Appointment of Dover Joint Transportation Advisory Board Chairman for 2026/27
It was agreed that Councillor E A Biggs be appointed as Chairman of the Dover Joint Transportation Advisory Board for 2026/27.
Every time Dover's minutes name Councillor Biggs, as the council published it.
It was agreed that Councillor E A Biggs be appointed as Chairman of the Dover Joint Transportation Advisory Board for 2026/27.
It was proposed by Councillor K Mills, duly seconded by Councillor E A Biggs, that Councillor S H Beer be elected Chairman of Dover District Council for the ensuring municipal year.
It was moved by Councillor E A Biggs, duly seconded by Councillor D G Cronk, and
It was agreed that Councillor E A Biggs be appointed as Vice-Chairman of the Dover Joint Transportation Advisory Board for 2025/26.
Councillor E A Biggs voiced concerns about Members questioning the results of the second road safety audit and disputing the advice of the statutory consultee. The TL stressed that the views of statutory consultees should be given significant weight, albeit he was aware that some Members had reservations about them. He emphasised that the scheme had been scrutinised by a number of experts who had unanimously concluded that it was a safe crossing point.
Councillor Biggs queried whether Class Q permission was relevant in this case. In response, the TL advised that Class Q applied to the conversion of agricultural buildings and there had been some debate as to whether the building had been in agricultural or an alternative use. There were restrictions under Class Q relating to the amount of curtilage that could be added and elements of this application meant that the applicant could not apply for Class Q.
Councillor E A Biggs expressed disappointment at the loss of the billiards room which was a piece of local history. Whilst a condition required it to be photographed, he requested that this be actively monitored. He hoped that the care home would be open to NHS patients and affordable for local people.
In response to Councillor Biggs, he confirmed that if the applicant wished to reinstate the removed works in future, a separate application and planning permission would be required.
Councillor E A Biggs declared an Other Significant Interest in Agenda Item 7 (Appointment of Professional Consultants for Proposed Redevelopment of Albany Place Car Park, Dover for Affordable Housing) by reason that he was the Chairman of Municipal Charities of Dover, an outside body to which he had been appointed by the Council, which had an interest in acquiring some of the car park land.
Councillor E A Biggs requested that the information aired at the meeting should be passed on to Councillor Baker.
Councillor J S Back Councillor R M Knight Councillor T J Bartlett Councillor J P Loffman Councillor M Bates Councillor K Mills Councillor D G Beaney Councillor M W Moorhouse Councillor S H Beer Councillor D P Murphy Councillor E A Biggs Councillor M J Nee Councillor P M Brivio ... view the full minutes text for item 33.
It was moved by Councillor E A Biggs, duly seconded by Councillor J S Back, and (a) That the Inspectors’ Final Report into the examination of the Dover District Local Plan be noted (Appendix 1).
Councillor E A Biggs flagged up the importance of the document as a means of obtaining funding from central government to address the impact of international haulage traffic on the district’s roads. Councillor O C de R Richardson commended the aspirations of the Plan and sought further information on the number and location of consultation events.
Responding to comments made by Councillor T A Bond, Councillor E A Biggs expressed disappointment at his negative attitude towards the consultation and encouraged him and others to take part. The TSM stressed that KCC did not have the means to fund the majority of these schemes. Whilst small schemes could sometimes be funded ... view the full minutes text for item 129.
In response to Councillor E A Biggs (Mayor of Dover), [name removed] advised that the colour palette for windows, doors, walls, etc had been kept simple and would need to be signed off with the Council’s Planning team. In addition, there were regulations that required the use of certain colours for people with impaired sight. She reassured Members that the team was spending the Council’s money wisely, seeking to achieve a high-quality finish whilst keeping costs down.
In response to Councillor Biggs, the Project Manager advised that a testing and evaluation report on ground conditions had been received that day. She clarified that ground conditions would have an impact on the piling contractor.
Councillor E A Biggs raised the following points:
Councillor E A Biggs asked how the proposal could be reconciled with its location within an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB). He was very familiar with the road and had concerns about vehicles speeding down there, and adding more houses could make for a hazardous situation. Whilst affordable homes were included in the outline application, he questioned what would happen if a viability assessment ruled them out at a later date .
Councillor Biggs sought clarity on the weight that should be attached to the new proposal when compared to the application that already had planning permission. The Planning Officer advised that page 149 of the report summarised the position in respect of the planning balance. The extant planning permission provided a fallback position which carried significant weight.
