Recommended: That Council: (i) Note the letter from the Secretary of State and the issues as set out in the report. (ii) Approve the submission to Government of a case for City of York Council remaining a unitary on its existing footprint. (iii) Delegate authority to the Interim Head of Paid Service to make a submission, in line with the decision above, within the Government’s timescales. (iv) Approve the submission of a Strategic Partnership Agreement with North Yorkshire, which proposes areas of potential joint working between City of York Council and a new North Yorkshire unitary council to support efficient local government in the region. (v) Approve the submission of Devolution ‘Asks’ (as approved by Executive in July 2020) alongside the unitary submission, subject to the permissibility within this process, in order to progress devolution discussions with Government as quickly as possible. Reason: To ensure that an appropriate response, which benefits York, is submitted to Government within the required timescales.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
1. In July, Executive approved a set of “Asks” for a devolution deal, with the intention that these would be submitted to Government to allow the commencement of negotiation of a potential devolution deal for York and North Yorkshire. The Asks incorporated the devolution of significant powers to the region and around £2.4bn of investment to support inclusive economic growth and social and environmental wellbeing over a 30 year period.
2. Since Executive’s approval of the Asks, there have been some policy developments from Government which impact on both the possibilities for devolution and the future of local government in York and North Yorkshire.
3. At 5.15pm on Friday 9 October, the Secretary of State wrote to York and North Yorkshire Council Leaders to invite submissions of proposals to replace 2-tier (County and District) Local Authority structures with new unitary models. Initial submissions must be made by 9 November. Whilst York, as an existing unitary authority, does not need to change to meet this requirement, it is likely that proposals will be put forward from other authorities which include York in new structures. Given these exceptionally challenging timescales it is, therefore, necessary to update Executive as a matter of urgency.
4. From initial analysis of the options likely to be put forward, there are significant benefits of York remaining as a unitary on its existing footprint, in terms of:
a. the speed at which devolution may be achieved, b. the continuity of services at a time when it is critical for Covid recovery, and c. the continued identity of the city.
5. An option to merge York with surrounding districts would: a. increase the cost of council tax by £117 (8%) per year (based on PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) calculations), b. disrupt service delivery across York and districts, and c. end the 800-year connection between the city and the council, impacting on the very identify of the city.
Recommendations
6. Executive is asked to recommend to Full Council:
a. To note the letter from the Secretary of State and the issues as set out in this report.
b. To agree the submission to Government of a case for City of York Council remaining a unitary on its existing footprint.
c. To agree to delegate authority to the Interim Head of Paid Service to make a submission, in line with the decision above, within the Government’s timescales.
d. To agree the submission of a Strategic Partnership Agreement with North Yorkshire, which proposes areas of potential joint working between City of York Council and a new North Yorkshire unitary council to support efficient local government in the region.
e. To agree the submission of Devolution “Asks” (as approved at July’s Executive) alongside the unitary submission, subject to the permissibility within this process, in order to progress devolution discussions with Government as quickly as possible.
Background
7. As a region, Yorkshire has been discussing devolution for many years. In 2018, leaders across Yorkshire committed to developing a joined-up deal for One Yorkshire Devolution, a single deal across the whole of Yorkshire. York continues to be connected into both North and West Yorkshire through membership of York and North Yorkshire Local Enterprise Partnership (YNY LEP) and continuing non-constituent membership of West Yorkshire Combined Authority
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.