Procedural Business
26(a) Declaration of Substitutes 26.1 Cllr Sue Shanks attended as substitute for Cllr Pete West.
Every time Brighton and Hove's minutes name Councillor West, as the council published it.
26(a) Declaration of Substitutes 26.1 Cllr Sue Shanks attended as substitute for Cllr Pete West.
21.2 Councillor West commended the work which had been undertaken and welcomed the report but queried the rationale for recommissioning what was clearly been established as a good service.
Councillor West also expressed the view that it would be beneficial for Members to receive training in respect of contractual matters and the different approaches adopted as that would aid their understanding of the germane issues and processes involved.
24.3 Councillor West referred to the arrangements being made (Chair’s Communications) to roll out the vaccine, including care home residents who were being targeted specifically. The report sought to make additional bed spaces available, and he sought clarification regarding how this played against the current extreme funding pressures.
24.6 Councillor West enquired regarding regulation by central government, and it was explained that precise clarification was awaited.
8.2 Councillor West was informed about the intent of the delivery strategy, which was to inform staff about why they come to work, and the Council’s aims.
9.2 Councillor West was informed about why the Home Care DPS was being extended until 2028.
10.2 Councillor West was informed that the Procurement Advisory Board had previously agreed all of the Recommendations in the report.
11.2 Councillor West raised some concerns with the report.
12.2 Councillor West was informed by Robert Persey and Alistair Hill as to why there is more time needed to conduct stakeholder engagement. Sandra O’Brien confirmed that the recommendations were permissible and lawful.
12.3 Robert Persey agreed to give a written response to Councillor West regarding stakeholder engagement.
2.2 Councillor West noted that the All-Party Working Group on cycling recommended that Highway Authorities spend approximately £20 per person on cycling improvements every year. The proposal in the report recommended just over £1 per person in Brighton & Hove and was therefore some way off that recommendation and was not sufficient to tackle the health crisis and take action on climate change.
Councillor West noted the additional £3.9m capital funding for transport expenditure identified by a Green Group amendment passed at Budget Council and he believed it vital that there be democratic oversight and input as to how that funding was allocated.
Councillor West noted that it was critical that funding be invested where it would best benefit meeting carbon neutrality targets and the work of the Climate Assembly and Local Cycling Walking Infrastructure Plan needed to feed into those decisions.
Councillor West expressed his opinion that the Sustainability and Carbon Reduction Investment Fund Member Oversight Group (SCRIF MOG) should steer the committee on the allocations proposed at paragraph 3.8.
2.9 The Head of Transport Policy & Strategy stated that it may be useful to hold a briefing with Members for officers to go through road safety schemes and the differences and changes that had occurred since 2016. 2.10 Councillor West stated that Hove Station Footbridge required a proper proposal for replacement or other solution as using capital funding to prop up the structure was not sustainable.
Councillor West noted that he was aware that £900,000 of damage was caused by pavement parking every year. It was therefore very likely that the proposed £600,000 capital allocation would be for repairing damage and not for improvement or new pedestrian facilities.
Returning to the SCRIF MOG, Councillor West stated that the new investment meant that the Group’s terms of reference required revising and updating.
Councillor West stated that the target for carbon neutrality by 2030 would very likely need community ownership and community initiatives in working with the council and it was important for those groups to be able to access funding from the council.
3.2 Councillor West stated that the ward councillors welcomed the changes being made permanent and they would benefit residents and ease congestion around the Clock Tower.
4.2 Councillor West noted that the local cycle lobby had written to Members with their observations against the proposals for Circus Street and Freehold Terrace and had asked the committee to revisit the design. That was on the basis that the current design created a barrier to cycling as both sites could incorporate contraflow measures for cyclists.
Councillor West stated that he was minded to agree to that request and could not support the recommendations that dealt with those locations.
Councillor West noted that he was also aware that there were some objections to the consultation period and advertising of the TRO.
Councillor Wares stated that he hoped that Councillor West would hold a similar view on future decisions on the Valley Gardens project.
5.2 Councillor West noted that the proposal for Westdene was fully supported by his colleagues in Withdean ward.
6.2 Councillor West noted that there was no recycling of any of the materials collected under the current contract that he found a shame as there were undoubtably items collected that could be re-used.
Councillor West stated that all Members were concerned about Cityclean’s capacity to deliver services and the committee would be aware of the problems with the garden collections service that would also operate the new bulky collections service.
Councillor West stated that the in-house option was his preference but there needed to be a very honest appraisal on whether the service would work that way.
7.10 Councillor West stated that the current contract needed to be updated for the scheme to move forward and it already stood as one of the most successful schemes of its type in the country and was very important in keeping people active. Such schemes could be volatile in terms of income but the positives in areas such as health and air quality meant that the right support should be provided.
Councillor West stated that e-bikes would be a step change for the scheme as it would mean users were more easily able to tackle the challenging topography of Brighton & Hove and it could expand wider in the city a be a viable form of commuter travel.
Kitcat nominated Councillor West and this was seconded by Councillor Sykes.
47( a) Declarations of Substitute Members 47.1 Councillor West declared that he was attending as a substitute for Councillor Davey.