Cllr Kevin Mills Industrial Communities Alliance Cllr Daniel Parks JAC Kent Downs AONB Cllr Pam Brivio Partnership Kent & Medway Economic Cllr Cllr Kevin Mills Partnership Board Kent & Medway Police Cllr Charlotte Zosseder & Crime Panel Kent Resource Partnership Cllr Edward Biggs Members’ Board Local Government Association – Cllr Kevin Mills General Assembly Local Government Association Cllr Edward Biggs Coastal Special Interest Group Manston Skills and Employment Cllr Pam Brivio Board Manston Sustainability Advisory Cllr Sue Beer Board Municipal Charities of Dover Cllr Edward Biggs (4 Years) Appointment deferred Appointment deferred River Dour Partnership Cllr Pam Brivio River Stour (Kent) Internal Cllr Daniel Parks Drainage Board Appointment deferred Sandwich & Pegwell Bay Appointment deferred National Nature Reserve Steering Group South-East England Councils Cllr Kevin Mills (sub: J Pout) (b) That Cabinet requests the Leader of the Council to nominate an alternative Members to substitute at meetings on a
It was agreed that Councillor E A Biggs be appointed as Chairman of the Dover Joint Transportation Advisory Board for 2024/25.
In response to Councillor E A Biggs, the RDM explained that Atkins Realis had been managing the project before the PCSA but would now act as the Council’s employer’s agent and protect its interests as Jenners assumed responsibility for the detailed design of the project. The team was working with Jenners on the potential social value gains of the project, including the use of local supply chains and apprenticeships. He added that the team intended to work with Jenners on maximising construction opportunities that would benefit the town such as improving the public realm, etc.
Councillor Biggs queried how flexible the internal spaces would be and what facilities there were to clean and maintain rooflights and glazed areas. [name removed] acknowledged that the building’s location by a main road and the coast was challenging. The team had avoided the use of certain materials to reflect Dover’s environment, and brick samples had been tested for durability, for example.
Councillor Biggs mentioned the construction management plan, specifically the traffic congestion issues that gridlocked the town during the summer and how each could affect the other. The RDM advised that the contractors’ compound would be situated at Stembrook Place, 150 metres away from the site so there should be no problems with deliverability. In relation to the A20, there would be a temporary closure of Mill Lane and the main deliveries would come straight off the A20.
Councillor E A Biggs stressed that HMOs were a necessary form of accommodation in Dover. Whilst he understood people’s concerns, the management plan was key and, if adhered to, should prevent problems occurring. Terraced houses were not built for modern needs so parking would always be a problem in areas like Tower Hamlets.
Councillor Biggs pointed to the aerial view which demonstrated that the applicant was proposing a very large development that was out of context with anything nearby. It was clear that the development would be completely dominant due to the elevated level of the site. It was the Committee’s role to assess whether proposals were in keeping and this one was clearly not appropriate.
In response to Councillor E A Biggs who queried the significance of the fence and gates, the Planning Consultant clarified that it was the occupation of the land that had triggered enforcement action, adding that fences up to two metres high could be erected without permission in any case. That being said, there was a visual impact as the fence and gates could be seen from the street scene. There was nothing to stop the applicant from applying in three years’ time (as he was entitled to do), at which point his children’s educational needs would continue being a relevant factor.
Councillor Biggs added that it seemed reasonable to grant a temporary permission for this type of application which lent itself to this approach, unlike other applications where the erection of buildings was involved.
Councillor Biggs expressed disappointment that part of the school grounds was being sold off for a residential scheme. The clearance of the site before a planning application had been submitted also troubled him. These spaces needed to be protected and he questioned whether a secondary ecological appraisal had been carried out.
Councillor E A Biggs queried whether there were any other developments proposed in the surrounding area and, if so, whether Members should take those into account when determining this application. He also queried whether approving the application would set a precedent for further development in the park. Finally, he sought advice on how the Committee could ensure that the park was looked after and not allowed to become neglected.
Councillor Biggs expressed disappointment at the design of the hotel building and asked whether a design review had been undertaken. Noting that design was a subjective matter, the Planning Consultant explained that the applicant had sought to follow the form and general proportions of the existing visitor centre. Because it was important to achieve a building of quality in this location, Officers had engaged quite rigorously with the applicant to ensure that that was achieved.
Councillor E A Biggs raised the following matters:
It was proposed by Councillor J P Loffman and duly seconded that Councillor E A Biggs be elected chairman. On being put to the vote the motion was CARRIED.
Councillor E A Biggs commented that the site appeared to be a difficult one to develop which meant there were significant issues for Members to grasp. In his view there was currently too much uncertainty surrounding the development, and he believed that some of the issues needed to be resolved before outline permission was granted.
Councillor E A Biggs spoke in favour of the proposal, citing the sympathetic extension layouts, lower ridge height and setting back from the road.
In response to Councillor Biggs, [name removed] stated that, although not familiar with the exact details, he believed the mitigation scheme had evolved over time and would involve part signalisation of the roundabout plus widening and circulatory improvements. The Chairman reminded the Committee that it was only looking at access onto Archers Court Road, and discussions about Whitfield roundabout were not relevant. There was no definition of severe impact, and traffic congestion and inconvenience were not sufficient reasons for refusal on highways grounds.
