Asked13 Mar 2025Local Pension Board
Regulatory Update
Councillor A Hopgood asked who would ‘pick up the bill’ if Government legislated in terms of investment and such investments performed poorly. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted that the suggestions so far were that Government would ‘nudge’ in terms of investment into UK productive capital, with no indication that they would directly underwrite investment.
Asked13 Mar 2025Local Pension Board
Pension Fund Training Policy and Governance Compliance
Councillor A Hopgood queried the proposed Pension Fund training for the end of March 2025, raising concern over attendance give proximity to elections. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted the need to progress the Fund’s business, and the continuity of Committee membership from non-Durham County Council Committee members. He added that he would circulate the Pensions Regulations Toolkit to the Board, and all new members appointed to the Fund’s governance bodies.
Said17 Dec 2024Local Pension Board
Pension Administration Report
Councillor A Hopgood noted the new Government’s direction in terms of an expectation in relation to inward investment into the UK by Pension Funds. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted that intention, noting the LGPS Consultation item later on the agenda. He added that there was a proposed requirement for a ‘plan for local investment’, however, that could be zero, or perhaps up to five percent.
Said17 Dec 2024Local Pension Board
Pension Administration Report
Councillor A Hopgood agreed, noting that Government needed to be clear that Pension Funds’ purpose was to pay pensions to its members, and that money not generating appropriate returns to enable pensions to be paid, was not an appropriate investment for the LGPS.
Asked17 Dec 2024Local Pension Board
LGPS Consultation - 'LGPS: Fit for the future'
Councillor A Hopgood asked if Government would look to ‘clamp down’ on those Funds which had not pooled. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted there were now hard deadlines in terms of pooling criteria and the March 2026 date.
Asked17 Dec 2024Local Pension Board
LGPS Consultation - 'LGPS: Fit for the future'
Councillor A Hopgood asked if there were implication for Durham. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted not directly, as Durham had pooled effectively through BCPP with most assets already under management; however all Pools would be required to submit proposals as to how they would meet the aspirations of the consultation.
Said17 Dec 2024Local Pension Board
LGPS Consultation - 'LGPS: Fit for the future'
Councillor A Hopgood noted the Government messaging appeared to be mixed, with many aspects looking at devolved powers, with their proposals in relation to the LGPS being the opposite. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) reiterated that Government was looking for greater investment in the regions, through the eight “megafund” Pools, rather than 86 individual Pension Funds.
Said17 Dec 2024Local Pension Board
LGPS Consultation - 'LGPS: Fit for the future'
Councillor A Hopgood noted other Government approaches ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Asked12 Sep 2024Local Pension Board
Pensions Dashboard Preparation
Councillor A Hopgood asked if we would be promoting the Pensions Dashboard. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted there would be a national advertising push and the Pensions Team Leader added that we would promote alongside our Pensions Portal, including information setting out the benefits and features available via our Pensions Portal. The Pensions Team Leader noted that the second table within the report set out a number of challenges, and she explained there were a number of LGPS Practitioners Groups that were discussing these issues and providing helpful information.
Named24 Jun 2024Local Pension Board
Observations and Feedback from Pension Fund Committee
The Head of Pensions (LGPS) , Paul Cooper noted Councillor A Hopgood had attended the meeting of the Pension Fund Committee held 24 June 2024 and presented the Annual report of the Local Pension Board to the Committee. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted that the Committee had received a number of reports, including in Part A: review of the Committee’s Terms of Reference; Internal Audit update;
Asked24 Jun 2024Local Pension Board
Observations and Feedback from Pension Fund Committee
Councillor A Hopgood asked as regards performance of Global Equity Alpha and the Funda Managers and structure. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted the current position and explained as regards fees.
Asked24 Jun 2024Local Pension Board
Regulatory Update
Councillor A Hopgood asked whether there was any consequence for those Funds that had not yet demonstrated pooling progress. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) explained that there may be issues for those Funds, reminding the Board of the progress that Durham had made with Border to Coast Pensions Partnership (BCPP) in respect of pooling, with a looming 2025 deadline against which Fund may be assessed. He added it appeared that there appeared to be a desire for fewer pools, of larger scale, noting the current largest pool being around £60 billion, with Government referring to economies of scale of up to and beyond £100 billion.
Said24 Jun 2024Local Pension Board
Pensions Regulator Single Code of Practice Update
Councillor A Hopgood noted caution regards changing positions in respect of climate change, and the risk of investing too much resource at this early stage. The Pensions Team Leader gave further details in respect of Administration and reporting to the Regulator. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted a report to come back to the Board in March 2025, following the end of an external review.