53.5 Councillor West agreed that it was easy to talk in jargon. He recalled that the council had been awarded a Crystal Mark for its use of plain English. However, if English was not the first language there would be a problem.
Councillor Mears thought this information could be provided to new tenants. 54.13 The Chair explained that the aim was to support people and to sustain tenancies. 54.14 Councillor West referred to paragraph 4.4 – Anti-social behaviour. He asked why the council did not report on all wards. The Head of Tenant Services stated that this information could be included in future reports.
56.6 John Melson considered that the council should retain all council property. 56.7 Councillor West also agreed that he could not see why tenants should not be able to live in these flats.
57.11 Councillor West referred to paragraph 7.4 of appendix 1. He queried if there would be consultation with people in the area on whether they wanted to be part of the extension of the area of benefit.
57.18 Councillor West referred to amendments to the constitution, Appendix 1, Paragraph 7. He was concerned that changes to the constitution could be made without notice. 57.19 Charles Penrose referred to Appendix 4, Paragraph 8 concerning the representative of the Area Panel. Presently, if a representative did not attend three consecutive meetings and had not sent apologies they were derecognised.
186.2 Councillor West stated that it was an important report and that whilst funding was available for some works that may result from the review, there could be costs associated with improvement works as recommended by review which would fall to the council unless other government funding was made available. He suggested that consideration needed to be given to this possibility and to how areas outside of the study could be accounted for and whether costs would be shared across those authorities affected. He also noted that the emerging seafront strategy would need t take account of key environmental aspects as well as sea defences.
75.9 Councillor West stated that he believed the Committee were correct to respond to the concerns raised about the removal of the tree by the local community however, his concerns that the retention of the tree would compromise increased accessibility remained.
76.7 Councillor West stated his support for the proposals as the latest part in improving road safety and sustainable travel that included Valley Gardens and Lewes Road.
Councillor West added that his personal experience as a pedestrian on Edward Street was very bad and he felt the traffic was an impediment to the communities on either side of the road.
Councillor West supplemented that improvements on the road would also assist transport links to the hospital, Amex Community Stadium and Brighton College all of which were key destinations in the area.
77.5 Councillor West thanked the Project Manager for his work. As ward councillor for the area he was aware how thorough the consultation had been via workshops, public meetings and meetings with community and traders associations.
Councillor West added that there were a number of complications arising from the location of a taxi rank on Fredrick Place and, whilst the possibility of doing so needed to be examined, it was clear that logistically and from the negative reaction from the North Laine Community Association and North Laine Traders Association that this was not viable.
Councillor West summarised that even though the issue of the relocation of the taxi rank had not been resolved, this would be offset by other benefits including a gyratory system and a large increase in pavement space.
78.2 Councillor West stated that he believed that introduction of a controlled parking scheme in the London Road Station South area had been the benefit and prevented displacement.
Councillor West noted that the overall result of the consultation had been equal and that he was in favour of accepting the recommendations to improve road safety.
78.8 Councillor West stated that the TRO process was quite distinct from the consultation process and the Committee could not assess the TRO responses alone.
79.3 Councillor West commended the work undertaken to regenerate the area that was demonstrating early success.
160.8 Councillor West welcomed the report and noted that funding had been levered in from CIVATS and the National Park Authority and he wished to thank the officers involved. There was a need to invest in the city and he welcomed the improved street lighting programme and choices for residents that were now available.
163.3 Councillor West welcomed the report and stated that he also wished to thank the Chief Executive for her contribution and measured approach to the revised corporate plan and the intention to combine the new commitments within the budget process. He drew the committee’s attention to the second priority on page 208 and stated that the committee should be encouraged by the work of officers in delivering changes.
164.3 Councillor West stated that it was an important piece of work and that there was a need to look at the efficient use of resources and the impact of climate change and to embed sustainability as an issue in everyone’s minds. The approach set out in the report outlined a clear way of to implement change and he hoped it would be taken forward.
164.8 Councillor West stated that the greenhouse gas emissions had been reduced by 3% and funding had been secured as part of the Green Deal from the government for improvements to homes.
65.2 Councillor West asked if the design brief presented to the Committee was the same as the one it had received previously in July 2012. In addition, he asked the Senior Project Manger to acknowledge the issue of traffic neutrality and the presence of elm trees.
65.4 Councillor West asked if a traffic reduction was considered in order to eradicate the need to build across the park.
65.13 Councillor West stated that whilst he believed there were many good aspects to the proposed scheme which would deliver improvements, he had numerous concerns.
Councillor West stated that he was uneasy about the impact of two lanes of traffic in the natural open spaces of Valley Gardens including a possible third stretch of road on Marlborough Place.
Councillor West noted that he had checked the brief provided to Committee in July 2012 which he believed differed to the one presented to Committee at this meeting. Specifically, there was less traffic and more tranquillity and that the potential of the scheme had not been met with the current proposals.
Councillor West added that whilst he appreciated that aspects of the scheme had been consulted on, he believed that the specific details of the scheme, particularly the new elements, should be consulted on again as the public must have ownership of the Valley gardens scheme.
Councillor West stated that he believed the scheme could be improved adding that because of the constraints of a traffic neutral scheme and the narrowing of green spaces, the current design would create little more than a central reservation.
