Resolved
That the application be refused. REASON: 1. The introduction of additional smaller units and creation of 2 large units selling an unrestricted range of goods is unacceptable because the proposed development will impact on the ability to secure investment in vacant buildings and spaces in the city centre, and particularly the Castle Piccadilly site which in the opinion of the Local Planning Authority is suitable and available for development. It is also considered that the development will have significant adverse impacts on planned investment in, and the vitality and viability of, the city centre. . The proposed development is therefore contrary to advice within the National Planning Policy framework published on the 27 th March 2012; the objectives set out in of the City of York Core Strategy Submission (publication version 2011) in particular policies SP1, SP3, CS2, CS3, CS4,CS15 and CS17 and policies SP7b, SP9, SP10, S1, S2 and YC1 of the Development Control Local Plan approved for development control purposes April 2005. 2.It is considered that the adverse effect on investment and employment in the City Centre that would result from the development would not be outweighed by employment generated on site by the development . In addition the development represents a sequentially unjustified expansion of out of town shopping, contrary to national and local planning policy; maintains unsustainable travel choices; and hinders the promotion of fairness and inclusion ... view the full minutes text for item 56b