Named24 Jun 2024Local Pension Board
Pensions Regulator Single Code of Practice Update
The Chair and Councillor A Hopgood reiterated the importance of cybersecurity and impact and reputational damage that could result from a successful cyber-attack. The Chair noted she would share further information with Officers, as required.
Asked24 Jun 2024Local Pension Board
Internal Dispute Resolution Procedure
Councillor A Hopgood asked as regards compensatory payments, set out at paragraph seven of the report. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted that this can be a small amount when compared to reputational risk, however, some cases related to old transfer cases. The Pensions Team Leader reminded the Board that scheme members were allowed to transfer, however, it was important to not only give those individuals sufficient information but also to evidence that information had been given, so that the scheme member could make an informed decision.
Named24 Jun 2024Local Pension Board
Internal Dispute Resolution Procedure
Councillor A Hopgood made an analogy to mortgage payment protection payments, and the high number of claims following high profile advertising as regards claims of being mis-sold those policies. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted that there were a number of companies that would canvass scheme members in terms of making a complaint, however, he reiterated that the number we received were relatively small, with none currently sufficient to refer to the Ombudsman.
Asked22 Mar 2024Local Pension Board
Observations and Feedback from Pension Fund Committee
Councillor A Hopgood asked if there were a large number of requests in terms of such transfers. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted that volumes are included in the KPI reporting but the complexity is a greater issue than volume. The Pensions Team Leader explained that there were a number of options in terms of draw down, as well as a lot of ‘interfund-fund’ transfers.
Named22 Mar 2024Local Pension Board
Observations and Feedback from Pension Fund Committee
Councillor A Hopgood, noted that the work the Chair referred to had been nominated for a national award. The Chair added that the work had been used as a case study and presented to over 100 Headteachers, with the finals of the Cyber Outstanding Security Performance Awards (OSPA) being held in April 2024. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted work with the Council’s ICT Section as well as the Civil Contingencies Team.
Asked22 Mar 2024Local Pension Board
Training Policy and Governance Compliance Statement
Councillor A Hopgood asked if there could be substitute members at the Pension Fund Committee, the Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted they could, if they had received the requisite training in the current term. He added that there were always additional training sessions for Pension Fund Committee Members in advance of any investment decision. He added the proposed training programme would include regulatory toolkits and there would be an expectation that Members completed the training programme within the timeframes outlined.
Said22 Mar 2024Local Pension Board
Training Policy and Governance Compliance Statement
Councillor A Hopgood suggested if Board members were available, it would be beneficial to attend the BCCP conference.
Asked22 Mar 2024Local Pension Board
Regulatory Update
Councillor A Hopgood asked if a change in Government could lead to a change in direction. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted that the Opposition had indicated they would go ‘further and faster ’ and that the expectation currently was that the 2025 deadline would be ‘comply or explain’ deadline, with an expectation that Funds would comply, with there being powers of intervention. He added the Minister had put the question, whether 87 Pension Funds across the LGPS was the correct number and the Minister had outlined a desire for greater LGPS allocations that support the Levelling Up missions; with targets of 10 percent in private equity.
Said22 Mar 2024Local Pension Board
Regulatory Update
Councillor A Hopgood noted that whilst local investment was to be commended, however, the primary role of the Fund was to ensure that pensioners were able to receive their pensions. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) agreed, outlining the Fund’s responsibility to try and keep pension contributions as stable as possible. He noted that through BCPP’s UK Opportunities Fund it was hoped that the Fund could achieve some secondary, positive, benefits in the UK;
Said22 Mar 2024Local Pension Board
Spring Budget 2024 - Verbal Update
Councillor A Hopgood noted Government was considering legislation in terms of private providers and Children’s Homes.
Asked22 Mar 2024Local Pension Board
Pension Administration Report
Councillor A Hopgood asked as regards how to prioritise, with some perhaps being looked at quarterly, some annually as an example. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted that approach could make sense, with colleagues developing performance reporting on death processes, and making appropriate process changes being top of the list. He added that quick wins would be taken in line with the ‘best endeavours’ intention, then the rest of the KPIs would be built out though 2024/25.
Said22 Mar 2024Local Pension Board
Pension Administration Report
Councillor A Hopgood noted that it may be that less important KPIs could be reported upon at points when the Team were not as busy with other work.