65.14 Councillor Janio asked the Senior Project Manager if the proposals would lead to a significant loss of green space as described by Councillor West.
65.16 Councillor West formally moved the following amendments to the recommendations as shown below:
She explained that Cllr Pete West was not able to attend the meeting due to the ill-health of a family member and time was given for the panel and witnesses to read his submission (see attached).
141.7 Councillor West noted that in regard to the expenditure for travellers, it was a variable matter which was subject to changes throughout the year and he believed that the costs had been managed well to date.
142.6 Councillor West stated that over 27,000 households were being consulted and noted that the pilot scheme had been positively welcomed and he hoped that it would be taken forward, however it would depend on the outcome of the consultation.
142.11 Councillor West noted that two opposition groups were not prepared to outline their positions in regard to the budget proposals at this point and suggested that it had been an open and transparent process, involving more people than before. He believed that there had been a well managed approach and noted that the value for money exercise was outperforming its objectives and hoped that the budget could be taken forward and be supported by the council as a whole.
110.5 Councillor West stated that he was concerned about the potential impact on the budget of the additional £7m cost and the impact on local businesses.
111.3 Councillor West formally seconded the proposed amendment.
111.5 Councillor West stated that should the Mobile Library be retained, there was a need to replace the actual vehicle at a significant capital cost, and when taken into account with the reduced level of service and the actual number of users of the service, it was not value for money. The proposed expanded home delivery service in Option 7 would provide a better service for more people and was already working well in Patcham.
113.7 Councillor West stated that the sustainability factors would need to be monitored and taken into account in regard to the life-time cost of new buildings and improved energy costs and contributions to the sustainable footprint of the city. He believed it was an important plan for the future and provided for a flexible approach.
117.3 Councillor West stated that it was important to give an indication of the council’s intention to have a low carbon economy and to signal its concerns over the process of ‘Fracking.’ 117.4 Councillor Mitchell stated that the Labour & Co-operative Group were supportive of the recommendation and suggested that a regional strategy should be developed to support this concern.
125.4 Councillor West stated that the proposed works would also bring a number of the seafront arches back into use which would benefit the area.
128.2 Councillor West welcomed the report and stated that it was helpful to have the information set out as to what was already taking place in the council and what was being taken forward. He believed the set of principles were very good and provided for potential opportunities to undertake shared, partnership of joint working.
47.4 Councillor West relayed that this was an important issue that had already been considered and approved in principal by the Committee. He believed that it would be to the merit of the entire city to approve the proposals which could have the added benefit of improving tourism in the city.
48.7 Councillor West stated that he believed the motion was ineffective as some B roads already had 20mph limits. Agreeing the motion would mean increasing the limits on those roads which was illogical.
Councillor West relayed that of 3,600 respondents to the consultation, 55% were in favour of implementation and, importantly, Sussex Police had not stated any objection to the scheme.
Councillor West added that the average speed of traffic in the Phase 1 area was 24mph so 20mph would not be a significant reduction and that 70-80% of journey time in the city was spent at junctions or traffic lights and ‘smoother’ transit arising from driving at 20mph could improve traffic flow and air quality.
Councillor West highlighted that 43% of pedestrian road casualties and 48% of cycle accidents in the city occurred within the area identified for the Phase 1 scheme. The Scrutiny Panel of 2010 had stated that “vulnerable road users need to be protected” and he believed the proposals within the report would ensure this.
Councillor West stated that the scheme would necessitate coherency and consistency which the proposed Phase 1 area would deliver.
Councillor West did not agree that A roads and some B roads could be exempt from the scheme.
49.6 As a ward councillor for the area, Councillor West thanked residents and traders that had contributed to the consultation and informally on the project. He noted this was a big project in a compact residential area and accordingly, sometimes concerns would be realised at a late stage.
Councillor West supported the delay in order to make sure the project was right.
50.12 Councillor West stated that he was pleased with the proposals as safety at the Dials had been getting worse over the past few years and that the proposals had support from the public and local businesses.
Councillor West added that he was pleased with the introduction of zebra crossings which provided pedestrian empowerment and the removal of the barriers for the same reason.
Councillor West supplement that he was glad support would be offered to those visually impaired.
53.7 Councillor West stated that the Labour & Co-Operative party had first stated resident parking schemes when in administration.
Councillor West added that the council had a duty to manage parking spaces and demand.
54.4 Councillor West stated that he interpreted the factual information provided in the report to be different to the public debate on the topic of parking. It demonstrated that the weather and rising price of fuel had had an impact and he believed the opposition parties’ conduct in the debate had not done the city justice.
The panel would hear firstly from Councillor Pete West and accompanying officers about Environment and Sustainability, and secondly from Councillor Geoffrey Bowden and officers about Economic Development and Culture.
Councillor Pete West, Lead Councillor for Environment & Sustainability (E&S) introduced the budget proposals:
268.1 Councillor West introduced the report which detailed the outcome of a review and sought approval of a revised waste management strategy and action plan. He stated that he believed it was an excellent strategy and wished to thank the Waste Advisory Group for their work in putting the strategy together.
268.4 Councillor West stated that the trial food waste collection would provide real data and enable an evaluation to be made. However, if the bid failed then there would need to be a reassessment of the position. In regard to the collection of glass this would continue to be collected on a separate basis.
