Exclusion of the Public
It was proposed by the Chair, seconded by Cllr Bhinder and agreed to move to Part II of the meeting and to exclude the public.
Every time Dacorum's minutes name Councillor Bhinder, as the council published it.
It was proposed by the Chair, seconded by Cllr Bhinder and agreed to move to Part II of the meeting and to exclude the public.
Cllr Maddern and Cllr Bhinder advised they are both members of the Dacorum Health Action Group.
Councillor Douris substituted for Councillor Bhinder.
Cllr Bhinder queried what caused the pharmacy fire.
Cllr Bhinder noted that they are now looking at new avenues. It was suggested that the lack of attendance should be raised with Trust management. The Chair queried how many times West Herts Hospital Trust have declined to attend meetings.
Cllr Bhinder suggested that they have now declined to attend 3-4 times, adding that it is not uncommon for them to not reply and they last attended over a year ago.
Cllr Bhinder queried where the vision is available to view. EGlatter stated that it should be available via their website.
Cllr Bhinder requested clarification regarding the 11,000 homes and it was confirmed that the 5,000 homes referred to by EGlatter was included in this. JDoe confirmed that this is an estimated figure at present and may be refined further.
Cllr Bhinder responded that these concerns have been raised repeatedly and that representatives are no longer attending meetings. The Chair asked if there is a joint strategic needs assessment around health at a local level. JDoe confirmed that this would be checked.
It was proposed by Cllr Bhinder and seconded by Cllr Link to move to Part II of the meeting and to exclude the public.
Cllr Adeleke for Cllr Anderson for Cllr Banks for Cllr Barratt for Cllr Barry-Mears for Cllr Bassadone for Cllr Beauchamp for Cllr Bhinder for Cllr Birnie abstain Cllr Chapman for Cllr Claughton for Cllr Douris for Cllr Durrant for Cllr Elliot for Cllr England for Cllr Foster for Cllr Freedman for Cllr Griffiths for Cllr Harden for Cllr Hearn for Cllr Hobson for Cllr Hollinghurst abstain Cllr Imarni for Cllr Johnson for Cllr Link for Cllr Maddern for Cllr Peter for Cllr Pringle for Cllr Ransley for Cllr Riddick for Cllr Rogers for Cllr Silwal for Cllr Sinha for Cllr Stevens for Cllr Su Mahmood for Cllr Sutton for Cllr Symington for Cllr Taylor for Cllr Timmis for Cllr Tindall for Cllr Townsend for Cllr Wilkie for Cllr Williams for
Cllr Bhinder agreed that they should quantify officer time, noting that this could also help with comparing outsourcing training.
Cllr Bhinder noted that members need to be contactable and approachable and that this also needs to be considered as part of the risk assessment.
Cllr Bhinder noted that Licensing and DMC courses should all be held in-person.
Cllr Bhinder commented on the briefing on ICT and meetings, noting that this should be a priority.
Cllr Bhinder stated that how the council functions and the hierarchy in place would also be important to cover.
Cllr Bhinder asked if the protocols could be bullet-pointed with easy access to members. The Chair advised that protocols regarding development and management meetings is already set out, though information could also be included in the mandatory constitution. The Chair commented that they could introduce an FAQ for members, though the information is already available.
Cllr Bhinder noted his agreement and stated that they require reasoning behind the action.
Before proceeding with the presentation, Cllr Bhinder noted Cllr Beauchamp's statement.
Cllr Bhinder checked that all Committee members had received [name removed] ' statement on vaccine availability.
Cllr Bhinder agreed with Cllr Allen's comments in regard to [name removed] ' response.
Cllr Bhinder suggested that the comments be fed back to [name removed] regarding Covid vaccine distribution in Dacorum .
Cllr Bhinder noted the seriousness of the situation regarding the ambulance service
Cllr Bhinder confirmed that they would focus on health provision in Dacorum over the coming meetings.
Cllr Bhinder noted the rise in Covid cases and suggested that a Covid update be added to the next meeting's agenda.
There being no further business, Cllr Bhinder closed the meeting at 8:27pm.
Cllr Bhinder asked if contacts would be across the board. CONeil commented that they would also need to ensure they have the resource to keep the contact list up to date and that they would also work with heads of service to identify the best point of contact for members and how they would let them know if this changes or that person is away.
Cllr Bhinder commented on external contacts and asked how this would be managed. CONeil stated that this would have to be considered further and would reach out to committee chairs on what they require.
Cllr Bhinder commented on portfolio holder training and asked that this be considered .
Cllr Bhinder stated that there is already training for Chairs and that being a portfolio holder is a big responsibility.
Cllr Bhinder noted an incident, which he would report at the next meeting. There were no other issues reported
Cllr Bhinder upheld Cllr Maddern’s request for details.
Cllr Bhinder was pleased to hear the team effort.
Cllr Bhinder noted that Christine Allen was not present at the meeting and clarified that the comments being made were a perspective of the letter. It was noted that LHalfpenny was still on the call, who commented she would not be arguing the point and was seeing the points for the first time. PAylett confirmed that the information could be made available to LHalfpenny if required.