Said22 Mar 2024Local Pension Board
Communications Review
Councillor A Hopgood noted she may be able to attend, and it would be helpful if the item was early on the agenda.
Asked7 Dec 2023Local Pension Board
Observations and Feedback from Pension Fund Committee
Councillor A Hopgood asked as regards ethical investment. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted that was within the RI policy and would increasing be more important. He noted that for changes to those policies, all of the 11 Partner Funds would need to agree them, noting the Durham Pension Fund Committee had agreed the changes, with some input and challenge.
Said7 Dec 2023Local Pension Board
Local Pension Board Training - Verbal Update
Councillor A Hopgood noted she felt that this was a sensible update, bringing the Committee in line with the Board.
Asked7 Dec 2023Local Pension Board
Pension Fund Debt Management
Councillor A Hopgood asked if Government were likely to change the £250 threshold, as a consequence of inflation, increases in national minimum wage and so on. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted the level was felt to be sufficient at the moment , however, if HMRC were to raise their level then it would be revisited.
Said7 Dec 2023Local Pension Board
Responsible Investment Policy
Councillor A Hopgood noted the balance in terms of ethical investments and returns to be able to pay pensioners. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted that balance, and where there could be opportunities in the future.
Said7 Dec 2023Local Pension Board
Regulatory Update
Councillor A Hopgood noted that it was an excellent example of getting communication right and added her thanks to the team for their work.
Asked7 Dec 2023Local Pension Board
Regulatory Update
Councillor A Hopgood asked if any change in Government would impact upon the direction. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted that there was cross-party support for the changes, with the Shadow Chancellor, Rachel Reeves MP having supported further and faster changes.
Named14 Sep 2023Local Pension Board
Apologies for Absence
In the absence of the Chair, it was agreed that Councillor A Hopgood would Chair the meeting.
Named14 Sep 2023Local Pension Board
Apologies for Absence
Councillor A Hopgood in the Chair
Named16 Mar 2023Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held 16 March 2023
He added that he hoped it was not a trend, with Councillor A Hopgood noting it was an issue she had previously raised with the Chair of the Committee. The Head of Pensions (LGPS), Paul Cooper, noted there had been fewer Members in attendance than usual, however he noted that the meeting had been quorate.
Asked16 Mar 2023Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held 16 March 2023
Councillor A Hopgood asked as regards substitute Members, and whether the attendance could be looked at and reported back to the council’s Group Leaders.
Said16 Mar 2023Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held 16 March 2023
The Chair asked if there was a rule in terms of minimum attendance, Councillor A Hopgood noted for Durham County Councillors it was attendance at a meeting of any Council Committee the Councillor was a member of in a six-month period.
Asked16 Mar 2023Local Pension Board
Regulatory Update
Councillor A Hopgood asked how low other Funds were in terms of their percentage of pooled funds. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) explained that some funds had zero pooled funds and that while the Government policy was clear in terms of polling, the legal absolute legal required states that Funds should simply have a plan for pooling in place. He noted that DLUHC have made clear that intention is that Funds get with the requirement to pool, and statutory guidance may be issued.
Said16 Mar 2023Local Pension Board
Regulatory Update
Councillor A Hopgood noted the arguments for the merits of the changes, however, noted she could see why it may be felt it would not fix the problems intended, in terms of encouraging NHS staff to continue working for longer or coming out of retirement. The Head of Pensions (LGPS) noted that many in that situation already managed their position carefully and that it would not affect many within the LGPS.
Said26 Jul 2021Local Pension Board
Regulatory and Administration Update
Referring to the minimum pension age Councillor Hopgood suggested that a caveat was used to ensure that members knew it would always be 10 years below the state retirement age.
Asked26 Jul 2021Local Pension Board
Pension Administration Report
With regards to targets Councillor Hopgood asked that as some delays were due to the Scheme Employer and therefore out of the Fund’s direct control, we should look to set a more realistic target, rather than expecting to reach 100%. It was suggested that this should be assessed once a year’s data was known.
Said26 Jul 2021Local Pension Board
Membership of Board - verbal update
Councillor Hopgood advised of Councillor Tinsley’s resignation and that there would be a replacement appointed for the next meeting. She asked that a letter of thanks be sent to Ian Densham for his time and commitment to the board. He had been a great contributor and attendee and she wished him well for the future.
Named11 Mar 2021Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held on 11 March 2021
Local Pension Board Members Councillor Hopgood and Ian Densham were in attendance at the Pension Fund Committee, and had no particular observations to make. The Board members considered that the Committee had asked pertinent questions of Officers, Advisers and BCPP.