108.1 Councillor Davey and Councillor West both noted they were looking forward to working within the Committee Structure, and hoped it would be both constructive and co-operative.
108.2 Councillor West noted he had attended the formal opening of the renovation project at the Rock Gardens; he noted volunteers and local school children had helped work on the project, and hoped the area could be enjoyed by all.
Councillor West went on to say that £145k had been secured to improve playground facilities and equipment for children with disabilities, and young people would be involved in the design ideas.
110.1 Councillor West considered a report of the Strategic Director, Place. He noted that a cross party working group had considered the matter, and consulted with residents in 2011; it had been agreed that the scheme would be self-funding, and amendments to the scheme had been made to reduce the cut off hour for evening charging from 2000 to 1800.
Councillor West noted that charging at the weekend was necessary to ensure the scheme was self-funding; the charges were relatively low; a review would take place after 6 months and the scheme addressed safety concerns at the park.
235.2 Councillor West declared a personal and non-prejudicial interest in Item 252, Stanmer Park – Traditional Agricultural Buildings Update, as he was a member of the Brighton & Hove Estates Conservation Trust which leased buildings in the Park and also a member of the South Downs National Park Authority.
246.6 Councillor West stated that this was the first time that a clear goal had been set out in this regard for sometime and the council needed to embrace it and take actions to work towards meeting the standards, which he believed would result in a positive impact and in the long-term enable savings to be made.
252.1 Councillor West introduced the report stated that following the surrender of Home Farm agricultural tenancy, the council had obtained vacant possession of the traditional agricultural buildings located within Stanmer Village. Having acquired the buildings it was proposed to draw up a revised Downland Estates Policy that would enable the restoration and refurbishment of the buildings so that they could be put back into mixed use. It was intended to establish a project team to take the work forward and produce a feasibility study that could then lead to the use of the buildings in the future.
252.4 Councillor West noted the comments and stated that he believed there was a need to revise the feasibility study and look to encourage support from other parties so as to enable the restoration and re-use of the buildings. He also wished to move an amendment to recommendation 2.1 to include the word ‘City’ in front of Downland.
92.1 Councillor West provided the following communications:
94i.2 Councillor West provided the following response:
94ii.2 Councillor West provided the following response:
94iv.2 Councillor West provided the following response:
94v.2 Councillor West provided the following response:
So, we are proposing the compromise of a “peak hours only” loading prohibition on one side of the road between Holland Road and Montpelier Road). 94v.3 Councillor Theobald stated that the petitioner had made valid points and asked Councillor West to reject the proposals. He believed a more flexible approach on this issue was successfully operated in other countries in mainland Europe.
94v.4 Councillor West noted that the Council had also been lobbied in favour of the proposals as evidenced on page 116 of the agenda.
94vi.2 Councillor West provided the following response:
100.1 Councillor West considered a report of the Strategic Director, Place that sought approval for the procurement of a contract for the construction work as part of The Level restoration project.
100.2 Councillor West stated that he was very pleased to be presenting the report that sought approval for the procurement of the construction contract for the redevelopment of The Level. The contract would be key to delivering the improvements to The Level including restoration of the heritage features, construction of the new café, toilets, play areas and the new water feature.
Councillor West stated that works on site will commence in the autumn with the majority being completed ready for next summer.
100.6 Councillor West replied that a decision had been taken on the location of the skate park. Officers were now working on the ‘soft detail’ of the project.
101.1 Councillor West considered a report of the Strategic Director, Place that set out progress made towards Brighton and Hove achieving UN Biosphere Reserve status and sought approval for the next stages of the work plan and engagement and communication plan.
101.2 Councillor West stated that he was very pleased to present the report which set out the progress of Biosphere project, and the next steps towards submission of the bid to UNESCO.
Councillor West added that Biosphere was about conserving the natural environment, not just for enjoyment and health, but also to protect essential requirements for life such as clean water and air, and local food production, now and in the long term.
Councillor West supplemented that key partners had signed up to the project including four neighbouring local authorities, the National Park, the National Trust, the Sussex Wildlife Trust and the Environment Agency. The Biosphere project would be hugely beneficial for the city and the surrounding area, bringing together the wide range of work being undertaken and delivering coordinated actions to conserve the environment It would help raise the profile of Brighton & Hove nationally and internationally, and provide opportunities for sustainable economic development The Biosphere bid had already played a key part in the successful joint Nature Improvement Area funding bid with the national park worth £660k. This would bring approximately £116k of external funding into the city for habitat improvement and get the public more involved in their environment.
Councillor West stated that he was looking forward to the formal launch of the Biosphere in May and the subsequent public engagement activity to help inform the management plan submitted as part of the final bid.
101.7 Councillor West agreed that it would have been ideal to provide information at an earlier date however; the Biosphere Project Officer had only been undertaking work since being appointed to the post in September 2011.
102.1 Councillor West considered a report of the Strategic Director, Place that shared the results of the public consultation on infrastructure improvements to Lewes Road and details as to the nature of the infrastructure changes the Council was seeking to deliver.
102.2 Councillor West stated that he was pleased to present the report that provided an update on the progress made so far with the Lewes Road Local Sustainable Transport Fund (LSTF) project and outlined the proposed next steps.