Cllr Bhinder noted that Cllr Guest wasn’t present to give the report. MSells noted that the report was attached to the agenda and that any questions could be submitted after the meeting.
Cllr Bhinder noted a previous suggestion from Cllr Maddern that the committee meet more regularly as it was felt that every 3 months was not sufficient.
Cllr Bhinder confirmed that officers had looked into holding meetings every 2 months but that this was unsuccessful due to constraints such as school holidays and suggested that a steering group instead be set up to meet on an ad hoc basis to address individual items and ensure the right items are being brought to the committee. MSells added that a number of officers are interested in the meeting and that the steering group would be an opportunity for offices to provide information on other items in the borough.
Cllr Bhinder added that it would also be an opportunity to discuss items that would otherwise be discussed as part of the work programme agenda point.
Cllr Bhinder asked that this be left with him as an action to look into. SDay requested a copy of the meeting.
Cllr Bhinder noted the request.
Cllr Bhinder agreed, noting that they could look at the letter and any potential response.
Cllr Bhinder requested that this be added as an action point for the next meeting. LHalfpenny commented that if they are asked to submit anything to the Health Secretary then they would be prepared to share this and that this may be in the public domain ahead of the next meeting. LHalfpenny confirmed that she would inform MSells if anything was available ahead of the next committee meeting.
It was proposed by Councillor Bhinder and seconded by Councillor Bassadone to move to Part II of the meeting and to exclude the public.
It was proposed by Councillor Bassadone and seconded by Councillor Bhinder to move to Part II of the meeting and to exclude the public.
Councillor Bhinder referred to page 25 relating to the strike system. He sought clarification on the rationale of the system as he felt two years wasn’t a particularly long period of time. P Wortley explained that two years was considered a reasonable amount of time as drivers had to change their licences every three years.
Councillor Bhinder questioned whether that meant the decision was actually made by the Local Authority rather than a statutory decision.
Cllr Bhinder thought this was a positive idea based on the number of IT questions other members ask him.
Cllr Bhinder asked that licensing be added to this training as well.
Cllr Bhinder does not read it.
Cllr Bhinder was keen that people could not complete the course until they had filled in the feedback.
Cllr Bhinder asked that the cost of DORIS as a system is considered as clearly it is not functioning as it should. LF and MK will liaise with HR about the system and the issues the members have had and look at future dates for members so they can be added to DORIS with 2 dates for each training for the members to book in advance.
Councillor Bhinder referred to page 15 regarding enforcement options. He queried how the Enforcement Officers managed the difference between a licensee contravening an agreement with DBC and the law.
Councillor Bhinder drew the committee’s attention to the list under 4.1 as he felt it was very useful and interesting. He then asked why there was such a long gap (21 days) between the decision notice being issued and the revoking of a licence.
It was proposed by Councillor Hearn and seconded by Councillor Bhinder to move to Part II of the meeting and to exclude the public.
· Councillor Beauchamp to replace Councillor Bhinder on the Hertfordshire Health Scrutiny Committee.
Cllr Bhinder said there could be an issue with recording an external company, officer may wish to query. As he recalled the last licensing sessions were very long with lots of questions being asked, he feels it would be more practical to move it to a weekend or split it so as not to create information overload.
Cllr Bhinder said although he enjoys the licencing committee it is hard going and feels that splitting it would be a better way.
Cllr Bhinder agreed with Cllr Freeman, he said he spoke to IT months ago and was given the option of either in-ear or headphones to trial and to use. He chose in-ear was he wanted something discreet and he thought it was fantastic as it not only had the mute function but also prevented feedback issues.
Cllr Bhinder said he had wanted to explore the idea of Members being trained on more awareness of the Environment and particularly issues covered under the ‘Clean Neighbourhood and Environmental Act 2003’.
Action: K Mogan said that some instructions had been created on how to book Microsoft Teams meetings and that she could send these out to Councillor Bhinder.
Councillor Bhinder asked if officers had any feedback on Doris as they have been using it for some time. He also asked if Doris is a pre-built software that DBC has bought, he understands were not able to make changes, he would like to find out how other councils are getting on.
Councillor Bhinder asked if we could look at what the issues were to avoid them going forward.
Councillor Bhinder asked if they have to take mandatory training every year, Councillor Griffiths advised that it’s once in the 4 year term.
Councillor Bhinder was substituting on his behalf.
Councillor Bhinder chaired the meeting in absence of Councillor Guest.
Councillor Bhinder said he had concerns that there are still some people who are not wearing masks in shops and supermarkets and when it is mentioned to the staff, they say they cannot enforce it.
Councillor Bhinder said he would circulate the update notes to the committee.
Councillor Bhinder said he took this on board and the Health committee is cross party and we are all in agreement.
Councillor Bhinder said that he received a request for Microsoft Teams training.
Councillor Bhinder suggested training for Members on how to book Microsoft Teams meetings.
Councillor Bhinder added that there was the potential of being overwhelmed with information.
Councillor Bhinder added that some sessions required more interactivity.
Councillor Bhinder said that providing virtual training could be a challenge.
Councillor Bhinder said that he had acquired a headset from Gary Osler in IT.