Named12 Mar 2020Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held on 12 March 2020
Councillor Hopgood considered that the Pension Fund Advisers’ views on the impact of Covid-19 were over-optimistic, and she was concerned about the effects on global and UK markets, and the impact this may have on the Fund. Paul Cooper replied that Durham Pension Fund was a long-term investor, and the 35% allocation in defensive markets would offset the riskier high return investments. The situation would be closely monitored; Officers met regularly with the Chair of the Committee between meetings, and the Chair attended BCPP Joint Committee meetings.
Named12 Mar 2020Local Pension Board
Communications Review
Councillor Hopgood referred to the Statement at Appendix 1 and asked if the Local Pension Board should be included in the list of those bodies the Administering Authority communicated with. Paul Cooper confirmed that the Statement would be updated to reflect this.
Said17 Sep 2019Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held on 12 September 2019
Councillor Hopgood suggested that it would be useful for a Sub-Committee of the Pension Fund Committee to be established which could consider matters requiring decisions between the cycle of Committee meetings. Members were informed that BCPP was aware of the meetings cycle and in March 2019 was informed that Durham was a potential investor. The private credit product had been designed on that basis.
Said6 Jun 2019Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held on 6 June 2019
Councillor Hopgood pointed out that the Chair had asked the members if they were happy for the Advisers to ask some questions but she would not like to see questions solely from the Advisers. She thought members should be prompted to ask the questions.
Said6 Jun 2019Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held on 6 June 2019
Referring to matters arising, Councillor Hopgood said that last time the board had discussed Border to Coast representation and a report was circulated for information. She asked that the report should be included on the agenda for future meetings.
Said6 Jun 2019Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held on 6 June 2019
Bryan Smith explained that the main business should be reported to the Pension Fund Committee however, Councillor Hopgood said that this was for information for the scheme members.
Said6 Jun 2019Local Pension Board
Review Training Approach - Verbal Update
Councillor Hopgood suggested that this be deferred until September when new members were in post.
Said6 Jun 2019Local Pension Board
Any Other Business
Councillor Hopgood added that it would have to be proven that you had been negligent and therefore she did not see any cause for concern. Bryan Smith would look into this and report back.
Named14 Mar 2019Local Pension Board
Local Pension Board Membership
Councillor Amanda Hopgood, Ian Densham and Neville Hancock confirmed that they wished to extend their terms of office, and Geoff Sykes advised that his membership would end on 26 June 2019.
Said14 Mar 2019Local Pension Board
Communications Review
Councillor Hopgood stated that a single web-based facility would be beneficial and would reduce the existing costs of communication with employers and members.
Named6 Dec 2018Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held on 6 December 2018
Ian Densham , Neville Hancock and Councillor Hopgood were in attendance at the Pension Fund Committee and provided observations from the meeting.
Said6 Dec 2018Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held on 6 December 2018
Councillor Hopgood advised that in the move towards pooling there would be a need to make decisions which may not fit with the Committee’s cycle of meetings. It had been suggested that the Committee delegates decisions to the Corporate Director in consultation with the Chair and Vice-Chair of the Committee, but both the Chair and Vice-Chair did not feel that this would be appropriate.
Said6 Dec 2018Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held on 6 December 2018
Councillor Hopgood suggested that a small Sub-Committee be set up by the Committee who would be authorised to make decisions between meetings of the full Committee.
Named6 Dec 2018Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held on 6 December 2018
Ian Densham concurred with Councillor Hopgood and stressed the importance of the Committee process keeping pace with the decisions required as pooling progressed, and to ensure that the Fund was not rushed into decisions regarding asset allocation. The establishment of a Sub-Committee was proposed by the Board. Beverley White stated that there may be a Special meeting of the Pension Fund Committee called in January 2019 to discuss the asset allocation to the BCPP which could also consider setting up a Sub-Committee.
Said6 Dec 2018Local Pension Board
Pensions Regulator – Code of Practice for Public Service Pension Schemes – Gap Analysis
Councillor Hopgood noted that the Code of Practice required Board Members to be conversant with relevant scheme documents, and that easier access to documents was identified as an action. The Member asked if it would be possible to have a single link to all relevant documents which members could access on their devices.
Said6 Dec 2018Local Pension Board
Training
Councillor Hopgood suggested that Paul Cooper be asked to review the forms and consider if there were other training requirements not already identified. Paul Cooper confirmed that self-assessment was a key tool for examining training needs.
