That the Committee: 1. note the contents of this report and approves the proposal to continue with the existing number of operatives undertaking Place working; 2. approve the recruitment of two permanent staff to the Street Scene team (Place Working); and 3. recommend to Council an additional revenue budget of £55,000 to the Environmental Operations budget for 2022/2023.
Word for word from the decision Worcester published for this meeting.Source: committee.worcester.gov.uk
1.1Notes the contents of this report and approves the proposal to continue with the existing number of operatives undertaking Place working.
1.2Approves the recruitment of two permanent staff to the Street Scene team (Place Working), or
1.3Approves the deployment of two temporary staff to the Place Working service for an additional twelve months (from April 2022), and for this arrangement to be further reviewed for 2023/2024 budget.
1.4Recommends to Council an additional revenue budget of £55,000 to the Environmental Operations budget for 2022/2023.
Background
2.1In July 2020, a report was brought to the Environment Committee for approval for ‘Place Working’ to commence in October 2020 with the city being divided into five Places, including the city centre as a Place. Teams of five operatives were initially allocated to each of the outlying Place areas (working Monday to Friday) with a team of six (working Monday to Sunday) for the city centre.
2.2Previously, Place working was presented within the Budget Paper to Environment Committee, 28/01/2020. Item 2, of appendix 5, detailed the delivery of Place working and highlighted the need for two additional posts to be funded in order for 4 teams of 5 to be deployed in the outlying areas. The additional posts were to be funded at a total cost of £81,000 (equivalent to £54,000 p.a.) for a period of 18 months, this additional funding is due to end in March 2022.
2.3Operating with teams of 5 has brought a level of resilience, as the team members cover each other’s holidays and absence (c. 37 weeks cover per 5 person team). The Place Teams also cover the holidays/absence for the litter bin teams.
2.4Given the level of holidays/absence the teams, more often than not, have 4 operatives in attendance. Having 4 operatives in attendance allows for 2 teams of 2 to operate. This reduces the need for lone working and is more effective than single person working when undertaking larger, more detailed, tasks (alleyway clearances, hedges etc.). 2.5 In order to revert to the pre-October 2020 staffing levels of 18 operatives (currently 20 deployed) from April 2022, the following options were suggested in the January 2020 budget papers:
a) Other City-wide functions shift to a Place basis (e.g., mowing) and workloads combined; or
b) The number of Places is reconfigured across the remaining 18 posts, with 4 Place areas of 5 operatives being consolidated into 3 Place areas of 6 operatives); or
c) Reduce the number of operatives in 2 of the Place areas; resulting in 2 areas with 5 operatives and 2 areas with 4 operatives.
2.6Having further reviewed these three options, it appears that each of them would be detrimental to the current service:
a) City-wide functions shift to a Place basis (e.g., mowing): – the current city-wide functions have greater flexibility and better asset deployment (one set of assets moving through the city, rather than assets in each place), to split these functions across four Place areas would reduce efficiency.
b) The number of Places and the size of team is reconfigured across the remaining 18 posts (4 Places of 5 is reduced to 3 Places of 6): - Of the 3 options to reduce the number of operatives, this is most likely the more sustainable option.
The Place areas would obviously increase in size, with each area likely including more ‘hotspots’, so the cleansing standards in some areas would be recovered later in the day/week. There would initially be some disruption to the established cleansing patterns, whilst the teams adapt to their new areas.
c) Reducing two of the Place areas to 4 operatives: - it has not been established that any of the Place areas have less demand, or greater community involvement; therefore, the reduction of staff in 2 areas would have a detrimental effect on the current cleansing standards in those locations.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.