Question Time
Question from Councillor Greg Smith to Councillor Peter Strachan, Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Planning.
Every time Buckinghamshire's minutes name Councillor Strachan, as the council published it.
Question from Councillor Greg Smith to Councillor Peter Strachan, Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Planning.
The following members attended to ask questions to the following Cabinet Members: · Question from Councillor Stuart Wilson to Councillor Isobel Darby, Cabinet Member for Health and Wellbeing · Question from Councillor Robin Stuchbury to Councillor Peter Strachan, Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Planning · Question from Councillor Larisa Townsend to Councillor Ade Osibogun, Cabinet Member for Education and Children’s Services.
Speakers Local Ward Members : Councillor P Strachan, Councillor S Bowles and Councillor R Newcombe.
· Cllr Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning and Regeneration · Eric Owens, Service Director, Planning and Environment The Committee was informed that Buckinghamshire Council is one of the largest and busiest Local Planning Authorities (LPAs) in the country, with the biggest (in terms of application workload) councils went to appeal in the year ending March 2024.
The following questions were asked:- Question from Cllr Stuart Wilson to Cllr Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning & Regeneration Buckinghamshire Councillors and Town & Parish Councils consider the responses of residents, as well as statutory and non-statutory organisations, in fulfilling their duties to respond to planning applications.
The following questions were asked:- Question from Councillor Stuart Wilson to Councillor Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning and Regeneration There is significant public interest for all council taxpayers and particularly those residents who will be impacted by the various matters relating to Little Marlow Lakes Country Park including restoration works, the creation of a Suitable Alternative Natural Greenspace for development at Hollands Farm, the formal designation of a country park, and the relationship to the Marlow Film Studios planning appeal. Should Cabinet choose to accept the Recommendations or a version thereof contained within the Cabinet Report, will the Cabinet Member please confirm that Buckinghamshire Council will pursue full recovery of all Council investment in purchasing and improving this site through a gateway payment in a s106 agreement referenced at paragraph 6.5 so that there is no “free ride” for the landowners, promoters and developers of Hollands Farm at the taxpayers’ expense and that any legal or financial agreement that has or will be made with Dido for the fields to the north of the Council-owned land at Spade Oak will be made public in advance of the public inquiry on the Marlow Film Studio planning appeal in the residents’ interest of transparency?
Question from Councillor Stuart Wilson to Councillor Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning and Regeneration A political leaflet from prominent Buckinghamshire Councillors was distributed recently in Chalfont St Giles stating they were “fighting plans for 100,000 homes on local Green Belt” which I take to mean Green Belt in Buckinghamshire rather than Chalfont St Giles.
Question from Councillor Robin Stuchbury to Councillor Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning and Regeneration “Please can you provide detailed information on how many planning appeals are currently taking place in Buckinghamshire and which took place in 2023 - 2024, including legal fees, officer time, if these costs have been reported to Cabinet or a Select Committee meeting and in addition how many planning permissions have been refused by a Planning Committee against officer recommendations to approve?” Response from Councillor Peter Strachan There are a total of 139 planning appeals (excluding enforcement appeals) currently in progress as of the 27th September 2024. The detailed split of appeal types comprises 40 fast track householder appeals, 10 Hearings, 7 public inquiries and 82 written representation appeals.
Question from Councillor Stuart Wilson to Councillor Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning and Regeneration “What reassurance can the Cabinet Member provide that the consideration of nil rating for Community Infrastructure Levy on 400+ dwelling developments for North and Central areas (in line with East and South but not the West area which does charge CIL on 400+ dwelling developments) will not limit Buckinghamshire Council’s ability to address wider infrastructure needs beyond that which can be addressed by s106 agreements which are legally restricted to only the incremental impact of the planning application in question rather than existing community infrastructure issues or the cumulative impact of multiple developments, and that this will not set a precedent for CIL on 400+ dwelling developments in the West area (acknowledged to be an older tariff introduced in 2012) to be legally challenged by developers where the Wycombe Local Plan has identified clear infrastructure requirements that may require both s106 and CIL funding to ensure they are deliverable, such as the link road through Hollands Farm in Policy BE2 and the new medical facilities in Bourne End and Wooburn in Policy BE3?
Written Question from Councillor Stuart Wilson to Councillor Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning and Regeneration and Councillor Angela Macpherson, Cabinet Member for Health and Wellbeing “Today, Cabinet is reviewing the Joint Select Committee Review into Planning for Future Primary Healthcare in Buckinghamshire. An example of the past and present failings of the planning and primary care estates planning system are clearly illustrated in the Bourne End and Wooburn case study in the Appendix to the report. The Infrastructure Delivery Plan of the Wycombe Local Plan made it clear that the delivery of up to 800 new dwellings (now closer to 1100 dwellings with windfall infill and office conversions) created additional demand on transport, primary education and primary healthcare which requires new infrastructure and/or appropriate mitigation.
The Chairman welcomed Councillor Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning and Regeneration, and John Callaghan, Transport Strategy Funding Manager to the meeting.
Question from Councillor Stuart Wilson to Councillor Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning and Regeneration The Q2 Capital Budget Adjustments and Reprofiling report submitted to this Cabinet contains references in Appendix 1 to a re-profiling of £345,000 for environment-led opportunities and, in particular, ‘Spade Oak Lake and Little Marlow Visitor Facility business plans under development as original plans did not produce a net nil cost to the Council. Other options are being considered.’ Cabinet approved a programme of action to evaluate Little Marlow Lakes Country park in two phases last year, starting with a cross-function Officer group tasked with developing a commercial plan for the Council-owned land at Spade Oak Quarry. There has been no indication from this Officer group that this work has been substantially on progressed, beyond a workstream on the creation of a Suitable Alternative Natural Greenspace as mitigation for the impact of development in Bourne End on Burnham Beeches Special Area of Conservation.