Councillor Biggs commented that highways was often an area that the Committee struggled with. However, it was important to note that it had fulfilled its responsibility by seeking a review of highways matters from an independent consultant. He urged Members to give careful consideration to their decision.
Councillor E A Biggs noted that the new settlement boundary under the emerging Local Plan was nearer to the building than the old boundary. Given that the emerging Local Plan was not yet fully established, he felt that the Committee was currently in somewhat of a no-man’s land when it came to assessing the application. He questioned how the dwelling’s arts and craft design would fit in with the historical context of the village/area when his understanding was that new buildings should not be pastiches of the old.
In response to Councillor Biggs, she clarified that some permitted development rights, such as additions to the roof space and rear extensions, would be withdrawn since they were regarded as detrimental.
Councillor Biggs welcomed the applicant’s enthusiasm but stressed that the Local Planning Authority (LPA) had a duty to safeguard its heritage assets. The proposed style of roof was not sympathetic to the Kentish landscape. Moreover, without structural reports, it was difficult for the Committee to make an evidence-based assessment of the proposals.
In response to a query from Councillor Biggs, the Principal Planner advised that the applicant was required to submit a written scheme for archaeological investigations which would then be subject to consultation with KCC. In response to questions regarding ecological mitigation, she stated that reptiles would be translocated to a field south of the site.
Councillor Biggs viewed the scheme as an improvement on the original and welcomed it as a good addition to a residential area. In respect of flood mitigation, he sought reassurance on what information would be provided to future occupants. The Planning Consultant advised that there would be an emergency plan which would include information about the flood line, dry refuge locations, etc.
Councillor Biggs suggested that stock fencing would be suitable to use with planting.
Councillor Biggs accepted that there were a number of challenges in relation to the expansion of Whitfield, not least the effect of development on Whitfield roundabout. Officers had put in a lot of work behind the scenes to address highways issues which would take time to progress. Numerous discussions had taken place with statutory consultees such as KCC Highways and National Highways and Officers were obliged to follow their advice.
Councillor Biggs commented that the way the site was being developed was frustrating. He asked that an additional affordable unit be provided and requested that the developers be required to achieve 10% biodiversity as a gesture of goodwill.
In response to Councillor E A Biggs, the Planning Consultant advised that the country park was designated as open space in the current Local Plan and would remain as such in the draft Local Plan. Whilst this designation afforded a degree of protection, it was not a blanket ban on development. Local Green Space was a very specific designation and elevated protection to a level akin to green belt; such designation could only be achieved through the Local Plan-making process.
Councillor Biggs commented that there was a good deal of uncertainty around the ecology impact which was difficult to measure. In his view some of the economic benefits had been inflated.
Councillor Biggs voiced his support for the proposal, citing the Dover Society’s support as being a significant factor in his assessment. The Chairman commented that it was a sensitive site, but matters such as materials and permitted development rights were well covered by the proposed conditions.
Councillor Biggs praised the design of the house and commented that it would work well in this location which had an eclectic mix of houses.
It was agreed that Councillor E A Biggs be appointed as Vice-Chairman of the Dover Joint Transportation Advisory Board for 2023/24.
It was moved by Councillor S B Blair and duly seconded that Councillor E A Biggs be elected Chairman to preside over the meeting, in the absence of the Chairman and Vice-Chairman.
Councillor E A Biggs commented that the latter was a major shift in policy which had not been publicised or, as far as he was aware, widely consulted upon. He had sought advice from the Council’s Planners about the confidentiality of pre-application advice and been advised that it was information that could probably be disclosed under a Freedom of Information request. Councillor O C de R Richardson disliked the tone of the report and referred to paragraphs 1.3 and 1.9 which were contradictory in his view.
In response to a query from Councillor E A Biggs, she clarified that a full assessment of the site would have been undertaken as part of the lawful development certificate process. The applicant would have been required to submit evidence that the use of the containers as a dwellinghouse had existed for four years or more. Officers, including the Planning Solicitor, had reviewed the information submitted and determined that there was a lawful use.
Councillor Biggs commented that he had visited the site when the original structure was in situ and had found it to be unattractive and unacceptable in the street scene.
It was proposed by Councillor E A Biggs and duly seconded that Application No DOV/22/00688 be REFUSED in accordance with the report recommendation.
In response to Councillor E A Biggs who mentioned obscure glazing, it was clarified that the plans showed one of the windows as being obscure glazed. Whilst it was a condition that could be imposed if Members wished, it was not one that could have been imposed had the extension not needed planning permission.
Councillor Biggs agreed that a construction management plan was necessary given that the site was on a busy corner. He commented that the scheme was slightly disappointing and, in his view, could have been done better. In respect of the fence along London Road, the Principal Planner advised that permitted development rights would restrict this to a maximum height of one metre because it was adjacent to the highway.
