CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Winchester City Council
Cabinet, Tuesday 21 July 2026 at 9.30am

Securing the future of Guildhall and Abbey House (less exempt appendices)

Approved Executive 1 paper

AI summaryWinchester Cabinet approves marketing the Guildhall and Abbey House for an occupational lease, with a £97k budget to relocate the Walton Suite and other offices into City Offices.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedFormal marketing of Guildhall and Abbey House as combined and separate lots
Money£97k budget agreed
What happens nextFurther Cabinet reportOn marketing outcome before the Council enters into any lease
Who it affectsGuildhall and Abbey House usersEvent hirers, community groups, council staff, visitors and residents of Winchester

What was decided

Cabinet approved the formal marketing of the Guildhall and Abbey House to secure an offer for an occupational lease, offered as combined and separate lots, retaining the council's freehold. Report P2, 3.1

Cabinet agreed a £97k budget for relocating the Walton Suite and other Guildhall offices into City Offices, plus other one-off costs tied to the closure and refurbishment. Report P3, 2.3

Cabinet noted that a further report will be brought back before the council enters into a lease, with an additional budget request possible. Report P4, 2.6

Why

The Guildhall currently runs at a net operating cost and the council wants a financially sustainable model; soft market testing suggested a specialist operator could generate over £500,000 of net income in the first ten years, alongside savings of almost £3.7m over ten years. Report 2.1, 2.2

The buildings are listed heritage assets with high maintenance complexity, and a specialist event venue operator is seen as bringing management expertise, procurement savings and broader market reach that the council cannot match on its own. Report 5.1, P10

Stakeholder engagement by Blue Horizon found consistent support for the venue's heritage value but criticism of outdated infrastructure, weak marketing, high running costs and limited programming, which an operator model is intended to address. Report P43, P44, P46, P49

What happens next

Marketing to begin on 28/7/26, with operator submissions from September 2026, a preferred operator identified by December 2026 and Cabinet asked in February 2027 whether to enter into a lease, with agreement for lease around March or April 2027 and the new venues opening from July 2028. Report P76, 11.14

Blue Horizon will run the marketing exercise on capped fees; the lease will be at least 20 years, include a user clause, allow specified civic events and reserve the right to refuse the best offer. Report 11.10, 11.11, P59

Strategic capital works under CAB 3541 are to be completed before the lease is granted so the operator can shape fit-out, and a further report will set out any extra refurbishment contribution the council may need to make. Report 5.2, 2.6, 11.12

The money

  • £ 97k One-off budget for relocating the Walton Suite and other Guildhall offices to City Offices and other closure costs Report P3, 2.3
  • over £500,000 Forecast net income to the council from a letting over the first ten years, on top of operating cost savings Report 2.1
  • just over £300k Forecast annual savings versus current Guildhall operations Report 2.2
  • almost £3.7m Forecast savings over 10 years once forecast lease income is included Report 2.2
  • c£250k Estimated savings during the 14 month closure for essential works, including maintenance budget not spent Report 2.3
  • £335k Estimated further council maintenance spend on the Guildhall over the next 10 years after the main works Report 2.4
  • £5m Already committed council funding for essential and structural repairs to the Guildhall and Abbey House Report 2.6, P84
  • approximately £20,000 Estimated one-off cost of a temporary relocation of the Visitor Information Centre during the investment works, if needed Report 2.5
  • £603k Forecast annual revenue expenditure savings under the operator model Report P28
  • £250k Forecast loss of income per year under the operator model Report P28
  • £40k Annual cost of using city office space under the operator model Report P28
  • £313k Net ongoing annual revenue savings under the operator model Report P28
  • £45k One-off fitting out costs Report P30
  • £52k One-off costs associated with the closure of the Guildhall Report P30

Options considered

  • Chosen: Lease the Guildhall and Abbey House to a specialist event venue operator, offered as combined and separate lots (chosen). Forecast to deliver over £500,000 of net income in the first ten years, around £313,000 a year of net revenue savings and better use of a listed heritage asset, while the council keeps the freehold. Report P2, 2.1, 2.2, 11.11
  • Rejected: Continue to manage the Guildhall and Abbey House directly, either as dry facilities or as a fully serviced venue employing around 23 staff (Option 1). Past direct management models, including the pre-Covid fully serviced model, have not generated a profit and do not optimise use of the buildings. Report 12.1, P80, P81, P82
  • Rejected: Close the buildings to public use and consider freehold disposal (Option 2). Holding costs would be significant, the £5m already committed for essential maintenance makes closure hard to justify, and loss of freehold control over a building of historical and cultural importance is not acceptable. Report 12.2, P84, P85

Implications

  • Financial: Forecast net ongoing revenue savings of £313,000 a year and almost £3.7m over ten years, plus a £97k one-off budget, with a possible further contribution to operator refurbishment costs to be reported back to Cabinet. Report P28, 2.2, 2.6, P3
  • Legal: The council will retain the freehold and offer a lease only, with a user clause and a minimum 20 year term; the arrangement is a property transaction, not a procurement, and the council must satisfy its best consideration duty under section 123 of the Local Government Act 1972. Report 3.1, 3.2, 11.11
  • Equalities: No direct public sector equality duties arise, but accessibility requirements will be built into the lease to protect access to the buildings. Report 8.1, P57
  • Climate: Energy efficiency measures are to be included in the upcoming repairs and maintenance programme, and the operator will be expected to address the climate emergency in how they run the buildings. Report P8, 7.1, P55
  • Risk: Key risks include financial exposure, challenge to the letting, reputation, delivery of the outcome, timescales and project capacity ahead of Local Government Reorganisation; mitigations include capped marketing fees, a user clause, a Communications plan and aiming to complete the agreement for lease before any S24 Direction to a new unitary authority. Report P59, P60
  • Staffing: Before the Guildhall closes for refurbishment and repair, HR will support managers to apply the council's Managing Workforce Change policy to affected employees. Report 4.1, P36
  • Other: Alternative arrangements for civic events will need to be made if a lease is awarded, and a temporary Visitor Information Centre relocation could cost around £20,000 if needed during the works. Report P52, 2.5

Who and where

  • Existing Guildhall hirers, charities, businesses and community groups who use the venue for events Report P10, P45
  • Council staff in the Walton Suite, Democratic Services, business support, goods-in and the print room who will be relocated to City Offices Report 2.4, P3
  • Visitor Information Centre staff and visitors, with the future operating model still to be decided Report 2.4, 2.5
  • Current tenant Shoal, who occupy a unit within the proposed lease scope Report 2.4
  • Local performance, heritage and community organisations consulted during soft market testing Report 6.1, P42
  • Residents and visitors to Winchester, given the Guildhall's role in the visitor economy and Cultural Strategy Report 11.1, 11.2, 11.3

Timeline

  • 28/7/26: Subject to Cabinet decision, marketing of the Guildhall and Abbey House to begin Report P76
  • September 2026: Submissions from operators to be received Report P76
  • December 2026: Due diligence concluded and preferred operator identified Report P76
  • February 2027: Cabinet to consider operator submission and approve entering into lease Report P76
  • March/April 2027: Enter into agreement to lease Report P76
  • July 2028: New venues open following completion of works and lease to operator Report 11.14
  • 14 month closure period: Essential works to the Guildhall scheduled, with around £250,000 of savings expected during the closure Report 2.3

Plain English for the jargon

  • Occupational lease: A lease under which a tenant takes on the running of a building, paying rent to the landlord who keeps the freehold.
  • Grade II listed: A building of special interest included on the national statutory list of historic buildings, requiring listed building consent for alterations.
  • Soft market testing: Informal sounding of potential suppliers or tenants to gauge interest, terms and likely income before a formal marketing exercise.
  • User clause: A lease provision restricting the types of activity the tenant may carry on in the building.
  • Section 123 best consideration duty: Statutory duty under the Local Government Act 1972 requiring councils to obtain the best price reasonably obtainable when disposing of property.
  • CAB 3541: A separate Cabinet report covering the strategic capital works to the Guildhall and Abbey House.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item8

Resolved

That the formal marketing of the Guildhall and Abbey House to secure an offer for an occupational lease be approved as combined and separate lots. 2. That a budget of £ 97k for the reolocation of the Walton Suite and other Guildhall offices into City Offices as well as other one off costs be agreed. 3. That a further report will be presented on the outcome of the marketing exercise before the Council enters into the lease.
Word for word from the decision Winchester published for this meeting. Source: democracy.winchester.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Winchester's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

Recommendations

That Cabinet

1. approve the formal marketing of the Guildhall and Abbey House to secure an offer for an occupational lease as combined and seperate lots.

2. agree a budget of £ 97k for the reolocation of the Walton Suite and other Guildhall offices into City Offices as well as other one off costs.

3. Notes a further report will be presented on the outcome of the marketing exercise before the Council enters into the lease. CAB3529

IMPLICATIONS:

1 COUNCIL PLAN OUTCOME

1.1Greener Faster

The Guildhall is a Grade II listed building with associated limitations imposed on energy efficiency. However, the repairs and maintenance programme due to start next year will include energy saving measures designed to reduce CO2 emissions. The proposal is for an event Operator tenant to be responsible for maintaining new systems and ensuring efficient management.

1.2Thriving Places

The Guildhall is one of the largest event venues in Winchester serving the community, charities, businesses, and civic demands. A specialist event Operator will maintain access to the building for these groups and be able to offer an enhanced product and service.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Securing the future of Guildhall and Abbey House (less exempt appendices)Report 119 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

5 of 10 attended
MT
Councillor Martin TodChairperson, present
NC
Councillor Neil Cutler OBEVice-Chair, apologies
SC
Councillor Steve CramoysanCommittee Member, present
KB
Councillor Kathleen BeckerCommittee Member, apologies
KL
Councillor Kelsie LearneyCommittee Member, present
JP
Councillor Jackie PorterCommittee Member, present
MR
Councillor Mark ReachCommittee Member, apologies
LT
Councillor Lucille ThompsonCommittee Member, present
SG
Councillor Stephen GodfreyGuest, in attendance
MW
Councillor Malcolm WallaceGuest, in attendance

More from Winchester Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
25 Aug 2026 Membership of Cabinet bodies etc.That Councillor Laming be appointed as a deputy on the Hampshire and Solent Combined County Authority Planning Adviso... Decided Open
25 Aug 2026 Minutes of the previous meeting held on 21 July 2026That the minutes of the previous meeting held on 21 July 2026 be agreed as a correct record. Agreed Open
25 Aug 2026 St. Peter's Car Park: Proposed affordable housing scheme (less exempt appendix)That capital expenditure of up to £480,000 be authorised to allow for professional fees, site investigative work and ... Noted Open
25 Aug 2026 Central Winchester Regeneration (CWR) - updated business case (less exempt appendix)That the updated Business Case as presented in Appendix A and Exempt Appendix B be noted. 2. That the submission, by ... Noted Open
25 Aug 2026 To note the future items for consideration by Cabinet as shown on the September 2026 Forward Plan.That the list of future items as set out in the Forward Plan for September 2026 be noted. Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies