i ) That Cabinet thank the Task Group for their work. ii) That, following the update of the Financial Regulations, a report be presented to Cabinet in relation to the consideration and implementation of the Task Groups recommendations and their incorporation within the Regulations. Reason: To conclude the Scrutiny Review in line with CYC Scrutiny procedures and protocols.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
1. This report presents the review findings from the recently completely Loans & Grants Scrutiny Review.
Background to Review
2. In January 2013 the Corporate & Scrutiny Management Committee considered a scrutiny topic submitted by Cllr Healey and Cllr Runciman on how loans/grants from City of York Council (CYC) to outside organisations were being monitored. The topic was submitted as a result of the collapse of the North Yorkshire Credit Union, for which the Committee were informed there was an ongoing investigation.
3. The Committee agreed they would like to receive an update on the results of the investigation into the collapse of the North Yorkshire Credit Union, on its completion. However, they agreed the focus of the scrutiny review should be to look forward to provide guidance on best practice for monitoring future grants/loans provided by the Council.
4. On that basis, the Committee agreed to proceed with the review and set up a Task Group of the following Members to carry out the review on their behalf:
• Cllr Chris Steward • Cllr Ruth Potter • Cllr Carol Runciman
Information Gathered
5. An initial meeting of the Task Group held in March 2013 established that the issuing of loans and grants was not overseen by the Corporate Finance Team and in most cases the decision was taken at Directorate level with no central record of all the loans and grants made each year, other than the information recorded on the Financial Management System. APPENDIX 1
6. The Task Group considered a list of all the loans and grants made by the Council in the financial year 2012-13 and randomly chose six for further analysis and scrutiny – see a list of those below: Description Original value Grant or Current of loan / grant Loan amount O/S Bike Rescue 30,000 loan 22,443.36 Codebreaker Ltd 2,100 loan 2,100 York Homestart 26,636.85 grant n/a Homelessness Strategy 325,927.78 grant n/a Parenting Commissioning 2,500.00 grant n/a Programmes Warm Homes, Healthy 15,491.25 grant n/a People
7. In May 2013, the Task Group received detailed information on each of their chosen loans/grants as shown below:
8. Bike Rescue This loan was provided to the Bike Rescue Project in March 2010. The full reasons for the loan were outlined in the report to Cabinet on 2nd March 2010, but in summary it was to cover a shortfall in funding to convert a former electricity sub station into a secure cycle park at Lendal Bridge. The total project cost was £300k of which £270k was funded through the Local Transport Plan.
9. The Cabinet report provided a full analysis of the potential risks and how these would be mitigated. It also set out the reasons for offering a loan rather than a grant.
10. The loan is being repaid on a monthly basis, with interest being charged at 4.43%. It is monitored by Property Services who are in regular contact with Bike Rescue.
11. Codebreaker Ltd The loan was originally awarded in May 2007 as part of the Council’s 2006/07 support to Voluntary and Community Organisations and was approved by the service manager at that time. The loan was to help with the cost of attending a Rugby Festival in France on the basis that it provided benefit as a cultural exchange and would secure the future of French teams travelling to York in future years. The monitoring arrangements included measures to identify the number of children participating in sport and the diversity of the teams participating in local tournaments. APPENDIX 1
12. The organisation signed a loan agreement agreeing to repay the loan in 3 instalments over a 9 month period meaning the loan should have been repaid by February 2008. However, the organisation defaulted on the loan and the Council was not been able to recover the outstanding payments. The loan was written off in November 2012.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.