In response to Councillor Biggs, she clarified that wastewater would be deposited into containers and managed by the applicants. From the application details, she understood that the huts and horse box were likely to be finished in dark green and the finish was likely to be the only detail that could be controlled by the Local Planning Authority (LPA).
Councillor Biggs commented that the masterplan was key to assessing the application. The proposed scheme did not integrate into the wider development and there was no ecology report. The Neighbourhood Plan was an excellent document and the application’s failure to comply with it led him to believe that the application should not be approved.
Councillor Biggs referred to the four previous refusals and the two appeals that had been dismissed. The dwelling that was currently proposed was bigger than previous designs and there had been no change in policies that now made this site acceptable for development. The Senior Planner confirmed that the dwelling was larger than those previously refused on the ground of their visual impact.
Councillor E A Biggs queried whether the planning permission granted in 2019 was still valid and sought clarification on the water efficiency condition and the increase from three to four dwellings. The Planning Consultant clarified that the permission had been granted in mid to late December 2019 and was about to expire. However, the fact that planning permission had previously been granted was a material consideration, whether the permission had lapsed or not.
It was noted that, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor H M Williams had been appointed as a substitute member for Councillor E A Biggs.
In response to matters raised by Councillor E A Biggs, the Planning Consultant advised Members that the closure of hangar facilities at Maypole airfield was not relevant to their consideration of the application which should be assessed on its own merits. He clarified that electric aircraft were an emerging technology to which no weight had been attached when assessing the application. He agreed that the use of the airfield for emergency helicopter landings was of limited benefit given that landing areas for helicopters were generally widely available.
Councillor Biggs referred to the numerous reasons for refusal and questioned why the application had been brought forward with so many fundamental issues unresolved. He was puzzled why some Members had sought to add reasons for refusal to the application previously considered at the meeting but, in this case, where there were numerous and overwhelming reasons for refusal, they were looking to defer or approve the application. The proposed scheme was a random, eclectic group of houses that lacked cohesion and amenity.
Councillor Biggs commented that his understanding was that the increase in students was not a problem and that a restriction had only been imposed due to KCC Highways’ concerns about the access at Wigmore Lane which it considered to be dangerous. In his view, the fact that KCC Highways was satisfied with the scheme was sufficient to grant planning permission. The Planning Consultant agreed that KCC Highways’ concerns had been centred around the access being via Wigmore Lane which was not now the case.
Councillor Biggs raised concerns about the impact of the toilets on the curtilage-listed buildings. The Senior Planner noted that the toilets would be a compact and temporary structure, sited in the corner of the site, and not present on the site all the time. They were necessary to enable the venue to function and their visual impact would not be so unduly detrimental to warrant a refusal.
Councillor Biggs spoke in favour of self-build projects and was of the view that more could be done by the Council to support them. That being said, this particular application had a number of fundamental problems that militated against it. It was outside the settlement confines, and in an unsustainable location, where development would be contrary to the LPA’s policies.
It was noted that, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor E A Biggs had been appointed as substitute members for Councillor P M Brivio.
Councillor E A Biggs welcomed the development, stating that it was of high quality and noting that the applicant had done what he could to address the issues raised at the last meeting. He proposed that the application should be approved.
Councillor Biggs queried the arrangements for managing the supported living units and refuse collection. The TLDM referred to paragraph 2.16 of the report which set out the parking arrangements and the policy requirements. In summary, KCC Highways was of the view that the site was able to provide sufficient parking in line with DM13.
Councillor E A Biggs sympathised with residents and sought clarification on the B8 classification. He commented that scaffolding was a noisy business and the scaffolding towers would be high and intrusive. The Principal Planner advised that the B8 classification covered storage and distribution.
Councillor Biggs agreed, adding that, unlike some back garden developments, this was on a generous plot and surrounded by similarly large gardens. The low-level design gave the dwelling the appearance of an outbuilding which meant it blended into its surroundings.
In response to Councillor E A Biggs, the Planning Solicitor advised that the Local Planning Authority (LPA) was required to consider whether the access was safe. It was not the Committee’s role to think about whether residents could restrict or control the developer’s access to the route. It was KCC’s public rights of way team that had raised the issue of road safety and suggested a construction management plan to address it.
Councillor E A Biggs stated that he found Class Q permitted development rights confusing and apparently open to different interpretations by local authorities. His understanding was that the aim of Class Q was to retain agricultural buildings in the landscape which would not be the case with this proposal. If prior approval had not been given, his view was that approval would be unlikely.
Councillor Biggs commented that the proposal appeared to be an over-intensive backland development and the positioning of a driveway along the side of a dwelling was unacceptable. He also disliked the parking area at the front of the property which was out-of-keeping with the existing street scene.
