( i ) That the offer of a long lease for the land requested by English Heritage for the construction of a Clifford’s Tower visitor centre (shaded light blue on the plan at Annex 1) be retracted. (ii) That the offer of a two year lease for the adjacent land for the associated public piazza proposed as part of the visitor centre project (shaded orange on the plan at Annex 1) be retracted. Reason: To reflect the decision of English Heritage not to proceed with the visitor centre. ( i ) That the offer of a long lease for the land requested by English Heritage for the construction of a Clifford’s Tower visitor centre (shaded light blue on the plan at Annex 1) be retracted. (ii) That the offer of a two year lease for the adjacent land for the associated public piazza proposed as part of the visitor centre project (shaded orange on the plan at Annex 1) be retracted. Reason: To reflect the decision of English Heritage not to proceed with the visitor centre.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
1. Following the decision of English Heritage not to proceed with their plans to build a Visitor Centre for Clifford’s Tower, this report asks the Executive to reconsider the decision made in January 2017 to offer a long leasehold for the land required to build the Visitor Centre and the associated short term lease to create an adjacent public plaza.
Recommendations
2. Executive are asked to agree:
i) To retract the offer of a long lease for the land requested by English Heritage for the construction of a Clifford’s Tower visitor centre following their decision not to proceed with the proposed visitor centre (shaded light blue in Annex 1)
Reason: To reflect the decision of English Heritage not to proceed with the visitor centre
ii) To retract the offer of a two year lease for the adjacent land for the associated public plaza that was proposed as part of the visitor centre project (shaded orange in Annex 1)
Reason: To reflect the decision of English Heritage not to proceed with the visitor centre Background
3. English Heritage (EH) is the trading name for English Heritage Trust (EHT). They operate heritage assets under a licence from the Historic Buildings and Monuments Commission for England (HBMCE), whose trading name is Historic England. The ownership of Clifford’s Tower, therefore rests with HBMCE but it is managed and operated by EH.
4. In October 2016, EH (as the operational arm of HBMCE) received planning permission to build a new visitor centre as part of works to improve and restore Clifford’s Tower. The site of the proposed visitor centre was partly on council land and partly on HBMCE’s land, and EH consequently made a formal request to acquire the required land.
5. In response, in January 2017, Executive agreed to a package of land deals to both formalise the complicated ownership agreements relating to Clifford’s Tower and to allow the implementation of EH’s planning permission for the proposed restoration and development of a visitor centre. It was agreed to:
offer a temporary licence to allow the site compound for the remedial works to the tower and construction of a new visitor centre at the base of the motte (land edged blue in annex 1) offer a long lease on the section of council land required for the new visitor centre to be built (land shaded light blue in annex 1) offer a short term lease for an adjacent piece of council land for use as a public plaza as part of the new visitor centre development (land shaded orange in annex 1) to transfer freehold ownership of the section of the motte that is currently under council ownership but the guardianship of EH (land shaded pink in annex 1)
6. Since EH received planning permission for their proposals in October 2016 the planning decision has been subject to a period of Judicial Review (JR), and although the High Court dismissed the initial challenge a further appeal is now listed before the Court of Appeal on 23rd July 2018. During that judicial review period, EH have been positively engaged in the development of the Castle Gateway masterplan which includes the land surrounding Clifford’s Tower. In June 2018 EH notified the Council that following a strategic review of their proposals, and due to the exciting alternative opportunities offered by the masterplan (which was approved by the Executive in April 2018) they did not intend to take forward their existing plans for a visitor centre. Instead they are keen to undertake the conservation and restoration works to the tower and motte, and to work with the council as part of the Castle Gateway project to consider other options to improve the Clifford’s Tower visitor experience.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.