Councillor West noted that there has been a strong response to the initial consultation that had indicated that sustainable modes, bus, foot and bike were the predominant travel modes for local people. Respondents had also reported that their travel experience was poor, blighted by congestion, inconsiderate parking, and for cyclists a lack of actual and perceived safety.
Councillor West said that the information gathered from local people had been used to help identify and design specific improvement schemes for Lewes Road. The proposals identified had been developed in partnership with members of the local community and had support from a number of key stakeholders including Brighton and Sussex Universities, Brighton & Hove Buses, The Big Lemon, Brighton & Hove Albion Football Club and The Jo Walters Trust - a charity set up by the family of Jo Walters who died cycling to University on Lewes Road in 2010.
Councillor West added that being able to travel safely and sustainable along the Lewes Road is of great importance to local residents and business, but also to the city as a whole. With plans to expand the Amex Stadium, the Albion were keen to build on their success in encouraging fans to travel sustainably, and the Lewes Road improvements would be key to enabling that.
Councillor West supplemented that the improvements would also underpin sustainable travel choices for those experiencing the new national park, and the developing Eco Tourism offer.
Councillor West stated that a second consultation on the detailed proposals outlined in the report would take place in April 2012 for a further 6 week period. Subject to the results of that consultation, construction work could commence in late 2012.
102.5 Councillor West apologised to Councillor Mitchell for the lack of a briefing on the project adding that it was important for opposition Members to be kept informed on such a major undertaking.
Councillor West agreed that there would be a cross over period when the work was being carried out. The Principal Transport Planning Officer supplemented that the work proposed for Eastern Road was the development of a bus priority infrastructure not an increase in the number of buses.
103.1 Councillor West considered a report of the Strategic Director, Place that requested extensions of the Area C and Area H Resident Parking Schemes and the necessary pay and display equipment to ensure implementation.
103.2 Councillor West introduced the report which considered the outcome of the public consultations undertaken. The first was for a proposed extension to the Area C Residents Parking Scheme (Queens Park area) into the Richmond Heights area and the second for a proposed extension to the Area H resident parking scheme (RSCH area) into Canning Street.
Councillor West stated that there was a good response rate to both consultations, with majority support among respondents in favour of resident parking schemes being implemented.
Councillor West added that ward councillors had also been consulted and expressed their support for taking this forward to the formal Traffic Order consultation.
104.1 Councillor West considered a report of the Strategic Director, Place that outlined actions that the council would have to undertake to introduce a permit scheme in Brighton and Hove following a Notice of Motion agreed at Full Council in October 2011.
104.2 Councillor West stated that he was pleased to present the report which discussed the provision of a Permit Scheme for the city.
Councillor West said that a permit scheme would give more direct control of road works on the city’s streets; road workers would have to seek permission rather than the current requirement to simply provide notice to the Council of their intention to do work.
Councillor West added that a permit scheme should be cost neutral and was not an opportunity for the council to raise income from utility companies. Council works would also be “permitted” and parity must be shown between Council and non council highway works.
Councillor West stated that the report recommended creating a full business case which would in turn help the Council to decide if a Permit Scheme was operationally and financially appropriate for the city.
Councillor West noted a change to the report recommendation 2.1 which would read ‘presented to a Committee Meeting’ rather than ‘presented to a CMM’ due to changes to the authorities’ governance structure effective from May 2012.
105.1 Councillor West considered a report of the Strategic Director, Place that requested approval for various changes to Controlled Parking Zones (CPZ) following consideration of the comments, support and objections received.
105.2 Councillor West explained that the Council received a significant amount of requests for changes to parking throughout the City and the report responded to the request of residents, businesses and Ward Councillors. The report considered the comments, support and objections received to an amendment Traffic Regulation Order and contained proposals for 150 roads. The amendments include the provision of safety improvements such as waiting restrictions to improve visibility at junctions and often help to improve sustainable transport.
105.4 Councillor West agreed and asked officers if a risk assessment could be conducted for the site before implementation.
105.7 Councillor West replied that he was content that a compromise had been reached and all views had been considered. The Parking Infrastructure Manager added that introducing a loading ban on only one side would be less disruptive to parking. It was explained that there are two main reasons why the loading ban is on the north side of the road only.
106.1 Councillor West considered a report of the Strategic Director, Place that outlined proposals for introducing a contraflow cycle network in the North Laine area and sought permission to advertise the associated Traffic Regulation Orders for the first phase of streets where contraflow cycling networks can be introduced.
Councillor West stated that Contraflow cycling was already common in the North Laine and these new measures would help to address some of the concerns raised by local businesses and residents regarding cyclists who use pavements and twittens .
Councillor West noted that the proposals had been taken to a number of public meetings, and had been largely well received, particularly by The North Laine Traders Association.
Councillor West added the work would continue with local groups to iron out any emerging issues whilst seeking to keep the measures as simple and easily understood as possible.
221.2 Councillor West stated that he wished to thank the panel for their work and the various witnesses that had given evidence and welcomed the report. He believed it had been a valuable piece of work and stated that it had contributed to the development of the strategy. It was an excellent example of how the scrutiny process could be utilised to formulate policy and he hoped that it would continue to be used in such a way under the proposed new governance arrangements.
