RESOLVED – That permission be REFUSED . Reason In the absence of an approved scheme for the erection of a free standing restaurant with Drive Thru Facility, it would be premature and inappropriate to grant consent for signage which would be out of context with the existing site and detrimental to the wider visual amenities of the area. To allow the proposed signage would be contrary to Policy GDP1 (a) of the adopted Wrexham Unitary Development Plan and Local Planning Guidance Note No 1.
Word for word from the decision Wrexham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.wrexham.gov.uk
Advertisement Consent is sought for the erection of new signage in association with the proposed McDonald’s restaurant and drive thru (P/2019/0919). This application for a Totem sign is part of a suite of signage proposals referred to in this same agenda. HISTORY
P/2019/0917 9 No. Internally Illuminated Signs. Decision Pending – also on this agenda P/2019/0918 4 No. Freestanding Signs, 1 Digital Booth Screen, 1 No. Banner Sign and 16 No. Dot Signs - Decision Pending – also on this agenda P/2019/0919 Erection of a Free Standing Restaurant and Drive Thru Facility Decision Pending – also on this agenda
DEVELOPMENT PLAN
The site is within the settlement limits. UDP Policies GDP1, EC9 and EC4 are relevant.
CONSULTATIONS
Community Council: The signs should not be a distraction to motorists using the nearby roads. Adj. Community Council: Consulted 18.12.2019 Local Member: Notified 18.12.2019 Adjacent Local Member: Notified 18.12.2019 Highways: No objections subject to a condition preventing any illumination that would dazzle drivers on the highway. Conservation Officer: The proposed signage will not have a significant impact upon the setting of the nearby grade II listed, Glyndwr University. Tree Officer: * Comments on the original Proposal The proposed positioning of the totem sign means there will be an increasing risk of direct conflict with the development and the two adjacent London plane trees T10 and T11 subject to TPO WCBC 264/2016. The close proximity of the sign means that it may become visually obscured to customers by the crowns of the two trees leading to increasing pressure to have both or either of the trees pruned or even felled. Installation of the sign may also be a concern due to potential root damage caused during excavation works. Comments on the amended proposal The Totem Sign has been moved to a suitable location, and I have no objections to the siting of the Totem in its new location. Site Notice: Expired 10/01/2020 Neighbours: 51 responses received: The Totem sign would have a negative visual impact upon the ‘Gateway’ into Wrexham and would not be in keeping with the local area such as the college campus and surrounding residential area, and would be overbearing in appearance and look ugly to visitors; Drivers could be distracted by looking at the Totem which would impact upon highway safety in this busy area; Light pollution.
SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS
Visual amenity: The proposed totem sign is 12 metres high from ground level, and is subsidiary in height to the building to which it is associated. (See images 1 to 3 below). In terms of the proposal, there is nothing which is considered incongruous for a McDonald’s restaurant, set within an established retail park, and is part of its corporate branding.
For a sign of this size, the Technical Report by The Institution of Lighting Engineers – Brightness of Illuminated Advertisements – requires a maximum restriction of 1200 candelas / sq. metre, within an already lit location such as this. Taking the proximity of the highway into consideration, the applicant is proposing that the level of illumination is reduced by half to 600 candelas / sq. metre. The will therefore be no adverse impact upon the residential and visual amenities of the area, or upon highway safety, and the (illumination level will be controlled by condition.
Figure 1. Proposed Totem Sign Figure 2. Example Image
Figure 3. Example Image Figure 4. Proposed Location (circled in red)
CONCLUSION
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.