That the Committee: 1. note the recommendation by Policy and Resources Committee on 5 February 2019 and approves the procurement of 28 bins in 2 phases; Phase 1 – 16 bins (10 litter & 6 recycling), Phase 2 – 12 litter bins. Once installed, Phase 1 to be up to 6 months in duration; 2. grant delegated authority to the Corporate Director - Place in consultation with the Chair and Vice-Chair of the Committee to select the bin to be procured, complete the procurement process and award the contract for Phase 1; and 3. dependent on the success of Phase 1, grant delegated authority to the Corporate Director - Place in consultation with the Chair and Vice-Chair of the Committee to complete the procurement process and authorise the commencement of Phase 2.
Word for word from the decision Worcester published for this meeting.Source: committee.worcester.gov.uk
1.1That the Committee notes the recommendation by Policy and Resources Committee on 5 February 2019 and approves the procurement of 28 bins in 2 phases; Phase 1 – 16 bins (10 litter & 6 recycling), Phase 2 – 12 litter bins. Once installed, Phase 1 to be up to 6 months in duration.
1.2That the Committee grants delegated authority to the Corporate Director Place in consultation with the Chair and Vice-Chair of the Committee to select the bin to be procured, complete the procurement process and award the contract for Phase 1.
1.3Dependent on the success of Phase 1, that the Committee grants delegated authority to the Corporate Director Place in consultation with the Chair and Vice-Chair of the Committee to complete the procurement process and award the contract for Phase 2.
Background
2.1Worcester City Council is reviewing the way it manages street scene services through a number of projects to identify improvements, efficiencies and financial benefits. The Street Scene Task and Finish Group have been looking at litter bin provision in the city centre with an aim to review all litter and dog bin provision across Worcester.
2.2The report to Environment Committee on 29 January 2019 proposed the capital purchase of 28 ‘Smart’ bins. Committee agreed to recommend approval of capital funding of up to £144,000 to P & R Committee.
2.3P & R Committee on 5 February 2019:
Agreed to approve in principle capital funding of up to £144,000 for procurement of 28 ‘Smart’ litter and recycling bins for the City Centre.
Recommend that the Environment Committee consider a phased procurement so as to be able to evaluate the effectiveness of the bins.
2.4The Task and Finish Group has produced a set of quality criteria to use in selecting the right bins for the City Centre. An assessment of suitable bins and procurement options is now being considered and it is recommended that the Chair and Vice Chair of the Committee, in consultation with the Corporate Director Place, select the bin to be procured.
3. Preferred Option
3.1Phase 1 to be the installation of 16 bins comprising of 10 litter and 6 recycling bins located from Foregate Street Station to Cathedral Square. Once installed, Phase 1 to be up to 6 months in duration. An evaluation will be undertaken towards the end of Phase 1 to determine the success of the initial bin installation.
3.2Dependent on the success of Phase 1 and that the benefits of the scheme will be realised then Phase 2 will be the installation of the remaining 12 litter bins to the rest of the City Centre area. Bins will be purchased with warranty to cover the designed 5 year lifespan.
3.3Advantages; recycling introduced from start, if problems experienced option to change supplier for Phase 2 using remaining capital funding.
Disadvantages; reduced operational savings before Phase 2 starts, any supplier discount may not be realised if purchase of remaining bins is delayed, mixed bin styles if change supplier.
Alternative options considered
4.1Capital purchase all 28 bins and install at the same time.
Advantages; maximise supplier discount, 100% operational savings from first day.
Disadvantages; if problems experienced no return of bins, capital spent – no option to change supplier.
Advantages; smaller quantity of bins purchased for Phase 1 to prove bin reliability before further funds committed, if problems experienced option to change supplier for Phase 2.
Disadvantages; recycling not introduced until Phase 2, reduced operational savings before Phase 2 starts, any supplier discount may not be realised if purchase of remaining bins is delayed, mixed bin styles if change supplier.
5. Implications
5.1Financial and Budgetary Implications
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.