221.6 Councillor West stated that with regard to the Sussex-wide protocol he would raise it with colleagues from East and West Sussex and in relation to recommendation 22, he felt that councillors had a responsible role to play and should therefore have the opportunity to keep abreast of matters through training.
222.1 Councillor West introduced the report and stated that he was delighted to present to the Traveller Commissioning Strategy to the Cabinet. He believed that it outlined a strategy which responded to balancing the needs of the travelling community as well as local people. The strategy was based on four underlying principles, to improve site availability, to improve health, safety and wellbeing, to improve education outcomes and to improve community cohesion.
222.4 Councillor West stated that the numbers did vary and the figures used showed a snap shot in time. He stated that he would raise the question with the Secretary of State in regard to having a National Framework for dealing with unauthorised encampments and noted that improvements had been made recently to prevent incursions to certain areas within the city.
223.1 Councillor West introduced the report which outlined the proposals to meet the requirements of the Housing Act 2004, which required local authorities to assess the accommodation needs of Gypsies and Travellers and to have a strategy that meets those needs.
Councillor West stated that he was pleased to present the report and believed the proposed extension of Horsdean to provide a permanent site was the best option. He was aware that part of the area fell within the National Park boundary and stated that officers had worked with the National Park Authority to ensure that the park’s character was maintained. He also noted that should the report be approved there would be a full consultation process.
223.4 Councillor West noted the comments and stated that there would be a need to address landscaping issues so that the two sites were separated and that the rents would need to be reasonable. He believed that there would be further improvements as a result of locating the permanent site at Horsdean and that it was the best solution.
231.3 Councillor West welcomed the proposal and stated that he felt that the number of conversations to HMOs was too high and that there was a need to reduce the levels of concentrations of HMOs. He accepted that it might lead to a degree of displacement, but hoped that it would prevent the loss of other households in areas.
63.1 Councillor West presented the following communication:
65ii.2 Councillor West provided the following response:
65vi.2 Councillor West provided the following response:
71.2 Councillor West explained that the Budget Process Report 2010/11 agreed at Cabinet in July 2009 specified that Fees and Charges are assumed to increase by a standard inflation rate each year, which is 2% for 2012/13. It was not always possible when amending a fee to increase it by exactly 2% each year, therefore there may be some rounding to the nearest whole figure. The implications of any additional revenue had been included in the budget setting process for 2012-13.
Councillor West went on to highlight the unprecedented financial pressure placed upon the authority by central government austerity measures and the effect this had placed upon the budget setting process.
71.5 Councillor West responded that the council had been disproportionately hit by the central government austerity measures and had to find savings where they could to preserve jobs.
Councillor West believed the administration had justified savings and the rises in fees where applicable and relayed his interest in hearing proposals from the opposition groups.
72.1 Councillor West considered a report of the Strategic Director, Place that sought approval for the procurement of a new Traveller Waste contract.
72.2 Councillor West explained that the report proposed the procurement of a new contract to manage waste and recycling for Traveller sites in the city.
Councillor West stated the he had asked a team of officers to look at how the council could ensure it gets value for money out of the new contract and they had looked at what elements of the service could be better provided in-house.
Councillor West stated that he was pleased that this saving was identified and would also ensure that travellers visiting Horsdean get the same level of service as other residents in the city Councillor West explained that officers would also look to utilise the council’s Housing Repairs & Improvement partner Mears Limited for some of the repairs to the Horsdean site Councillor West noted that the contract would aim to increase levels of recycling and reduce waste, litter and fly-tipping associated with unauthorised encampments at the Horsdean transit site.
The Council would also work to increase awareness amongst Travellers and take enforcement action where necessary in order to achieve this Councillor West stated that the procurement would include stipulations to ensure the successful bidder had high sustainability standards including minimising carbon emissions from their operations, reducing waste sent to land-fill and maximising recycling The procurement would follow European Union OJEU regulations and the new contract should be awarded towards the end of August 2012.
72.4 Councillor West replied that the report recommended savings to a contract agreed by Councillor Theobald when he was Cabinet Member for Environment.
Councillor West stated that it was essential to normalise conditions at unauthorised sites to reflect those across the city.
73.1 Councillor West considered a report of the Strategic Director, Place that recommended new measures for parking regulation at Preston Park.
73.2 Councillor West stated he was pleased to present the report which set out proposals to address the issue of long stay parking in Preston Park.
73.5 Councillor West thanked Councillor Mitchell for her agreement that the proposals were the right way to address the issue. He agreed it absolutely right to monitor the issue and he would be doing so.
73.7 Councillor West agreed that this would be a good idea to monitor developments.
73.9 Councillor West replied that it was deemed necessary to charge for the first hour of parking as this would adequately cover the cost of enforcement with any surplus re-invested back into the Park.
74.1 Councillor West considered a report of the Strategic Director, Place that summarised the response to the consultation proposing a trial of communal recycling in Brunswick and Adelaide ward and permission to begin that trial.
74.2 Councillor West explained that the existing black box recycling service performed less well in the city centre than elsewhere for reasons which included that people have less room to store their recycling, there is a higher turnover of population and many people do not know how to access the service. Plans for a communal recycling trial were set out in the waste strategy and support from Brunswick and Adelaide Wards came through the Community Waste Forum. Cityclean consulted with over 3,000 residents in the area asking them if they want to try communal recycling. 17% of people responded and of those 87% supported the trial.
