CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Wychavon District Council
Executive Board, Tuesday 29 November 2005

Response to CPA District Consultation

Agreed Executive 2 papers

Executive Board agreed this item on Tuesday 29 November 2005. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item122

Resolved

Resolved That the Audit Commission be advised of the Council’s response to the inspection proposals for Comprehensive Performance Assessment, as follows:- – The Audit Commission is upfront on the importance of District Councils – at only 7% of local government expenditure we are clearly not a priority for the Commission or indeed for inspection! Given the District regime cost £20 million last time to implement they are in no rush to re- categorise all 238 Districts again. The lack of timetable to accompany proposals and delay in publishing the consultation options means we are not confident proposals will ever actually be implemented. Indeed the Commission talks about a ‘transition phase’ before Local Areas Agreements become more widespread, making area based inspection possible in the future. We see some logic in this as it can focus on how partners work together to make improvements for people on agreed local themes. – In the transition phase our favoured option is option 4 - it is the most pragmatic, yet robust option. Some of the other options proposed by the Commission are clearly not cost- effective, we question why they were even included. Option 4 includes “use of resources”, “direction of travel” and “service assessments” although defining these will be key . The detail is important – for example “service assessment” could include on site inspection or simply a review of PIs. – Whatever CPA proposals are decided upon, it is clear that central audit requirements continue to grow. The Use of Resources self-assessment with the new Value for Money aspect together with the forthcoming Direction of Travel Assessment add to things like the collection of Performance Indicators that we are required to report progress on. – As a near excellent council we do not need inspection to motivate improvement. We learnt the value of self-assessment and the Direction of Travel provides us with that opportunity to ‘take stock’. – Whatever regime the Commission decides on for Districts we know our motivation comes from wanting to give residents better value for money services every year.
Word for word from the decision Wychavon published for this meeting. Source: mgov.wychavon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Wychavon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive Board, 7 pages

Options for district council CPA

50 The following options for consultation set out some different ways in which the various elements of CPA could be brought together. The options fall into two categories:

e options that allow the Commission to re-categorise all councils (group A) through a programme to be delivered over a number of years; and

e options that allow the Commission to identify, from initial evidence of improvement, that a council may be ready to be considered for re-categorisation (or where service or corporate failure indicates a potential need for re-categorisation) before activity to confirm whether re-categorisation should take place (group B).

51 All options need to allow for the possibility that re-categorisation can be either upwards or downwards depending on performance.

Longer-term context

52 The national policy context, including the introduction of local area agreements and our ongoing work on area profiles, raises the potential for future area based assessments of public services and a focus on the achievement of local priorities. It is therefore important that a new framework for district council CPA looks forward beyond 2008/09 and that all the options should be capable of contributing to any such future framework. :

53 The Commission intends to consider ways in which district council CPA may contribute towards area based assessments in the longer term. We are, therefore, seeking volunteer district councils to help us pilot work in this area during the next 18 months.

The framework for comprehensive performance assessment of district councils from 2006 15 | 16 | The framework for comprehensive performance assessment of district councils from 2006

Group A Option 1

54 This option takes the first round assessment framework as its starting point.

55 The framework under this option would include:

e service delivery diagnostics (for example, public space and housing as in the first round);

e benefits assessment; e use of resources assessment; e aperiodic corporate assessment; and

e it could include regular statements of direction of travel that sit alongside CPA categorisation.

Option 1

Housing benefit assessment Use of resources assessment

Public space diagnostic

Housing diagnostic

Overall CPA judgement

56 It does not include separate regular service assessments. The framework for comprehensive performance assessment of district councils from 2006 fag

57 Corporate assessment activity would be an in-depth and comprehensive assessment activity for all councils by way of a phased programme over the period 2006-09.We would pilot ways of undertaking a corporate assessment.

58 This option would require a high level of resource. The cost of this approach during 2003 and 2004 for all councils was approximately £20 million and required significant effort by district councils in preparation for the corporate assessments.

Option2 59 This option takes the adopted single tier and county council CPA framework as its starting point.

60 The framework under this options would include: e use of resources assessment; e service assessment(s); e periodic corporate assessment; and

e possibly direction of travel scored judgements published annually when CPA categories were updated.

61 Arules set would bring together scores from each component part to produce an overall CPA category.

62 Corporate assessment activity would be periodic on a rolling programme covering all councils in the period 2006-09. In these circumstances it may be appropriate to provide transitional protection of corporate assessment scores along similar lines to those in place for single tier and county councils!

63 Some essential modifications would be required to the single tier and county council framework. For example, service assessment(s) would need to reflect district council functions and could be developed as one or a series of blocks as discussed earlier.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
CPAscanReport 7 pages DownloadRead as text
PDF
Response to CPA District ConsultationReport 2 pages Download

More from Wychavon Executive Board

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
16 Sep 2026 Minutes of the Previous MeetingResolved That the minutes of the meeting of the Executive Board held on Wednesday 24 June 2026 be confirmed as a corr... Decided Open
16 Sep 2026 Budget 2027/28Resolved That Executive Board Approves the budget timetable for the 2027/28 budget process, attached at Appendix A, i... Approved Open
16 Sep 2026 Health Suite Pershore Leisure CentreResolved 1. That the Executive Board considers the report to refurbish the Pershore leisure centre health suite and t... Approved Open
16 Sep 2026 Street Naming and NumberingResolved That the revised ‘ Policy’, as presented in Appendix 1, be adopted. Approved Open
16 Sep 2026 Street Naming and Numbering for Wychavon TownResolved That the street naming and numbering for the development of Wychavon Town, delineated by the allocation in t... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies