Apologies for absence
Councillor Anderson substituted for Councillor Walker and Councillor Silwal substituted for Councillor Mitchell.
Every time Dacorum's minutes name Councillor Silwal, as the council published it.
Councillor Anderson substituted for Councillor Walker and Councillor Silwal substituted for Councillor Mitchell.
Cllr Mitchell advised that Cllr Greenfield will replace Cllr Silwal on the Finance & Resources Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
Councillor Silwal substituted on behalf of Councillor Mitchell and Councillor Anderson substituted on behalf of Councillor Riddick.
Cllr Goverdhan Silwal, Ward Councillor for Grovehill has joined the Labour Party Cllr Ron Tindall, Ward Councillor for Adeyfield West is now an Independent councillor In addition, following their announcement at the Council meeting on 25 th September 2024, the following Councillors have resigned from the Liberal Democrat party and will each stand as an Independent councillor representing their elected wards;
Councillor Silwal substituted for Councillor Hannell.
The Chief Executive - On 26th March I received notification that Councillor Goverdhan Silwal left the Conservative Party and will continue as an Independent Councillor.
Cllr Williams advised Cllr Walker was to replace Cllr Silwal on The Development Management Committee.
Councillor A Williams substituted for Councillor Silwal
5 A Cllr Guest arrive at 19:16 C B Cllr Silwal left the meeting at 20:53 D
It was proposed by Councillor Durrant and seconded by Councillor Silwal to DELEGATED with a view to APPROVAL.
It was proposed by Councillor Guest and seconded by Councillor Silwal to DELEGATED with a view to APPROVAL.
Before moving on to the next item the Chairman went through the previous minutes, highlighting that he had asked five questions, Councillor Silwal had asked two questions and Councillor Townsend had asked twenty questions. He said he would appreciate members streamlining their questions as the discussions were very complex and some of the queries could have been put to the officers when the agenda had been published. He requested that any intricate questions should be put to officers’ prior to the meeting to give them time to provide a comprehensive response.
Cllr Adeleke for Cllr Anderson for Cllr Banks for Cllr Barratt for Cllr Barry-Mears for Cllr Bassadone for Cllr Beauchamp for Cllr Bhinder for Cllr Birnie abstain Cllr Chapman for Cllr Claughton for Cllr Douris for Cllr Durrant for Cllr Elliot for Cllr England for Cllr Foster for Cllr Freedman for Cllr Griffiths for Cllr Harden for Cllr Hearn for Cllr Hobson for Cllr Hollinghurst abstain Cllr Imarni for Cllr Johnson for Cllr Link for Cllr Maddern for Cllr Peter for Cllr Pringle for Cllr Ransley for Cllr Riddick for Cllr Rogers for Cllr Silwal for Cllr Sinha for Cllr Stevens for Cllr Su Mahmood for Cllr Sutton for Cllr Symington for Cllr Taylor for Cllr Timmis for Cllr Tindall for Cllr Townsend for Cllr Wilkie for Cllr Williams for
Councillor Silwal queried the amber and red ratings. N Howcutt stated that part of the risk strategy outlines a matrix system for risks and anything that scores over 9 as an actual risk or over 4 as likely or consequence will be regarded as red, with amber being any item that scores over 2 or 3. The first red risk is on the failure to secure sufficient investment in essential infrastructure, which requires £1bn of investment, and is therefore particularly high risk as this relies on what funding is in place.
Councillor Silwal commented on borrowing and asked if this amount could be justified. F Jump advised that borrowing for local authorities is part of the normal course of events with the majority of forecasted borrowing in relation to the housing revenue account and investment into housing stock. This work can be financed in a number of ways, including rental income and selling off existing assets, with borrowing being the final option.
Councillor Silwal said he asked a couple of questions at the last meeting but they hadn’t been included in the minutes.
She advised she would email Councillor Silwal to confirm any changes. Action.
Councillor Silwal asked if reasonable assurances from previous years were left or continued to be worked on. P Lazenby advised a ll of the assurances have recommendations and those are profiled on the root cause indicator section which is included in the committee reports. There are regular follow up’s that get reported ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Cllr Silwal commented on item 2.5 of the report and the 66 accidents reported, asking if these were all of the accidents or incidents and if assessments were up to date. RLeBrun confirmed the risk assessment has been checked to ensure it is fit for purpose and Corporate Health and Safety also received a copy of the investigation report to ensure lessons are learned and documents are updated as required. It was confirmed that this was done on all internal accidents and incidents reported.
Cllr Silwal, Cllr Griffiths and Cllr Douris read it.
Cllr Silwal added that he had issues accessing DORIS and he was encouraged to pick this up with IT.
Cllr Silwal referred to 2/3 being the food premises rating and commented it was low in comparison to 4/5 and asked why that was.
Cllr Silwal referred to paragraph 3.4 where the local authority could issue a fixed penalty of £200 instead of prosecuting and asked if that was before ... view the full minutes text for item 10.
Cllr Silwal asked about the Asset Management Plan which covers five years but MD talked about this being a long term plan for 25 years, will the Asset Management Plan be extended or is it a different plan? MD replied that their Asset Management Plan is what they are going to deliver over the next five years, but the long term plan for 25 year plan for water, resources and drainage matters will be split up into five year chunks so there will be five chunks that feed into that more strategic plan.
Cllr Silwal asked CT which Clean Safe and Green projects have been put on hold due to staff levels CT replied that the Splash Park hasn’t opened yet and the educational awareness events around the clothes swaps and compost give away were postponed.
Section 9 of the LGA Code of Conduct (Interests) – Cllr Silwal asks – “Does it apply if the land is in a foreign country?” Mark Brookes replies – “No it relates to land in the borough” Cllr Anderson asks – “This only relates to our roles as Councillors and therefore can we participate as private citizens?” Mark Brookes replies – “Yes, if does not affect your role as a Councillor” Section 10 of the LGA Code of Conduct (Gifts and Hospitality) – Mark Brookes notes a Key point is the increase from £25 to £50 value. Members ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Cllr Silwal asked what training needs to be undertaken to sit on DMC.
Cllr Silwal referred to page 24 point 4.2 and maintenance costs. He asked if the total should be 280k. He asked how long the maintenance costs would take for the vehicles.
Cllr Silwal referred to item 5.3 and the Green Community Grant scheme where applications could be made for up to £2,000 out of a total pot of £10,000 and asked whether, if there were more demand , that would be added to the total pot.
Cllr Silwal said double is fine, but demand may go up MGaynor hoped that it would.
Cllr Birnie asked if this concerned the Green Home Grant vouchers Cllr Silwal advised that it did not.
Cllr Silwal advised that this was Cllr Hobson Cllr Hobson complained that she had raised this several times. She had originally raised it in response to residents writing to her about their concerns over where their plastic goes. At the time when they received training for their role as committee members, one of the sessions included the right that they have to hold an enquiry to which they can invite people.
Cllr Silwal referred to the administration costs in 2018-19 of £105k and those in 2019-20 of £140k, asking;
Cllr Silwal asked about p4.1 the £564k pressure against budget and initially there were 20 staff in self-isolation and queried if there were any staff in self-isolation now. C Thorpe advised that we have had one go into self-isolation but everyone else at the Depot is back in work. Also C Thorpe mentioned that E Walker confirmed there were 8 in total across the organisation.
Action: C Thorpe Cllr Silwal mentioned the two indicators that were red, WR01 and WR03, where the collection is 214 and target is 120 but it’s still in the red. C Thorpe advised the figures were for the quarter, so it’s actually target 750 and we went over that and the collection total for everything we do was 1,187. We have about 614,000 collections every month so the missed number is fairly miniscule and is down to the number of temporary staff we’ve been using, plus the number of parked vehicles on the roads where, as a result, we’re unable to get into the street and the assisted collections that have been missed.
Cllr Silwal queried the food and hygiene inspections from 23 March to 01 September and asked if we received any complaints. E Walker confirmed that we did deal with complaints during that period and all of those complaints are followed up routinely within our three day response time.
Councillor Silwal advised he is booked on to a safeguarding course through his school governor duties, will this be recognised as completing the mandatory training in his councillor duties. K Mogan advised that mandatory training has to be provided by the council to be compliant.
Councillor Anderson substituted on behalf of Councillor Guest and Councillor Silwal substituted on behalf of Councillor Johnson.
Councillor Silwal said he was concerned about children returning to school and asked if there were any plans to test children in schools.
Cllr Silwal mentioned that since 2006 there are 546 live cases, but only 53 live cases where formal action has been taken. P Stanley advised that we use a range of tools at our disposal and dealing with them formally with a Notice is not always appropriate. Firstly it may not be a breach and if it is a breach it may not be harmful and it wouldn’t be expedient to take action.
Cllr Silwal asked why there was still a live case from 2006. P Stanley confirmed there are about 8 or so approaching 10 years old. If we have served an Enforcement Notice, unfortunately after 10 years it’s too late to take action.
Cllr Silwal asked about point 4.2 car ownership levels. A Robinson confirmed that point 4.2 was seeking to illustrate that there hasn’t been much of an increase in ownership levels between those two periods and the evidence base is largely derived from the Census between 2001 and 2011. We do rely on evidence that is collected at a national level and that’s what has informed in part ... view the full minutes text for item 111.
Cllr Silwal asked if we could add tree planting to the priorities for 20/21. N Polden advised that he was aware that we were planting trees under climate change policies, but this was neither a proven or unproven solution for air quality and would continue to be looked at through climate change.
Cllr Silwal referred to capital programme commenting that there is reference to five projects on pg.15 but he can only find four projects listed and so asked; what was the fifth project?
Cllr Silwal referred to there didn’t appear to be a clearly defined structure in place for overall plan and individual projects.
Councillor Silwal asked for the details of the Equality, Diversity and Inclusion Training.
Cllr Silwal asked a question regarding the replacement of the waste fleet, has the rolling programme completed and are the vehicles now being utilised?
Cllr Birnie suggested that a written reply to this question would be acceptable and FJ said that she would send an email out to Cllr Silwal, who was happy with this outcome. ** Action point FJ Cllr Birnie asked a question regarding page 4 item 3.4 about a retention of £491,000 not finalised and he asked if it was finalised now?
Cllr Silwal commented that the report refers to work being carried out in 2020 and asked; will you be able to do that work while this pandemic is ongoing? ARobinson responded that a lot of work can be carried out remotely from home so work can continue. The only area that may be impacted will be public consultation and that will be programmed in to fit around current constraints of COVID-19 pandemic.
Cllr Silwal asked; with regard communal bin areas, is there any plan to disinfect? Also is there enough PPE for Clean Safe & Green staff?
Cllr Silwal asked a question about Independent Members Allowances.
Cllr Silwal asked how many enterprises were involved.
Cllr Silwal asked how many cases of Hand Arm Vibration (HAV) there were.
Cllr Silwal said that in Grovehill they receive 25% because they have a neighbourhood plan.
Ø Appointment of Councillor Rosie Sutton to the Development Management Committee Ø Appointment of Councillor Margaret Griffiths to the Member Development Steering Group (to replace Councillor Rosie Sutton) Ø Appointment of Councillor Goverdhan Silwal to the Standards Committee (to replace Councillor Rosie Sutton) Appointment of Councillor Claire Hobson to the Development Management Committee
Councillor Silwal proposed support for this nomination which was seconded by Councillor Bhinder.
Councillor Silwal noted that it may be useful to have ICT training.
Resolved - Cllr Silwal will be leaving the Finance committee and joining Member Development and SPAE.
Cllr Silwal asked what the blue colour code was.
Cllr Silwal asked if future projects should be included. MB advised this would be reported in the next quarter information.
Cllr Silwal asked if it was necessary to installed carbon mono oxide detector, fire alarm and fire extinguisher, what’s your plan?
Cllr Silwal commented on ( pg 30 of the Agenda pack); and asked why it was taking so long to decide the Housing Benefit Claim; he asked if it is due to the new Universal Credit system. C Baker responded saying that it was disappointing as DBC had reduced the target down to 20 days from 22 or 23 days in previous years. He said that Performance was around 30 days; He said the key problem, similar to Building Control, was a lot of gaps in staffing at present and difficulties in filling those vacancies.
Cllr Silwal asked if problems related to Universal Credit were caused by staffing issues. C Baker said Universal Credit was an odd situation. He said that DBC were halfway through rolling out this new process, and there were single people who were out of work at the moment that needed to claim Universal Credit but, he said, virtually everybody else who needs help with their housing costs still need to claim Housing Benefit.
Cllr Silwal asked if we are notifying people of the removal of register.
Councillor Silwal referred to paragraph 3.10 ( pg 6 of 17 of the report), and asked for further clarification regarding the pressures of approximately £120k in relation to Third parties. B Hosier said that this related to a large invoice that had submitted to Hertfordshire County Council (HCC) in respect of the library and registry office;
Councillor Silwal referred to pg 52 of the agenda pack, specifically the red Inherent Risk Score of ‘16’; he asked why this was so high? J Doyle said that the red was the impact if something were to go wrong with the election process. He said that in this case, the financial penalties would be substantial, as well as significant reputational damage, if a mistake in the election process were occur.
Cllr M Griffith arrived at 19:50 Cllr Silwal referred to 3.1, over budget and asked if it was on top off.
Councillor Silwal asked about the overspend at the Forum and was informed that it involved Herts County Council expenses. The cost was to fit out the library and the HCC share of the cost has since been received.
Cllr Silwal emailed a question to Richard Baker.
Councillor Silwal referred to the Employees - £217k over budget on page 10 of the report and asked the officer to clarify this.
Councillor Silwal asked for clarification on the term “heritage”.
Councillor Silwal asked the officer if the Council would be able to sell allotments for profit.
Councillor Silwal asked for an explanation of the terms ‘political fallout’ and ‘reputational damage’ in relation to Strategic Risk C3 – Failure to use the Council’s commitment to invest £30m across the Borough.
Councillor Silwal asked if the Key Amnesty had impacted on sub letting and was informed that this internal initiative has resulted in keys being handed back Councillor W Wyatt-Lowe raised the issue of how DBC might categorise the recording of complaints from different sets of tenants – e.g. private householders complaints about Council tenants. EB advised that tenant complaints are recorded and we look at themes;
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Silwal attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Nov 2022 | Council | Change to committee dates | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Silwal was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 0 of 1 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Silwal declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Silwal in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Silwal sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Nov 2022 | 2 | 16 Dec 2026 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.