159.1 The Chair noted that there were two notices of motion referred for consideration from the Council meeting held on the 15 th December, regarding City in Bloom Brighton & Hove and Intelligent Commissioning and the Community & Voluntary Sector. 159.2 Councillor West referred to the City in Bloom motion and noted that the Administration’s previous budget proposals had been sent out for consultation and following feedback on those proposals, there had been a change to the proposed reductions for City in Bloom announced yesterday. These provided funding for the next year with the intention of enabling a transitional phase so that provision could continue but without such financial support from the council.
160.7 Councillor West queried what the potential impact would be for the council’s budget if a council tax freeze was agreed rather than the proposed 3.5% rise.
172.1 Councillor West introduced the report and welcomed its submission which provided a snap shot of the current state of the local environment within the city. He wished to congratulate the City Sustainability Partnership on commissioning the review and to thank the Sustainability Team for their work in putting the report together. It had proved to be a large piece of work and he noted that the City Sustainability Partnership would need to decide on how often to update the information.
172.4 Councillor West noted the comments and stated that he shared Councillor Mitchell’s frustration in regard to identifying outcomes, but noted that there was a need to have the resources and genuine political commitment to the process from all groups.
141.1 Councillor West introduced the report which outlined the revised waste management strategy and the intention to put it out for consultation before being brought back to Cabinet for final approval. He noted that recycling rates were falling and that the revised strategy had ambitious targets to be met by 2025. He also wished to thank the officers involved for their work in preparing the revised strategy.
141.4 Councillor West stated that there was only so much waste that people wanted to store in their own gardens and the proposed collection was another strand to that and would be trailed in areas where collections could be made easily.
142.1 Councillor West introduced the report and stated that it outlined the refreshed Brighton & Hove Food Strategy which the council was being asked to endorse as one of the partner organisations to the development of the strategy. He noted that it had a number of long-term aims and ambitious objectives and sought to support the Sustainable Community Strategy. He also wished to thank the Food Partnership and officers involved in the revision of the strategy.
142.5 Councillor West stated that he was happy to raise the question of partnership working with the National Park Authority and would provide a written response to Councillor Mitchell on the question of community allotments.
29.13 Following Member questioning Cllr Kitcat and Cllr West left the room. Commission Members debated whether or not to refer the decision back to Cabinet.
(Note that this item was considered after Item 19) 23.1 The Strategic Director Place Geoff Raw said Councillor Pete West regretted that he had had to give apologies for this meeting. He introduced the report stating that many of the actions following the scrutiny review of climate change adaptation fell within his area, although much of the work done pre-dated his Strategic Directorship. The work of the scrutiny panel chaired by the independent specialist Professor Gordon MacKerron had been helpful.
23.4 The Head of Sustainability and Environmental Policy remarked that he was working closely with Cabinet Member Councillor Pete West. Policy Development Officer Lisa Shaw had investigated major severe weather events that had affected the City over the last decade. These could now be used to develop risk assessment related to future local climate impact projections.
5.6 Councillor Pete West, Cabinet Member for Environment and Sustainability, told the meeting he looked forward to a beneficial, productive, open and inclusive relationship with Scrutiny. He said he was already tackling a number of key issues.
5.8 Councillor West said the State of the Local Environment report made grim reading. Asked to expand on this, he referred to indicators on recycling, drinking and seawater quality and the Council’s carbon footprint.
17.5 Councillor West, who had been a Member of the ECSOSC, explained that the Committee had found the existing methodology to be lacking and made a number of recommendations to officers. The new methodology addressed the Committee’s concerns and demonstrated the important role of scrutiny in policy development.
87a.4 Councillor West suggested that more information was required for the Cabinet Member to make an informed decision and that a report was required.
89.4 Councillor West reported that the e-petition had been initiated by Councillor Kennedy prior to the progress detailed in the deputation, which had taken place in a relatively short period of time and was welcomed.
93.3 Councillor West welcomed the proposals in the report overall, but queried the decision not to implement a shared space for pedestrians and cyclists at Argyle Road. He also requested clarification on the use of Cycle Town funding for the scheme when larger schemes would not be going ahead.
Declaration of Substitutes 19.1 Councillor West declared that he was substituting for Councillor Kennedy.
28.8 Councillor West agreed and felt that whilst an online survey was a good idea he felt that residents might expect that extra weight be given to the results, and online surveys excluded those who did not have access to a computer. He believed it was necessary to ensure residents were aware that the purposes of the survey was merely to extend the debate and was not a proper survey.
29.3 Councillor West asked who had decided the Council’s response to the consultation and noted that the consultation paper was merely about the technicalities behind running referendums, and not whether Council’s supported the idea of referendums themselves.
Councillor Pete West also advised the panel that he had been working with a group in Ditchling Rise on road traffic issues and had presented a petition from the group at a Cabinet Member Meeting.
85(ii) Petition – Traffic in Ditchling Rise 85.4 Councillor West presented a petition signed by 170 people requesting a meeting with traffic engineers to discuss measures to reduce the amount of traffic in Ditchling Rise.