It was proposed by Councillor E A Biggs and duly seconded that Application No DOV/21/01903 be REFUSED on the grounds that the proposed scheme had not adequately addressed concerns raised in relation to the previous application, namely that the extension of the driveway to the proposed dwelling would, by reason of its use, the comings and goings of pedestrians and vehicles and associated levels of activity along it by the occupiers of and visitors to the proposed dwelling, harm the living conditions of the occupiers of Nos. 21 and 23 Bewsbury Crescent. On being put to the vote, there was an equality of votes and the motion FAILED.
Councillor Biggs noted the inclusion of tandem parking and lamented a missed opportunity to build energy efficient housing. The Planning Consultant advised that a private company would manage the open space and sustainable underground drainage system, but the central open space would be transferred to the Highways Authority. Whilst there was some tandem parking, this was because it was considered more efficient and took up less road frontage.
Councillor Biggs expressed concerns about what he regarded as a backland development and squeezing a dwelling into such a narrow plot. The Planning Consultant clarified that backland developments did not normally have a frontage onto the highway and this proposal was not therefore regarded as a backland development. The parking spaces that were attributed to no. 18 Sandwich Road had already been displaced elsewhere.
In response to Councillor E A Biggs, it was clarified that several buildings, probably used as air raid shelters, would be demolished. Whilst there would be noise and disturbance to 90A during construction, this would clearly be for a relatively short period and not an ongoing problem. The original plans discussed at the pre-application stage had proposed a larger fifth dwelling which, on the advice of Officers, had been scaled back and moved away from the boundary.
Councillor Biggs stated that he was elected to represent the opinions of local people and he could not ignore the very large number of objections received. It was a contentious site and its development would be a loss to the area. The Team Leader advised that KCC had assessed the proposed road layout for safety and functionality.
It was noted that, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor H M Williams had been appointed as a substitute member for Councillor E A Biggs.
Councillor E A Biggs commented that the road to the site was narrow and overgrown. He was of the view that an additional dwelling in this location was not desirable. The Planning Officer pointed out that paragraph 11 of the NPPF had a presumption of approval unless significant and demonstrable harm would be caused.
Councillor Biggs argued that the dwelling had to work for modern families and should be repurposed. The Planning Solicitor referred Members to paragraph 3.1 of the report where the clear conclusions of the Council’s Heritage Officer against the proposals were summarised. He clarified that the listing applied to the entire building, including any modern extensions.
Councillor Biggs spoke in favour of the proposal which would provide affordable housing within a well-designed scheme. Citing the landscape buffer as a crucial element, he proposed that the application should be approved.
In response to concerns raised by Councillor E A Biggs about refuse storage, the Planning Officer advised that there would be no external amenity space. For this reason, storage space for bins and bicycles would be created within the dwellings which would use smaller refuse bins accordingly.
Councillor Biggs was of the opinion that Dover did not need another hotel or swimming-pool. The proposed motel was a bland building when something distinctive was needed in this iconic location. He had been enthusiastic about the original proposal to use shipping containers but was underwhelmed by the latest proposals, arguing that a design review should have been undertaken.
In response to a query from Councillor Biggs, it was clarified that planning application fees were set nationally and were therefore beyond the Council’s control. Fees were reduced for some charitable organisations and parish councils.
Councillor E A Biggs spoke in favour of the proposal which would improve the condition of the existing cottages and secure an impressive new building.
Councillor Biggs welcomed the development, commenting that it was a large plot and expanding an existing dwelling rather than adding another one in was to be commended.
Councillor Biggs argued that the traffic movements would be different to those generated by the pub and restaurant, and were likely to occur at similar hours of the day, for example at school drop-off and collection times. The Principal Planner recognised that the pattern of traffic movements arising from the new development would be different. She recapped that the development would use an existing access which was not a public access nor new as part of the application.
In response to Councillor E A Biggs, he advised that the site was largely bare agricultural land. Whilst there would be some impact on trees on Sandwich Road due to access, this was not considered to be sufficiently harmful to warrant a refusal. He clarified that the latest local housing requirement had been taken into consideration and was factored into the report recommendation.
In response to Councillor Biggs, the Planning Consultant understood that the site was well managed, with the applicant having been at the site since at least 2008. Whilst planning permission was attached to the land and it could change ownership, he was not convinced that a management plan was necessary. He clarified that there was currently a deficit of 13 pitches which needed to be filled by March 2022.
Councillor Biggs requested that conditions be added regarding surface water and refuse.
In response to concerns raised by Councillor E A Biggs about massing and style, the Planning Officer added that it was not unusual to have a two-storey building next to a bungalow. The proposed dwelling, like the existing one, would be built of brick, with white windows and a similar floor area on the ground floor. The only difference between the two properties was the additional floor.
Councillor Biggs agreed that the lack of substantial information about the trees meant that the infilling of the cutting could not be justified.
In response to Councillor Biggs, the Principal Planner clarified that there had been concerns that a narrow alleyway between the two proposed buildings would be dark and uninviting, with the potential to attract anti-social behaviour. The possibility of bringing the alleyway within the development site had been explored and discussions held with KCC. However, the cost and timescales involved were prohibitive.
In response to Councillor E A Biggs, the Planning Consultant clarified that some works to the hall building had already commenced without permission. He explained that, whilst a non-designated heritage asset was one that was not listed, it was considered to be of historical interest. Whilst such assets could not be protected statutorily, they had a value which meant that their alteration or demolition would be subject to scrutiny.
In response to Councillor Biggs, the Principal Planner confirmed that the base of the dwellings had already been poured. They were similar to the measurements shown in the approved plans for the dwellings that had already been granted planning permission.
It was moved by Councillor E A Biggs and duly seconded that Application No DOV/21/00567 be REFUSED as per the Officer’s recommendation.
Councillor E A Biggs stressed the need to ensure that biodiversity compensation was provided on a like-for-like basis. He supported earlier requests to receive further information about the ecology reports required as part of the legal agreement. The Principal Planner clarified that BCP was protected as open space in the Local Plan but had no statutory designation for wildlife.
Councillor Biggs questioned why the application was before Committee when it was evidently contrary to local and national policies. If granted, what was to stop any rural business building a dwelling on the basis that it would form an essential part of the business. The rationale behind key worker policies had been to support animal husbandry, etc.
In response to Councillor E A Biggs, the Senior Planner reported that the applicants had been advised to withdraw and resubmit an amended application on the basis that the proposal was unlikely to be approved. They had chosen not to do so. She added that there was no scope for screening along the western or southern boundaries.
In response to Councillor Biggs, it was clarified that there was a condition that would ensure that the trees forming the western boundary of the site would be protected, with a requirement to seek permission from the LPA should future works to them be proposed. Removing soil deposited on the roots as a result of the Gore Lane development should help to rehabilitate them. Were the trees to fail in future, Officers could look at including additional planting in the landscaping scheme.
Councillor Biggs welcomed the proposals for the reception and bar area which looked distinct and vibrant. However, he expressed concerns about the design of the motel. He liked the concept of using shipping containers and was aware of similar developments elsewhere.
Councillor Biggs raised concerns about the storage of fertiliser near dwellings which he viewed as a potential hazard. He also referred to the barn outside the site and the fact that there would be no control over its use. Whilst the site would be ideal for commercial development, he did not believe it was suitable for residential use.
It was proposed by Councillor E A Biggs and duly seconded that Application No DOV/20/01303 be REFUSED on the grounds that:
In response to Councillor E A Biggs, the DDM advised that 278 agreements were made between a developer and Kent County Council (KCC) where works in support of a development and affecting an existing highway were proposed. In cases of minor highway works, a letter of understanding would normally suffice. Section 38 agreements were used tosecure the adoption of new roads by the highway authority.
In response to Councillor Biggs who questioned why the changes had to be brought in by April, the POM advised that the implementation dates had been brought forward. Three of the proposals had to go through the lengthy TRO process and agreeing delegations to the Chairman and Vice-Chairman was therefore the only way of ensuring that the changes were introduced by the deadline agreed by Cabinet.
It was moved by Councillor E A Biggs, duly seconded and
Councillor E A Biggs agreed that the proposal was an appealing facility but in the wrong place and would harm the attractive vista of the seafront.
Councillor Biggs voiced concerns about the report recommendation, and believed that there was insufficient information to come to a view on the application that evening. He was concerned about the ecological impact of the proposal, and mindful that there had been a significant number of public objections. For these reasons he could not support the proposal.
In response to concerns raised by Councillor E A Biggs, the Senior Planner confirmed that the proposed orientation of the dwelling was considered appropriate for the site given its relationship with adjacent properties. She also advised that, although vehicles would have to reverse in and out of the parking area, this was a similar arrangement to other properties in the road and was considered acceptable by KCC Highways. She clarified that a standard condition for electric vehicle charging points was used to reflect the fact that there were different types of plug.
Councillor Biggs expressed concerns about access, double parking at school times and the inability of cars to pass each other. Castle Avenue was one of only a few streets in Dover offering large, attractive homes in sizeable plots. He questioned whether granting permission for a block of flats would set a precedent for others to demolish houses and replace them with flats.
Councillor Biggs stated that he disliked infill developments, questioning what was to stop another development being built to the north of the site. Whilst Members were aware that discussions about flooding at Albert Road were ongoing, they had yet to receive any details of these.
It was noted that in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor E A Biggs had been appointed as substitute member for Councillor H M Williams.
In response to a question from Councillor E A Biggs, the members of the committee were assured that there was no intention to use the powers to target any particular socio-economic demographic in the community.
Councillor E A Biggs agreed that the changes made were insignificant. The proposal was unacceptable due to the harm it would cause to the AONB which should be protected.
In response to Councillor Biggs who referred to setting a precedent, the Planning Solicitor advised that the creation of a precedent was capable of being a material consideration. The question was whether a proposal could be replicated widely across the district and therefore whether the granting of permission in this instance would create a risk of other such applications being submitted. In those circumstances, granting planning permission could be seen to be setting a precedent.
Councillor Biggs raised concerns about back-garden development and the potential creation of a precedent. In his view the extension to the existing building and the proposed dwelling were not in keeping with neighbouring dwellings. The Planning Officer clarified that it was the roof of the extension that had not been constructed in accordance with the approved plans and which was currently the subject of investigation.
It was moved by Councillor E A Biggs, duly seconded and
Councillor E A Biggs commented that the design of the gazebo appeared incongruous in relation to the house which was Georgian. Councillor O C de R Richardson agreed and, referring to complaints, queried whether the gazebo could be reduced in height so it was not visible above the garden wall. The Trainee Planner advised that Members were required to consider the application before them.
Councillor Biggs referred to the overbearing nature of the proposed building, and agreed that it would have an unacceptable impact on the garden of No 5. In his view it was possible to build a better scheme on the site.
In accordance with Council Procedure Rule 13, Councillor E A Biggs moved the Motion of which he had given notice as followed:
Councillor E A Biggs and his seconder agreed to accept the AMENDMENT.
It was suggested by Councillor Biggs that further details of sustainability measures should also be required. The Planning Officer clarified that the proposed dwelling would reduce Ryarsh’s annual sunlight hours from 76% to 66%. She stressed that the proposed dwelling had been moved further away from Ryarsh and the ridge height reduced by 1.1 metres.
In response to concerns raised by Councillor Biggs about vehicular access for allotment holders, the Principal Planner stressed that there was currently only an informal agreement between the club and allotment holders. Negotiations were taking place outside the planning process and it was a matter for the parties to resolve. The Committee’s role was solely to assess the proposal for a new tennis court in this location.
In response to queries from Councillor E A Biggs, the Planning Consultant clarified that the basement was in use and that an attic room was not currently in use. It would be a breach of conditions if its subsequent occupation raised the number of residents above the threshold of seven. In terms of parking, it was the view of Kent County Council (KCC) Highways and Officers that the demand for parking was unlikely to be materially different from the demand generated by the building’s previous use as a family dwelling.
Councillor Biggs commented that the construction of a dwelling in this location was unfortunate, particularly when it could encourage others to do the same.
Councillor Biggs commented that the site should be left undeveloped. There had already been a lot of development in the area, and he was struggling to see the justification for shoe-horning in the proposed scheme.
Councillor Biggs supported the proposal which would see the replacement of a redundant building, and Councillor Williams welcomed the good design. The Planning Officer confirmed that a pre-commencement condition for a construction management plan would ensure that all matters such as construction access would be addressed.
Councillor Biggs agreed that traffic and parking were significant issues. Furthermore, he was not convinced that parking spaces provided within the development would be available for Stanhope Road residents. He also raised concerns about the use of tandem parking spaces.
In response to concerns expressed by Councillor E A Biggs about the length of tenancies, the Principal Planner advised that the Council’s housing team had identified 12 months as an appropriate tenancy period. Tenants would be supported by the Council and moved on at an appropriate time by the housing team. The proposal’s aim was to get the homeless off the streets and to provide an alternative to B&B accommodation.
Councillor Biggs commented that the proposed building was completely inappropriate for the location in terms of pricing and design. He was sceptical that the development would ever go ahead at a loss of £2 million. By approving the application the Committee would be blocking a site that could be developed more appropriately and for the benefit of the community.
It was proposed by Councillor E A Biggs and duly seconded that Application No DOV/19/00287 be REFUSED on the grounds that the proposal was out-of-keeping with the street scene and character of the area and due to the lack of affordable housing.
Councillor E A Biggs supported the proposal which was a modest extension that would use sympathetic materials in keeping with the building’s surroundings.
Councillor Biggs expressed disappointment that the application was before the Committee when the application site was outside settlement confines, in an unsustainable location and the buildings were incapable of being converted. He queried whether the approval of the Ham Barn application, which was a similar development brought to Committee, had set a precedent. In response, the Planning Solicitor advised that the courts accepted that setting a precedent was a valid reason for refusal and it was certainly a material consideration.
Following a point raised by Councillor E A Biggs, it was acknowledged that gable dormers were more prominent in this locality. However, Officers were not looking to replicate every design feature of the surrounding estate, and the dormer proposed for this dwelling would add interest to the roofline.
Councillor Biggs pointed out that the applicant had sought pre-application advice, followed by negotiations, yet the proposal was still found to be unacceptable.
Councillor E A Biggs raised concerns about the height of the proposed dwelling in relation to surrounding properties, and its potentially dominating appearance.