Councillor Bhinder is currently working with The Hospital Group regarding some marketing material and will therefore withdraw from item 7.
Councillor Bhinder has attended 3 meetings so far and will ensure the minutes of the County Council Health Scrutiny Meetings are circulated to the Group.
Councillor Bhinder arrived late to the meeting therefore will not take part in item 7.
Councillor Bhinder said that it was important to provide regular training for those areas where legislation was constantly changing.
Councillor Bhinder said that it would be useful for this session to include raising awareness of abuse and bullying online.
Councillor Bhinder said that offering two sessions was a good idea as some training like the Licensing training provided a heavy amount of information in a short space of time. He suggested that Social Media training could give the Councillors’ perspective as well as the perspective of residents using Social Media.
Councillor Bhinder said that it was important to consider the resources of managing this.
Councillor Bhinder said that demographics needed to be looked at carefully.
Action: Councillor Bhinder asked that alternate rows were shaded on the Attendance Totals spreadsheet so that it was easier to read.
It was proposed by Councillor Bhinder and seconded by Councillor Bassadone to move to Part II of the meeting and to exclude the public.
Councillor Bhinder said that he had completed two GDPR sessions externally but that both of these had been delivered by the Council’s GDPR Officer. He added that it was understandable that legislation will change and that Councillors will need to be up to date but that training needed to be specific to Councillors.
Councillor Bhinder said that Licensing and Planning has legislation changes and that they could be constantly changing. He suggested refresher courses for these changes and updates.
Councillor Bhinder stated that Councillors were on Committees for these things and therefore had to be confident in what they were doing.
Councillor Bhinder said that due to changes in legislation, it was important for Councillors to remain up to date.
Councillor Bhinder said that with the current paper forms, not everyone is aware of them at Member Development sessions. He added that it was important for the objectives to be clear and defined at the start of a session.
Councillor Bhinder said that he may be late for the next meeting.
Councillor Bhinder asked if D Evans could elaborate on the collaboration proposal.
Councillor Bhinder said it was an impressive set up and asked for more examples of what these PCN’s deliver for customers and if ... view the full minutes text for item 15.
Councillor Guest informed the committee that Councillor Bhinder was DBC’s nominated representative on this committee.
Councillor Bhinder said he would meet with Councillor Maddern and E Glatter prior to this meeting to form a plan.
Appointment of Councillor Alex Bhinder as Dacorum’s Representative on the Hertfordshire Health Scrutiny Committee.
Councillor Bhinder thinks in principle this is a very good idea but would like to ensure clients are made aware that even though the service will be chargeable it will not guarantee the licence is granted, he would also like to see this information online to provide further clarification.
Councillor Bhinder thinks offering this service to applicants outside the borough would be a mistake at this point until the service is more established, the other Committee Members agree RECOMMENDATIONS The following recommendations were agreed by the Licensing and Health and Safety Enforcement Committee:
Councillor Bhinder is concerned that the rise in cost is substantial with some sites being charged almost double the fee from the previous year.
Councillor Silwal proposed support for this nomination which was seconded by Councillor Bhinder.
Councillor Bhinder said that it was important to make members aware of the cost of training and the importance of attending sessions.
Councillor Bhinder agreed with Councillor Anderson.
Councillor Bhinder continued that he understood the importance of attending regular training sessions where legislation was changing all the time and gave the example of Licensing training.
Councillor Bhinder noted that the Chairing Skills Training was similar as, generally, legislation did not change.
Councillor Bhinder asked if it would be possible to create separate reports of attendance for ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Councillor Bhinder agreed with Councillor Freedman and noted that the volume of information could be overwhelming for a new councillor.
Councillor Bhinder raised technological issues with connecting to the WiFi at The Forum.
Councillor Guest Councillor Hollinghurst Eddie Glatter Kevin Minier Substitutes Councillor Bhinder will be Chairing the meeting Councillor Wyatt-Lowe Councillor Freeman
Councillor Bhinder would like it made clearer in future that the 20M investment is made up of these land sales as well as he feels it is misleading not to mention this.
5f - 4/03226/18/FUL DEMOLITION OF EXISTING RESIDENTIAL DWELLING AND CONSTRUCTION OF 4 X 2-BED FLATS AND ANCILLARY WORKS LAVENDER COTTAGE, REDBOURN ROAD, HEMEL HEMPSTEAD, HP2 7BA Rachel Marber introduced the report to members stating that Officer’s recommendations were to REFUSE the application and said it had been referred to committee because it was called in by Cllr Bhinder on grounds of overdevelopment.
Cllr Bhinder will be joining Licencing.
N Gibbs introduced the item and said it had been referred to committee due to it being called in by Councillor Bhinder.
In his role as ward councillor, Councillor Bhinder spoke in objection to the application.
N Gibbs introduced the item and said it had been referred to the committee as it had been called in by Councillor Bhinder.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Bhinder attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Bhinder's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Bhinder was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 0 of 1 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Bhinder declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Bhinder in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Bhinder sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Nov 2022 | 2 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Licensing and Health and Safety Enforcement Committee | Vice-Chairman | May 2022 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.