CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Wychavon District Council
Development Control Committee, Thursday 4 February 2010

Planning application Ref W/09/02667/PN - Erection of one replacement dwelling and garage/plant room. Portway Farm, Radford Road, Flyford Flavell, Worcester, WR7 4DL. Mr J Davis.

Refused Planning 1 paper

Development Control Committee refused this item on Thursday 4 February 2010. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item185

Resolved

Resolved Refused for the following reasons:- Z001 The proposed development by virtue of its design, increased size and scale and alternative positioning on a different footprint to the dwelling it is proposed to replace, would be contrary to the criteria set out in Policy RES9 of the Wychavon District Local Plan (adopted 2006). The proposed dwelling would not replace the existing building with one that is more appropriate within its surroundings or the rural landscape as it will appear more visually prominent due to its design and add increased mass, bulk and height to the site which in the opinion of the Local Planning Authority fails to respect the character of the local area which is also contrary to Wychavon District Local Plan Policy ENV1 and Worcestershire County Structure Plan Policy CTC1. Furthermore, the proposed dwelling would be located on a different footprint outside of the authorised and historical curtilage occupied by the existing dwelling without sufficient justification or planning reason to override Criterion c) of Local Plan Policy RES9. Z002 Local Planning Authorities are required to apply the 3 “Tests” of the Habitat Regulations when considering planning applications involving European Protected Species. It is not considered that this application can be justified in compliance with Test One which requires that the application will have public health or safety benefits or overriding social, economic or environmental public interests in the demolition of the existing building. The second test requires that there would be no satisfactory alternatives to the demolition of the dwelling. In the opinion of the Local Planning Authority an alternative approach is available through the refurbishment and extension of the existing dwelling. On this basis, the application also fails in compliance with Test Two as it has not been demonstrated to a satisfactory degree that these alternatives have been thoroughly considered. Approval of this application would therefore be contrary to Wychavon District Local Plan Policy ENV6, the requirements of the Habitat Regulations 1994 and PPS9 – Biodiversity and Geological Conservation.
Word for word from the decision Wychavon published for this meeting. Source: mgov.wychavon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Wychavon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Control Committee, 9 pages

Development Control Committee - 04/02/2010

W/09/02667/PN Parish: Kington Grid Ref: E:398852.1 N:254682 Ward: Upton Snodsbury 32

Description: Erection of one replacement dwelling and garage/plant room.

Site: Portway Farm, Radford Road, Flyford Flavell, Worcester, WR7 4DL

Applicant: [name removed]: Ivy Architectural Services

Date Valid: 16/11/2009 Case Anna Thompson Officer: Expiry Date: 11/01/2010 Tel: 01386 565379 Member(s): Cllr Linda Robinson

1. Site Description and Details of Proposal

This application has been called to the Development Control Committee by Councillor Mrs Robinson who has also requested that a site visit is carried out. This application was deferred from the January committee meeting which took place on the 14 January 2010 where site visits were cancelled due to adverse weather conditions. Committee considered that a site visit was necessary to fully assess this planning application and the item was therefore deferred. This report has been amended to include all previous updates.

The application site is located within the open countryside, outside of the Green Belt, on the Radford Road between Flyford Flavell and Radford. The existing property is of a traditional Georgian red-brick design, remaining from its frontage largely unaltered, although a number of extensions to the rear have been carried out over previous years which the applicants suggest has resulted in a awkward and impractical internal layout and as such does not lend itself easily to adaptation due to differing floor levels.

The existing farm house is positioned on the roadside boundary, set back beyond the highways verge and a small walled front yard. The property is set adjacent to a similarly traditional dwelling set on the same building line and extending further across the frontage due to recent extensions. The neighbouring property, Portway Cottage appears more cottage like in its design, with lower eaves height and lower ridge to that of the existing dwelling proposed to be replaced, however they sit well together along the road frontage and add to the rural character and appearance of the street scene. The two dwellings are separated by a narrow vehicular access which provides the current driveway and parking areas associated with the house and also access to the farm which consists of a row of three large corrugated barns. A number of fields used for pasture land for grazing livestock complete the farm complex and these lie to the north, west and east of the farm house proposed to be demolished. A row of three linked wooden and corrugated metal sheds, one which is currently used as a garage, are located to the west of the existing dwelling. These appear dilapidated in their appearance and this application also includes the removal of these structures. The existing dwelling does not have an agricultural occupancy restriction on it.