In response to Councillor Biggs, it was clarified that the live/work units had been removed due to there being no demand for them, a finding which was supported by the Council’s own research. Their inclusion had been subject to that caveat, and it would not be considered reasonable to insist on their reinstatement.
Councillor Biggs voiced his disappointment at the removal of the units, and the marginal increase in affordable housing being offered by one of the country’s biggest developers. The Principal Planner emphasised the lack of demand for the units, and reminded Members that they were required to assess the application before them. He clarified that the affordable housing provision had been approved as part of the reserved matters.
Councillor E A Biggs pointed to the potential impact on the AONB and failed to understand how design improvements would be able to address that. The Planning Consultant clarified that the Planning Inspector had been satisfied that the access for one additional dwelling would be acceptable.
Councillor E A Biggs agreed that there was no merit in the scheme which would offer limited parking and poor standards of internal accommodation and external amenity space. Councillors Bond and Richardson added that parking provision was inadequate.
Councillor Edward Biggs expressed disappointment that the affordable housing contribution was not higher given the quality of the development. The Principal Planner explained that the Council’s housing team had been consulted on the allocation of this money. Moreover, the addendum to the Affordable Housing Supplementary Planning Document defined how financial contributions should be calculated.
Whilst acknowledging what had previously been considered, Councillor Biggs expressed concerns about the access and the development’s impact on the road. He was of the opinion that a site visit would be helpful.
It was moved by Councillor E A Biggs and duly seconded that a site visit be held to enable Members to visually assess the access and the potential impact on the road.
In response to Councillor E A Biggs who queried the review procedure, he advised that the review process would involve a Stage 3 road safety audit which would review the alterations and how they were operating. Officers were confident that the predicted trip rates were robust. He added that, when forecasting movements, previous national guidelines did not require any junction with fewer than 30 traffic movements to be considered which gave Members an indication of how severe traffic impacts had to be before a full assessment of highway capacity was required.
It was moved by Councillor E A Biggs, duly seconded and
Councillor Biggs reported on the site visit which had taken place on 11 February. A large contingent of members of the public had attended, together with parish council representatives, the applicant and KCC Highways Officers. As well as making their representations, the public had been given the opportunity to ask questions of KCC Officers.
Councillor E A Biggs commented that, whilst he thought it was a potentially exciting development, he had been surprised how tranquil the area was when he visited recently, and his view was that the increase in use would have a significant impact on residents. He also doubted the economic case for further development as he believed the majority of the jobs created would be of low value. In response to Councillor J P J Burman, the Principal Planner advised that ‘silent’ days could be changed without notice.
Councillor E A Biggs welcomed the scheme, as did the Chairman who urged other parishes to follow Staple’s example.
Councillor E A Biggs expressed concerns about the application, commenting that Folkestone Road had a chequered history and already suffered from anti-social behaviour issues. He did not believe this was the right location for an HMO.
Councillor Biggs welcomed the proposal which he regarded as a positive development.
Councillor Biggs welcomed the proposal, arguing that it would help to support the rural economy, and enable owners to exercise their horses after work in winter when business costs were highest.
Councillor E A Biggs expressed support for the applicants’ wish to replace a garage with open parking given that older garages were often unable to accommodate modern vehicles. Councillor O C de R Richardson referred to Kent Police’s suggestion that 1.5-metre hedges should be planted on both sides of the boundary wall to maintain security.
Councillor Biggs expressed disappointment that a new application was before the Committee for consideration. In his view, the proposal was an unsympathetic design in the countryside. The replacement of an agricultural barn with an egocentric dwelling should be resisted.
(3) Councillor E A Biggs asked the Portfolio Holder for Housing and Health, Councillor S S Chandler:
Councillor E A Biggs was doubtful that the proposed development would generate a similar amount of traffic to the site’s previous use as a nursing home. Wellington Parade had a unique vista. In his opinion the proposed development would affect the street scene and was therefore inappropriate.
Councillor E A Biggs expressed disappointment with the proposed design of the scheme and the lack of affordable housing.
Councillor Biggs reported on the site visit, the purpose of which had been to assess the potential impact on the countryside and to understand the needs of the applicant. A Tilmanstone Parish Council representative had attended the site visit and raised no objections. Following a walk around the site and along the footpath, Members had concluded that the proposed development would have a modest impact on the countryside.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Biggs attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Biggs's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Biggs was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Dover has not published attendance for Councillor Biggs's meetings yet.
What Councillor Biggs declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 13 Jan 2025 | Cabinet, item 70 | Councillor E A Biggs declared an Other Significant Interest in Agenda Item 7 (Appointment of Professional Consultants for Proposed Redevelopment of Albany Place Car Park, Dover for Affordable Housing) by reason that he was the Chairman of Municipal Charities of Dover, an outside body to which he had been appointed by the Council, which had an interest in acquiring some of the car park land. |
Where Councillor Biggs sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Biggs yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.