Resolved
Resolved Refused for the following reasons: (1) The application submissions include a daytime bat survey report by Betts Ecology, which reports that bat droppings were found scattered within the roof space of no. 27 Brewers Lane and that the presence of bat roosts within existing hedgerow to the east side of the site could not be discounted. The same report states that the evidence found in the roof confirms it is used as a bat roost, but that without further surveys it cannot be confirmed which species of bat uses the roost or how many. It can not be determined without further survey whether the roost is used for mating, breeding or hibernation purposes. The report goes on to recommend that emergence/return bat activity surveys are carried out during the optimal survey season to determine bat usage. Without the carrying out of these further surveys and being party to the findings, the Council is unable to determine whether the proposed development (and particularly the required demolition of no. 27 Brewers Lane) would result in significant harm to interests of biodiversity through adverse effects or risk of adverse effect to protected species (bats). Also without survey results to identify the significance of the ecological importance of the application site, the Council is unable to determine whether significant harm can be prevented, adequately mitigated against or compensated for. As such, insufficient information has been provided to ascertain whether the proposed development would be in accordance with policy ENV6 of the Wychavon District Local Plan, the EU Habitats Directive as well as the provisions of PPS9 on Biodiversity and Geological Conservation. The lack of sufficient survey work and subsequent survey results is also contrary to the provisions of Planning for Biodiversity and Geological Conservation: A Guide to Good Practice. (2) Whilst noting the applicants willingness to enter into a legal agreement, no secure arrangements are in place to ensure that any of the proposed units would be provided on an affordable basis, contrary ... view the full minutes text for item 184.