Resolved
Resolved Refused for the following reasons:- Z001 The proposed development by virtue of its design, increased size and scale and alternative positioning on a different footprint to the dwelling it is proposed to replace, would be contrary to the criteria set out in Policy RES9 of the Wychavon District Local Plan (adopted 2006). The proposed dwelling would not replace the existing building with one that is more appropriate within its surroundings or the rural landscape as it will appear more visually prominent due to its design and add increased mass, bulk and height to the site which in the opinion of the Local Planning Authority fails to respect the character of the local area which is also contrary to Wychavon District Local Plan Policy ENV1 and Worcestershire County Structure Plan Policy CTC1. Furthermore, the proposed dwelling would be located on a different footprint outside of the authorised and historical curtilage occupied by the existing dwelling without sufficient justification or planning reason to override Criterion c) of Local Plan Policy RES9. Z002 Local Planning Authorities are required to apply the 3 “Tests” of the Habitat Regulations when considering planning applications involving European Protected Species. It is not considered that this application can be justified in compliance with Test One which requires that the application will have public health or safety benefits or overriding social, economic or environmental public interests in the demolition of the existing building. The second test requires that there would be no satisfactory alternatives to the demolition of the dwelling. In the opinion of the Local Planning Authority an alternative approach is available through the refurbishment and extension of the existing dwelling. On this basis, the application also fails in compliance with Test Two as it has not been demonstrated to a satisfactory degree that these alternatives have been thoroughly considered. Approval of this application would therefore be contrary to Wychavon District Local Plan Policy ENV6, the requirements of the Habitat Regulations 1994 and PPS9 – Biodiversity and Geological Conservation.