That the Committee comment on the report as follows: · In broad terms the Committee support all the recommendations that have been put forward. · The Committee’s main concern is in relation to future finance of the service and being bound to a three year commitment. However, it is difficult to comment further until more details of any proposed new business model are forthcoming.
Word for word from the decision Worcester published for this meeting.Source: committee.worcester.gov.uk
JOINT WORCESTERSHIRE REGULATORY SERVICES SCRUTINY TASK GROUP
June 2014 This page is intentionally left blank Contents
Page No
1. Membership of the Task Group 1
2. Foreword from the Chairman & Vice Chairman 2
3. Summary of Recommendations 4
4. Introduction and Background Information 11
5. Chapter 1 – WRS Performance and Communications 15
6. Chapter 2 – Financing of WRS 20
7. Chapter 3 – Governance of WRS 24
8. Chapter 4 – Lessons Learned 34
9. Conclusion 41
10. Appendix 1 – Terms of Reference 42
11. Appendix 2 – Framework for Joint Overview & Scrutiny in Worcestershire 44
12. Appendix 3 – Summary of Meetings and Attendance Record 47
13. Appendix 4 - List of Services Provided by WRS 49
14. Appendix 5 - Acknowledgements 50
15. Appendix 6 - Declarations of Interest 51 This page is intentionally left blank MEMBERSHIP OF THE TASK GROUP
(From left to right) Councillors Peter Tomlinson (Vice Chairman), Simon Cronin, Rod Laight (Chairman), Richard Udall, Alan Mason and John Raine. The Members in the photograph above regularly attended the meetings.
Lead Member Substitute Authority
Rod Laight Pete Lammas Bromsgrove DC John Raine Mike Morgan Malvern Hills DC Alan Mason Gay Hopkins Redditch BC Simon Cronin Paul Denham Worcester City Richard Udall Lynn Duffy Worcestershire CC Peter Tomlinson Alastair Adams Wychavon DC Helen Dyke Tim Ingham Wyre Forest DC
1 Foreword from the Chairman and Vice Chairman This group came together for the first time in late September 2013. Since then we have met together on 14 further occasions. Our journey together has been taxing, concentrated, at times somewhat frustrating but, in the main, both fulfilling and stimulating. At no time have the divisions which separate us politically played any part whatsoever in our discussions, deliberations or our conclusions. Indeed it became clear from the outset that whatever views individual members of this Task Group may have held about Worcestershire Regulatory Services or whatever their own experiences may have been prior to the review, every single Member was prepared to wipe that individual slate clean and to approach the task with an open and enquiring mind. Working as a team on this Task Group has therefore proved to be very demanding though, for each of us, one of our most worthwhile experiences as Councillors to date.
And it has been some task! We have interviewed 16 people including regulatory professionals, senior Officers from the districts and elected Members representing all the partners in this complex organisation. We have asked for and been given evidence about the performance of WRS in all the areas it covers and we have circulated our own survey amongst elected Members. The overall success of this Joint Scrutiny has been achieved by a team working well together with trust and integrity.
It must be said that all those interviewed by the Task Group have been honest, open and forthright. In particular the Head of Regulatory Services, Steve Jorden, along with his team have been very open and transparent. We have had to listen to and digest a plethora of often divergent views from those sitting on the same Committee. But it would be fair to say that where contrary opinions were put to us they were expressed coherently and with passion. Without exception all those we spoke to believed in Worcestershire Regulatory Services and wanted it to succeed. As our knowledge of the workings of this organisation grew and as we took the pulse, as it were, of all those involved we became ever more certain that the challenge we had taken on was not only timely but vital to the survival of Worcestershire Regulatory Services.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.