That: 1. The Committee recommended the following amendment to objective 2: “To compare the previous service levels of each participating Council with current levels and those outlined in the final business case;” 2. The Committee recommended that “performance” in objective 3 should include enforcement; and 3. Councillor Joy Squires be nominated as the Council’s representative, and Councillor Paul Denham be nominated as substitute.
Word for word from the decision Worcester published for this meeting.Source: committee.worcester.gov.uk
FRAMEWORK FOR JOINT OVERVIEW AND SCRUTINY IN WORCESTERSHIRE
Principles Underlying Joint Working
Any joint scrutiny process needs to ensure:
a) Good quality scrutiny – which adds value and properly investigates issues of concern to participating authorities. b) Efficiency – avoiding duplication and bureaucracy. c) Confidence in the outcomes of the joint scrutiny exercise by each participating authority’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee, and clear communication of expectations from the outset. d) Clear working planning and co-ordination. e) A coherent approach to scrutiny for external partner organisations f) Clear arrangements for reporting and follow-up to ensure action on recommendations. g) Reporting arrangements should not create delay through over complexity, and should not create scope for other bodies to block recommendations. h) Flexibility in how to carry out joint scrutiny. i) It does not undermine each authority's O&S Committee’s remit, or officer support available.
Deciding to Scrutinise Jointly
It is for each authority’s O&S Committee to decide if they wish to participate in a joint scrutiny but this needs to be done as efficiently and speedily as possible.
To initiate a joint scrutiny proposal a scoping form should be completed and circulated which will then be subject to agreement of each authority's O&S Committee.
The Worcestershire Scrutiny Officers’ Network, in consultation with their respective Chairmen should make proposals for joint scrutiny for considered by the scrutiny chairmen’s network (possibly in between meetings) and subsequent recommendation to individual overview and scrutiny committees.
Carrying out Joint Scrutiny
There are a number of ways that joint scrutiny can be carried out.
There may be times when an individual authority wishes to co-opt members from other authorities onto a particular scrutiny.
There may also be times when it is agreed by each O&S committee that one authority takes the lead in scrutinising an issue on behalf of all authorities.
However, it is suggested that in Worcestershire joint scrutiny should usually be carried out by joint time-limited scrutiny task and finish groups, led by the authority from which the scrutiny originated.
D:\moderngov\data\published\Intranet\C00000147\M00002987\AI00011484\$ej25i5yf.doc Agreeing Membership of Joint Scrutiny Task Group
After O&S Committees agree to participate in a joint scrutiny they then nominate members.
As the task group would not be an official council committee, political balance requirements do not apply.
The number of Members participating in a joint scrutiny will depend on how many authorities are involved but if all Worcestershire authorities take part it is suggested that one member be appointed from each authority.
Agreeing Chairmanship of a Joint Task Group
Nominations for chairing the task group will be sought from all members of the task group.
Where one authority is leading the scrutiny it may be appropriate for the Chairman to be appointed from that authority.
Agreeing Terms of Reference/Scope of the Scrutiny
Each participating authorities’ Overview and Scrutiny Committee would be asked to agree terms of reference for the scrutiny as per the scoping and proposal form.
Conduct of the Scrutiny
Meetings of the joint task group will be arranged by the supporting scrutiny officer(s).
The task group should strive to conduct their business in a consensual, open, responsible and transparent way across the political divides and seek to avoid expressing views based purely on political considerations.
Equal Participation
It is important for all members to be equal participants in the process and for officer support to be available on an equal basis.
Meeting Venues
To be decided by the Review Panel as appropriate to the particular review.
Approval of Report’s Recommendations
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.