalent protection as the existing Scheme, that issues that could not be satisfactorily covered by an Article 4 Direction should be retained as part of the Scheme and that the Council should publicly consult on this and alternative options before proceeding with any preferred option. The current Scheme had many challenges, often as a result of different tenures: There were strong policies to guide the determination of applications, but a weak enforcement regime. The Council could take enforcement action against freehold properties by negotiating on an informal basis, referring the matter to arbitration (at a cost of £2,500 per case) and finally taking action through the Courts. However, the Council must take enforcement action against leasehold properties through the Law of Property Act 1925 by writing to its tenants to ask for a breach to be remedied, seeking compensation for damage to the value of the estate or forfeiture of the lease (eviction). Housing Trust properties were subject to their own covenants and action was taken by the Trust. Costs: § The planning service handled approximately 600 Scheme applications per year, but there was no fee § The ... view the full minutes text for item 39b