Application to vary Condition no. 1 of Planning Permission Code No P/2009/0900 to allow the development to commence before expiry of 5 years from April 2015 at Glenwood, Station Avenue, Chirk, Wrexham (Application Code No P/2015/0216)
RefusedPlanning1 paper
Planning Committee refused this item on Friday 17 July 2015. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
RESOLVED – That permission be REFUSED. Reason The proposed dwelling will detract from the appearance of Glenwood , the terrace to which it belongs and in turn the character of Chirk Conservation Area. The development therefore does not accord with policies GDP1 and EC7 of the Wrexham Unitary Development Plan.
Word for word from the decision Wrexham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.wrexham.gov.uk
APPLICATION NO: LOCATION: DATE RECEIVED: P/2015 /0216 GLENWOOD STATION AVENUE 26/03/2015 CHIRK WREXHAM LL14 5LS COMMUNITY: CASE OFFICER: Chirk DESCRIPTION: MP APPLICATION TO VARY CONDITION 1 OF PLANNING PERMISSION CODE WARD: NUMBER P/2009/0900 TO ALLOW AGENT NAME: Chirk South THE DEVELOPMENT TO MRS JUDITH CLARK COMMENCE BEFORE THE EXPIRY OF 5 YEARS FROM 19.04.2015.
APPLICANT(S) NAME: MRS JUDITH CLARK
THE SITE
Application site
PROPOSAL
As above. HISTORY
P/2008/1204 Erection of an attached dwelling. Refused 6.2.2009 (Highways grounds only) P/2009/0900 Erection of attached dwelling. Granted 19.4.2010
DEVELOPMENT PLAN
Within settlement, Chirk Conservation Area and Pontcysyllte World Heritage Buffer Zone. Policies GDP1, H2, EC7, EC11 and T8 apply.
CONSULTATIONS
Community Council: No objection. Local Member: I can remember the original application in 2010 and I was pleased with the quality of the architecture, design and appearance of the new building and was pleased to move the recommendation. Request the application goes to committee if the recommendation is to refuse. Public Protection: No comments. Highways: Recommend conditions. Welsh Water: Consulted 31.3.15 NRW: Consulted 31.3.15 Site Notice: Expired 22.4.15 Neighbours: The owners/occupiers of 7 nearby properties notified 2.4.15. SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS
Planning permission for the erection of a new dwelling attached to Glenwood was granted in April 2010. The permission was subject to a planning obligation to require the cessation of a guest house use in Glenwood. The permission was not implemented and the applicant has therefore sought to renew it - this application being submitted prior to the expiry of the previous permission.
Whilst there have been no changes in in local planning policy since the previous decision I am no longer of the opinion that this is the most appropriate development for the site. As such it would not be appropriate to renew the planning permission.
Glenwood and the adjoining terrace are identified in the Chirk Conservation Area Character Assessment and Management Plan as buildings of architectural importance to the character and appearance of the Conservation Area by virtue of their contribution to the streetscape and their historical interest as a fine Edwardian Terrace.
The proposed dwelling seeks to replicate the appearance of Glenwood. Despite this it will disrupt the unity and symmetry of the terrace to which Glenwood belongs to the detriment of its appearance and the wider Conservation Area.
CONCLUSION
The proposed dwelling will detract from the appearance of Glenwood, the terrace to which it belongs and in turn the character of Chirk Conservation Area.
Whilst I would have no objection in principle to the erection of a new dwelling attached to Glenwood, I am of the opinion that it would need to differ in scale, proportions and appearance to the previous proposals in order to avoid harming the appearance of the existing buildings and, in turn, wider Conservation Area.
RECOMMENDATION: That permission be REFUSED
REASON(S)
1. The proposed dwelling will detract from the appearance of Glenwood, the terrace to which it belongs and in turn the character of Chirk Conservation Area. The development therefore does not accord with policies GDP1 and EC7 of the Wrexham Unitary Development Plan.
PLANNING COMMITTEE 6 JULY 2015 ADDENDUM REPORT
CHI P/2015/0216 Glenwood, Station Avenue, Chirk, Wrexham. SPEAKER: FOR – Malcolm Andrew (Representing Applicant) Pa th
Recreation Ground
) um th ( Pa
Coronation Oak
Jarmay Ambulance Station 4 3
Child Hill Crest Compton House
Glenwood Oaklands 1
Health Centre Lynden House
38 4 ARE 40 S QU E N'S QUE R) YRW R AS Glascott (SQ WA
Application to vary Condition no. 1 of Planning Permission Code No P/2009/0900 to allow the development to commence before expiry of 5 years from April 2015 at Glenwood, Station Avenue, Chirk, Wrexham (Application Code No P/2015/0216)Report
15Application to vary Condition no. 1 of Planning Permission Code No P/2009/0900 to allow the development to commence before expiry of 5 years from April 2015 at Glenwood, Station Avenue, Chirk, Wrexham (Application Code No P/2015/0216)This decision
Who was there
10 of 19 attended
AB
Councillor Andrew BaileyCommittee Member, present
ID
Councillor I David Bithell, MBECommittee Member, apologies
TB
Councillor Terry BolandCommittee Member, absent
ME
Councillor Mike EdwardsVice-Chair, apologies
TE
Councillor Terry EvansCommittee Member, present
AK
Councillor A Keith GregoryCommittee Member, apologies
DJ
Councillor D J GriffithsCommittee Member, present
GW
Councillor G W GriffithsCommittee Member, apologies
KH
Councillor Kevin HughesCommittee Member, present
BM
Councillor Bernie McCannCommittee Member, present
MG
Councillor M G MorrisChair, present
PH
Councillor Paul H PembertonCommittee Member, present
Application to vary Condition no. 1 of Planning Permission Code No P/2009/0900 to allow the development to commence before expiry of 5 years from April 2015 at Glenwood, Station Avenue, Chirk, Wrexham (Application Code No P/2015/0216)This decision
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.