This application seeks to replace the existing farmhouse with a new red-brick family dwelling, set back from the road and repositioned to the rear of the site on the footprint of the dilapidated sheds located to the west of the existing property. A new 3-bay detached garage building is proposed on the footprint of the existing dwelling, adjacent to the vehicular access to the site and in line with the neighbouring road-fronting property. The internal floor layout indicates two garage bays to be provided for the parking of vehicles and one bay to be used as a biomass boiler and plant room. The Design and Access Statement suggests that the replacement dwelling is proposed as it would be more cost efficient and sustainable in the long term rather than continually repairing an old building. The proposed development is stated as being required for the future viability of the farm and for future diversification, possibly in the form of biomass planting, although no enquiries or proposals have been received regarding any future diversification measures on this site.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Planning application Ref W/09/02667/PN: Erection of one replacement dwelling and garage/plant room. Portway Farm, Radford Road, Flyford Flavell, Worcester, WR7 4DL. Mr J Davis.Report 9 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
173Minutes.Approved 174Department of Communities and Local Government - Permitted development rights for small scale renewable and low carbon energy technologies, and electric vehicle charging infrastructure - Consultation documentOn the agenda 175Enforcement Report IN/08/00357,10 Synehurst, Badsey.Approved 176Enforcement Report IN /08/00393, 13 Vine Street, Evesham.Refused 177Enforcement Report IN/07/00022, 32 Port Street, EveshamApproved 178Planning application Ref W/09/02564/PN - Proposal to construct 24 residential units and associated infrastructure. Land between Primrose Cottage and Hill View, Tewkesbury Road, Eckington. CALA Homes (Midlands) Ltd.Deferred 179Planning application Ref W/09/02872/OU - Outline planning application for replacement industrial building for storage and distribution (Class B8 of the Use Classes Order 2005) with ancillary offices (Class B1 of the Use Classes Order 2005).Approved 180Planning application Ref W/09/02647/PN - Erection of 29 houses and apartments and a sports and leisure centre with associated roads and parking. Resubmission of application W/08/03198/PN. Wychbold Hall, Stoke Road, Wychbold. Owens.Refused 181Planning application Ref W/09/02640/PN - Erection of poly tunnels. Zenith Nurseries, Station Road, Offenham, Evesham, WR11 8LW. Zenith Nurseries Ltd.Approved 182Planning application Ref W/09/02893/PN - Extension to glasshouses. Cross Nurseries, Evesham Road, Offenham, Evesham, WR11 8SA. Avoncross Ornamentals Limited.Deferred 183Planning application Ref W/09/02528/CU -Retrospective application for construction of two fishing lakes. Land adjacent to Little Goosehill Wood, Goosehill Lane, Broughton Green, Hanbury. Mr M Banham.Refused 184Planning application Ref W/09/01690/OU - Outline planning application for the demolition of No 27 Brewers Lane and the development of up to 39 dwellings and associated infrastructure. Land to the rear of including and 27 Brewers Lane, Badsey. Crest Nicholson.Refused
185Planning application Ref W/09/02667/PN - Erection of one replacement dwelling and garage/plant room. Portway Farm, Radford Road, Flyford Flavell, Worcester, WR7 4DL. Mr J Davis.This decision
186Planning application Ref W/09/02082/PP - Third storey extension (road level) to riverside dwelling. The Retreat, Main Road, Wyre Piddle, Pershore, WR10 2JB. Mr Rickards.Approved 187Planning application Ref W/09/02745/PN - Erection of an enclosure/canopy structure to provide storage for either of the following touring caravan, trailers x 4, additional storage of reclaimed materials for private use. Albion House, Main Road, Ombersley, Droitwich Spa, WR9 0DP. Mr J Lane.Approved 188Planning application Ref W/09/02584/PN - Barn for storage and keep of animals food, ground implements, animal bedding, tractor and extension to stable (retrospective). Field, Ladywood. Mrs J Rouse.Approved 189Charging for Pre-Application AdviceOn the agenda 190Planning Appeal DecisionsOn the agenda

On this subject at Wychavon

Search all
  1. Planning application Ref W/09/02667/PN - Erection of one replacement dwelling and garage/plant room. Portway Farm, Radford Road, Flyford Flavell, Worcester, WR7 4DL. Mr J Davis.This decision
  2. Planning Application Ref W/26/01261/FUL.Decided
  3. Planning Application Ref W/26/01241/LB.Approved
  4. Planning Application Ref W/24/01768/FUL. Locks View, Charlton Lane, Torton, Hartlebury. Three new gypsy plots each comprising one touring caravan, one static caravan and one utility block - (Variation of condition 1 Ref 19/02686/FUL and Appeal Ref APP/H1840/W/20/3256477). Mr Steven LockApproved
  5. Planning Application Ref W/26/00768/FUL. 18 Coronation Street, Evesham, WR11 3DA. Part change of use from Class F2 social club to Class F2 social club and Class E(f) children's day nursery. Mrs Susan TredellApproved
  6. Planning Application Ref W/26/00695/RM.Refused

More from Wychavon Development Control Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
28 Apr 2011 Minutes.Resolved That the Minutes of the Committee held on 31 March 2011 be approved as a correct record of the proceedin g s... Approved Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref W/11/00298/PN.Resolved Conditionally approved:- Z001 The development hereby permitted shall be begun no later than the expiration o... Approved Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref W/10/03096/RM. Reserved Matters Application following the granting of Outline Planning Permission Ref W/09/01690/OU for construction of 28 dwellings. ( Including 8 no. Affordable Units). Land to the rear of including and, 27 Brewers Lane, Badsey. Crest Nicholson.Resolved That this matter be deferred to await receipt of a revised layout plan to address comments made by the Count... Deferred Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref W/11/0004/PN. Erection of two detached dwellings. Land Adjacent, 19 Oak Tree Lane, Cookhill. Mr Ryan.Resolved That this item be refused for the following reason:- It is considered that the erection of two detached dwel... Refused Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref C/11/00658/CM. Proposed Anaerobic Digestion Plant, new roundabout access and associated ancillary infrastructure. Spring Hill Farm, Salters Lane, Fladbury, WR10 2PE. Mr A Bille.Resolved That the Council provide the following comments in response to the County Council consultation. The Council ... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies