Resolved
Resolved Refused for the following reasons:- (a) It is considered that the design of the new apartment building is plain, uninteresting and would not result in a high quality townscape. As such the proposal would detract from the setting of Abbey Gate a Grade 1 Listed Building and would neither preserve or enhance the Character of the Evesham Conservation Area and would be contrary to Policy QE5 of the West Midlands Regional Spatial Strategy, Policies CTC.19 and CTC.20 of the Adopted Worcestershire Structure Plan, Policies CB3, CB4 and CB5 of the Adopted Wychavon District Local Plan and Policies SUR1A, ENV13 and ENV16 of the Wychavon District Local Review Revised Deposit and the provisions of PPG15. (b) It is considered that a lack of detail over some of the exact works to be carried out during the restoration of Abbey Gate have been submitted meaning the exact impact on this important Grade 1 Listed Building cannot be fully assessed to ensure works will not result in damage or loss of fabric or features of special architectural or historic interest. As such the proposal is contrary is Policy QE5 of the West Midlands Regional Spatial Strategy, Policies CTC.19 and CTC.21 of the Adopted Worcestershire Structure Plan, Policy CB5 of the Adopted Wychavon District Local Plan and Policy ENV15 of the Wychavon District Local Review Revised Deposit and the provisions of PPG15. (c) The application does not satisfactorily demonstrate that the proposed new apartment building would not result in serious harm to the views of the Grade I and II listed churches and Bell Tower to the rear, several of which are Scheduled Ancient Monuments. The proposed development would thereby be contrary to Policy QE3 of the West Midlands Regional Spatial Strategy, Policies CTC2, CTC18, and CTC19 of the adopted Worcestershire County Structure Plan, CB5 of the adopted Wychavon District Local Plan and GD2, ENV16 and SUR1A of the Wychavon District Local Plan Review - Revised Deposit and the provisions of PPG15. (Councillors R C Adams and [name removed] required their votes against the proposal to refuse the application to be so recorded).