That, in accordance with Option One, the LPWG request that the Executive: i. Note progress on the consideration of the identified MOD sites for housing land within the context of the Local Plan ii. Instruct Officers to produce a report highlighting detailed implications to the Local Development Scheme, including any budget implications. iii. Note the impact of the additional costs that will arise and the requirement to consider as part of the future years budget process. Reason: To produce an NPPF compliant Local Plan.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
1. This report provides an update on the emerging Local Plan and in particular on the initial consideration of the newly submitted Ministry of Defence (MOD) sites against the Local Plan Site Selection methodology following the report to Executive on 7 December 2016. It highlights initial appraisal work completed to date to consider whether the sites represent „reasonable alternatives‟ for potential inclusion in the Local Plan and further technical work that will need to be completed in order to assess whether the sites can be included within the final Plan. The minutes of this meeting will be circulated to Executive on 26 January 2017.
Background
2. At the Executive on 7 December an update was provided on the Local Plan following the Preferred Sites consultation July – September 2016. It highlighted other factors that have arisen since the consultation and set out next steps for the consideration by Members. A significant aspect of this was the announcement by the MOD on the 7 November that they would be disposing of a number of military sites across the country as part of their Strategy – A Better Defence Estate. The announcement made on 7 November effectively confirmed the disposal of the three York sites: Imphal Barracks (estimated date of disposal 2031); Queen Elizabeth Barracks (estimated date of disposal 2021); and Towthorpe Lines (estimated date of disposal 2021).
3. The report indicated that technical work needed to be carried out to assess if the sites represented „reasonable alternatives‟ and if they did they would need to be considered as part of the Local Plan process. Any site identified as a „reasonable alternative‟ in the context of the SEA Regulations would need to be subject to public consultation. Not doing so would constitute a significant level of risk both in terms of the Local Plan Examination and potential legal challenge.
MOD Sites – Initial Technical Assessment
4. Following the Executive in December officers have been progressing work as quickly as possible. This has included meeting with the MOD to discuss the sites and ascertain any technical work completed to date for the sites. A further programme of meetings has been scheduled with the MOD to ensure that work progresses as quickly as possible and that existing work and evidence for the sites can be utilised to assess any issues raised through the technical officer assessment. Based on the information provided to date officers have considered the sites against the Local Plan Site Selection Methodology which is based on the emerging Plan‟s spatial strategy. The full methodology is set out in the Preferred Sites Document (2016). The sites have been tested against this methodology which is based on a four stage criteria approach as follows:
Criteria 1: Protecting environmental assets (including Historic Character and Setting, Nature Conservation assets and functional floodplain); Criteria 2: Protecting existing openspace; Criteria 3: Avoiding areas of high flood risk (Greenfield sites in flood zone 3a); Criteria 4a: Sustainable access to facilities and services; and Criteria 4b: Sustainable access to transport.
5. The outcomes of this assessment for criteria 1 to 3 are summarised below for each site. Imphal Barracks, Fulford (Gross Site Size 29.6ha): the site boundary includes part of a Green Wedge important in terms of the historic character and setting of York which may potentially reduce the site size; the site is adjacent to Walmgate Stray with its eastern boundary open to the Stray; and it includes areas of existing open space including sports pitches and public open space at Broadway which may potentially reduce the site size.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.