Resolved
Decision Planning permission be REFUSED for the following reasons: Policy DM5 (Development in the countryside) sets out forms of development that will be permitted in the countryside (affordable, rural workers dwellings, replacement dwellings and infill where there is a cluster of 10 or more existing dwellings). Policy DM27 permits dwellings in the rural area subject to certain criteria, amongst which are a requirement for dwellings to be proposed adjacent to or fronting an existing highway. In this regard, therefore, conflict with DM27 is identified. The dwelling is proposed above a garage, in a location where a single storey garage structure was previously proposed. However, the position of the proposed dwelling is set back behind those dwellings at the front, away from the road frontage in a way that does not comply with the requirement for it to be within a ‘frontage’ and ‘adjacent to or fronting a road’. In this case the dwelling is proposed back from the road, behind the extant dwellings on the frontage and it does not therefore comply with the provisions of DM27. As a consequence of this, conflict is also identified with the requirements of Policies DM5 and CS1. The NPPF states development should be “visually attractive as a result of good architecture, layout and appropriate and effective landscaping”, should be “sympathetic to local character history, including the surrounding built environment and landscape setting” and maintain a strong sense of place… building types and materials to create attractive, welcoming and distinctive places to live”. It further states “Development that is not well designed should be refused. Local policies in DM2 and DM22 further support these principles, as does DM27. It is considered that the proposal with its lack of fenestration, high eaves line and blank rear elevation, along with its scale, would have a hostile and intrusive impact within this location to the rear of the consented properties, and as a result is considered to be discordant and out of ... view the full minutes text for item 268.