RESOLVED – ( i ) That the appeal arrangements in the HR policies be amended, to provide a final stage of appeal to a Strategic and Performance Director as described in paragraph 2.7 of report HCCS/29/15. (ii) That the Head of Corporate and Customer Services be authorised to make the necessary amendments to the relevant policies and constitution. Reasons for decisions ( i ) To enable Officers of the Authority to make appropriate employee related decisions and be accountable for such decisions. (ii) To modernise the way the Authority deals with appeals. It places the appeal decision with a Strategic and Performance Director which is within their area of responsibility.
Word for word from the decision Wrexham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.wrexham.gov.uk
To seek Executive Board approval to change the arrangements for the hearing of appeals in cases of misconduct, attendance and capability dismissals which are currently heard by a Member panel – the Employment appeal panel.
Executive summary
2.1The Executive board has approved a number of Human Resources policies that include reference to an Employment Appeal Panel in cases of dismissal. Each panel comprises of 3 elected members taken form a body of members who have been appropriately trained. This includes appeals against dismissal under the Disciplinary policy, the Capability policy and the Managing Attendance policy.
2.2In April 2010, in compliance with emerging practice, the Executive Board were asked to consider a change to the appeal process which included a final stage “the right of appeal” to an ‘Employment Appeal Panel’ in cases of dismissal under the disciplinary, capability, attendance and grievance policies. At this time Executive board removed the Member involvement from the grievance process, but retained it for the other policies.
2.3The purpose of the Appeal (as defined by ACAS) is to consider if the process was procedurally fair and whether the penalty given is in the range of reasonableness. The process should deal with the appeal impartially and where possible by “a manager” not previously involved in the case. ACAS guidance also states that an Appeal should be heard without unreasonable delay.
2.4A function of Executive Board is to establish the standards for human resource management to ensure that the Council’s legal obligations and policy requirements are met. The recommendation included in this report sets this standard, and complies with ACAS best practice.
2.5The Council’s Constitution sets out the functions and associated decisions relating to employee matters and in respect of dismissals. It states that these are the responsibility of the Chief Executive, Strategic and Performance Directors and Heads of Department. Our policies also set out the alternative arrangements for this group i.e the Chief Executive, Strategic and Performance Directors and Heads of Department where they differ due to legal requirements.
2.6It is important that the Council places the responsibility on its Managers to make these decisions when required, ensuring that their role is clearly defined in people management procedures eg managing performance, attendance and conduct. This ensures that they are held accountable for their decisions. A Manager’s pay grade reflects their responsibilities which are set out in their job description and it is expected that they undertake these activities. This is clearly a management process and not a democratic process.
2.7To modernise our arrangements it is recommended that the Member ‘Employment Appeals Panel” arrangement is removed from the process and relevant policies eg the procedures for Disciplinary, Capability (to be replaced with Managing Performance) and Managing Attendance and this is replaced with arrangements that provide the appeal to a Strategic and Performance Director. The appeal will be allocated to a Strategic and Performance Director who does not line manage the Head of Department who made the decision to dismiss. This approach will comply with the ACAS code of practice that states that “an Appeal process should deal with the appeal impartially and where possible by a manager not previously involved in the case.
Recommendations
That Executive Board:
3.1Agree to amend the appeal arrangements in the HR policies, to provide a final stage of appeal to a Strategic and Performance Director as described in paragraph 2.7.
3.2Provide authority to the Head of Corporate and Customer Services to make the necessary amendments to the relevant policies and constitution.
Reasons for recommendations
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.