The Chairman welcomed Cllr Rachael Matthews, Deputy Cabinet Member for Town Centre Regeneration, Cllr Clive Harriss, Cabinet Member for Culture & Leisure, Cllr Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning and Regeneration, Sophie Payne, Service Director, Culture, Sport & Leisure, Shabnam Ali, Head of Economic Growth, Matthew Broadbent, Senior Economic Development Officer, and Lucy Dowson, Tourism Development Manager for Visit Buckinghamshire, to the meeting.
The Committee received an update from Councillor Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning and Regeneration, Darran Eggleton, Head of Planning Policy and Compliance and John Cheston, Planning Policy Manager.
Question from Councillor Robin Stuchbury to Councillor Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning and Regeneration “Neighbourhood Plans Buckinghamshire Council has set up a Sub-Group which includes Area Planning Committee Chairmen, Cabinet members and senior officers looking at the Local Plan for Buckinghamshire. Other Parish and Town Councils are drafting their own neighbourhood plans such as Chesham and Buckingham and will be going out to consultation on their plans with their constituents in the future.
Question from Councillor Robin Stuchbury to Councillor Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning and Regeneration and Councillor Gareth Williams, Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Climate Change and Environment “ Could the Cabinet Members please provide an explanation about the arrangements in place to check on the adequacy of sewage infrastructure/capacity, and on any likely sewage discharge and other impacts on local rivers and streams (e.g. River Ouse, Buckingham), when granting planning permissions for developments?
The following responses to the Cabinet questions were noted:- Question from Councillor Michael Bracken to Councillor Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning and Regeneration “My question follows a period in which I have been seeking to advise and assist a number of residents impacted by construction and planning issues in a particular location. The underlying issues are complex and clearly difficult to address and include:- prolonged and delayed construction project including multiple changes of contractors and project managers;
Question from Councillor Robin Stuchbury to Councillor Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning and Regeneration and Councillor Steven Broadbent, Cabinet Member for Transport “As part of the Buckingham Transport Strategy and the A421 Corridor, Buckingham Town Council will be starting the process of developing and updating the neighbourhood plan in line with current development plans.
Question from Councillor Stuart Wilson to Councillor Peter Strachan, Cabinet Member for Planning and Regeneration “Application of Legacy Authority Planning Policies to Former Wycombe Area for Little Marlow Lakes Country Park and Burnham Beeches SAC SPD Natural England have given late consent to the Slate Meadow Reserved Matters planning application (21/07006/REM) to mitigate Burnham Beeches SAC recreational impacts through a payment due under the Burnham Beeches SAC Strategic Access Management and Monitoring Strategy Supplementary Planning Document (SAMMS), November 2020. This contravenes the application of the SAMMS policy which clearly states: “This Supplementary Planning Document solely applies to the south and east planning areas of Buckinghamshire Council. Whilst the 5.6km zone… takes in part of the western area of Buckinghamshire, the Wycombe Local Plan has its own mitigation strategy for growth in the western planning area. [Paragraph 1.2.1] It does not apply to the former Wycombe District Council area which now forms part of Buckinghamshire Council.
RESPONSE from Councillor Strachan (provided at the meeting by Councillor G Hall) a) Habitats Regulations Assessment needs to consider the most up to date evidence at each stage of decision making. Whilst the Burnham Beeches Supplementary Planning Document [BB SPD] expressly does not apply to the Wycombe (west) area, that does not prevent contributions towards the Burnham Beeches Strategic Access Management and Monitoring Strategy [BB SAMMS] being secured in relation to planning applications in the Wycombe (west) area.
Write to the Chief Executive(s) of those water companies with sewage treatment works discharging raw sewage into the Thames, Ouse, Wye and other waterways across Buckinghamshire to seek assurance that they will pursue a programme of capital investment that will “demonstrate improvements in the sewerage systems and progressive reductions in the harm caused by untreated sewage discharges” per the Lords’ Amendment. ” An amendment to the motion was proposed by Councillor Martin Tett , seconded by Councillor Peter Strachan, and accepted by the proposer and seconder of the original motion. The amendment was then put to the meeting as the substantive motion. The wording of the first two introductory paragraphs were unchanged .
Cabinet Member for Environment and Climate Change · Councillor Strachan referred to legacy issues with refuse collection in the South of the County. This was due to contractual performance (staff shortages) including a large increase in gardening waste. The Council were working closely with the contractor to improve performance.
It was moved by Cllr R Scott, seconded by Cllr P Strachan and
It was moved by Cllr R Scott, seconded by Cllr P Strachan and
Resolved That Councillor Strachan be elected Chairman of the Central Area Planning Committee for the municipal year 2020-21.
It was proposed by Councillor Strachan, seconded by Councillor Khan Resolved That Councillor Paternoster be appointed as Vice-Chairman of the Central Area Planning Committee for the municipal year 2020-21.
Councillor Peter Strachan proposed Councillor Steven Broadbent for the position of Chairman, this was seconded by Councillor Carl Jackson.
Councillor G Hall proposed the appointment of Councillor P Strachan as Vice-Chairman of the Shadow Authority, which was seconded by Councillor H Wallace.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Strachan attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Strachan's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Strachan was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Buckinghamshire has not published attendance for Councillor Strachan's meetings yet.
What Councillor Strachan declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Strachan in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Strachan sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Strachan yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.