Named14 Jun 2018Local Pension Board
Election of Chair
AGREED that Councillor Amanda Hopgood be elected Chair of the Local Pension Board for the ensuing year.
Named14 Jun 2018Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held on 14 June 2018
Ian Densham, Neville Hancock and Councillor Hopgood (for part of the meeting) were in attendance at the Pension Fund Committee and provided observations.
Named7 Dec 2017Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held on 7 December 2017
Ian Densham, Councillor Hopgood and Neville Hancock were in attendance at the Pension Fund Committee and provided observations from the meeting.
Said7 Dec 2017Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held on 7 December 2017
Councillor Hopgood expressed concern about the length of time the Investment Managers had for their presentation to the Committee due the volume of business to be conducted in the time available. The Board had made the recommendation previously that the Committee should plan and allow for sufficient time for questioning of the Managers and if necessary start the meeting earlier or invite the Managers following a lunch break. The Committee had decided that as there were a number of new Members, and as reporting practices would change with the implementation of pooling, it would be premature to consider changing existing arrangements.
Named7 Dec 2017Local Pension Board
Training
Councillor Hopgood had attended.
Asked7 Dec 2017Local Pension Board
Work Plan - Pensions Regulator - Code of Practice for Public Service Pension Schemes - Gap Analysis
Councillor Hopgood asked that an update on progress of those areas that were not compliant be given at each meeting.
Asked7 Dec 2017Local Pension Board
Any Other Business
a) Data Protection – General Data Protection Regulations GDPR Councillor Hopgood asked if the Board would need to consider the proposed changes to the data protection legislation. Nick Orton advised that Officers would review current practices to ensure compliance and report to the Committee if necessary.
Named7 Sep 2017Local Pension Board
Training
Board Members Councillor Hopgood and Geoff Sykes had registered to attend, together with Councillors J Carr and J Atkinson of the Pension Fund Committee.
Named7 Sep 2017Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held on 7 September 2017
Councillor Amanda Hopgood was in attendance at the Pension Fund Committee and provided observations from the meeting.
Named7 Sep 2017Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee held on 7 September 2017
With regard to the report by the Independent Adviser in connection with proposed changes to the Investment Strategy, Councillor Hopgood was pleased to note that the Committee had identified the need to have an in-depth training session on private markets and equity protection in order to give Members full knowledge and understanding of the matter before reaching a decision.
Named12 Sep 2016Local Pension Board
Any Other Business - Local Pension Board Vacancy - Scheme Employer Representative
Councillor Hopgood had agreed to sit on the Panel to shortlist and interview applicants who met the essential criteria. Shortlisting would take place on 16 September 2016 with interviews scheduled for 23 September 2016.
Named13 Jul 2016Local Pension Board
Election of Chair
AGREED that Councillor A Hopgood be elected Chair of the Board for the ensuing year.
Said3 Mar 2016Local Pension Board
Observations from Pension Fund Committee
Councillor Hopgood suggested that there should be a standard item at each Pension Fund Committee to report any matters from the Local Pension Board in writing and that it would be useful for Pension Fund Committee Members to receive minutes of the Board meetings.
Named15 Dec 2015Local Pension Board
LGPS Pooling
Councillor Hopgood and Ian Densham expressed concern at the tight timescale for responding to the consultation which had not allowed the Committee to agree a response. They were of the view that the report to Pension Fund Committee should have included an option to call a Special meeting. They considered that a response should be agreed by the Committee as a whole and not under delegated authority to the Corporate Director in consultation with the Chairman and Vice-Chairman.
Named10 Sep 2015Local Pension Board
Declarations of Interest
Councillor Hopgood was asked to complete a declaration of interest form as a newly appointed member of the Board, and was provided with a Code of Conflict Policy and the training slides circulated at the last meeting. The Member advised that she was a Director of an Academy where non-teaching staff were members of the Pension Scheme. Again Bryan Smith advised that it was unlikely that this would conflict with her role but that she should declare an interest if a matter relating to the Academy was considered by the Board.
Named10 Sep 2015Local Pension Board
Work Plan
Councillor Hopgood viewed the role of the Local Pension Board as being similar to that of a Scrutiny Committee. She considered that the biggest challenge for the Pension Fund Committee was how effectively it challenged the Investment Managers. To do this it was necessary for Pension Fund Committee Members to have an understanding of how the Fund was allocated across the different classes and that these were explained (bonds/gilts/equities etc ), as it was a complex area to understand.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.