1b Declaration of interest 1.2 Cllr West declared that he had previously supported a petition for a 20 mph speed limit in one area of his ward.
203b.1 The Cabinet considered the following Notice of Motion proposed by Councillor West:
203b.2 Councillor West was unable to attend the meeting and speak to the motion.
Evidence from Councillor Pete West 81.1 Councillor West thanked the Commission for establishing the call-in meeting and for giving interested parties the opportunity to address the committee.
81.2 Councillor West informed members that the matter of the disposal of the ice rink had first been brought to his attention when it was included in the Council’s Forward Plan. Although there had been a subsequent exchange of e-mails with officers in Property & Design, and the 12 February 2009 Cabinet report had stated that ward councillors had been consulted, at no stage had the three ward councillors in fact been asked for their views on this issue.
Councillor West felt that this approach to the disposal of a sensitive site had been unhelpful and was disrespectful of the roles of elected representatives.
81.4 Councillor West also pointed out that the informal planning guidance note drawn up in relation to the Ice Rink site had not been included with the Cabinet report papers. In his view some passages in the report were incorrect, other information was incomplete, and Cabinet had been asked to decide on the disposal on the basis of flawed information.
81.5 As Cabinet had been unable to make an impartial and informed decision, Councillor West believed that the matter should be re-considered with all the pertinent information made available.
81.6 In response to members’ questions, Councillor West stated that he had initiated dialogue on the Ice Rink disposal with Property & Design; that he did not consider this contact with the relevant council department to amount to ‘consultation’ on the issue; that he had not known of the existence of the informal planning guidance note until shortly before the Cabinet meeting;
81.14 Councillor Fallon-Khan explained that, at the 12 February Cabinet meeting there had been some confusion over whether Councillor West had been consulted about the Ice Rink proposal, but that it was now evident that he had in fact been consulted.
When Councillor Mary Mears had spoken at Cabinet she had not acknowledged that Councillor West was not consulted, but rather had said if Councillor West had not been consulted it would have been regrettable.
Officers also offered to go through the property evaluation and proposed scheme in detail with Councillor West.
172.2 The Chairman invited Councillor West to address the meeting.
172.3 Councillor West spoke as a Ward Councillor and on behalf of concerned residents in the neighbourhood. He recognised the need for development in the city, but was concerned that residents had not been consulted at this stage. He appreciated that the majority of concerns raised were pertinent directly to the Planning Committee but felt that, given the sensitive nature of the area and the number of existing community groups, that consultation at this stage would have been beneficial.
172.4 Councillor West noted that the report contained reference to a proposed five or six storey building. This, he stated, was contrary to the councils own planning guidance. He felt that a proposal of this type would struggle to obtain planning consent and could deleterious consequences for future proposals for the site.
Councillor West requested that that the recommendations’ made in the report not be approved.
172.5 Councillor West noted that the report stated that Ward Councillors had been consulted; he explained that this was not the case.
(A) Declarations of Substitutes 36.1 Councillor West declared that he was attending the meeting as substitute for Councillor Duncan.
46.3 Councillor West welcomed the proposed change of name as it would better reflect the area to be served by the ward. However, he was also concerned about the loss of identification for Hollingbury and therefore wished to propose an additional recommendation to the report.
48.3 Councillor West referred to the draft article in appendix 1 and suggested that it was too impersonal and should be looked at e.g.
1a Declarations of substitutions 1.1 Councillor Pete West for Councillor Ben Duncan.
8.( xxiii) Petition - request to reconsider the proposed location of a communal bin halfway along St Nicholas Road 8.78 Councillor West presented a petition signed by 65 people concerning a request to reconsider the proposed location of a communal bin halfway along St Nicholas Road.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor West attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor West's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor West was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 1 of 4 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor West declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Apr 2014 | Housing Management Consultative Sub-Committee, item 47 | 47( a) Declarations of Substitute Members 47.1 Councillor West declared that he was attending as a substitute for Councillor Davey. | |
| 19 Apr 2012 | Cabinet (pre 2012), item 235 | 235.2 Councillor West declared a personal and non-prejudicial interest in Item 252, Stanmer Park – Traditional Agricultural Buildings Update, as he was a member of the Brighton & Hove Estates Conservation Trust which leased buildings in the Park and also a member of the South Downs National Park Authority. | |
| 28 Sep 2010 | Governance Committee, item 19 | Declaration of Substitutes 19.1 Councillor West declared that he was substituting for Councillor Kennedy. | |
| 19 Jan 2010 | Environment and Community Safety Overview and Scrutiny Committee Ad Hoc Panel - 20mph speed limits/zones - Completed, item 1 | 1b Declaration of interest 1.2 Cllr West declared that he had previously supported a petition for a 20 mph speed limit in one area of his ward. | |
| 18 Nov 2008 | Governance Committee, item 36 | (A) Declarations of Substitutes 36.1 Councillor West declared that he was attending the meeting as substitute for Councillor Duncan. |
Where Councillor West sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Feb 2024 | 3 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Audit, Standards & General Purposes Committee | Chair | Sep 2025 | 2 | 24 Nov 2026 |
| Housing Management Panel: North Area | Committee Member | Nov 2026 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.